RE: [PATCH] doc/pts: Add OPP PTS 6.2 results for Linux

[Gowtham Anandha Babu <gowtham.ab@samsung.com>]

Hi Szymon,

> -----Original Message-----
> From: linux-bluetooth-owner@vger.kernel.org [mailto:linux-bluetooth-
> owner@vger.kernel.org] On Behalf Of Szymon Janc
> Sent: Thursday, July 30, 2015 8:12 PM
> To: Gowtham Anandha Babu
> Cc: linux-bluetooth@vger.kernel.org; bharat.panda@samsung.com
> Subject: Re: [PATCH] doc/pts: Add OPP PTS 6.2 results for Linux
> 
> Hi Gowtham,
> 
> On Thursday 30 of July 2015 15:38:08 Gowtham Anandha Babu wrote:
> > This patch adds test case list and results for OPP profile tested
> > against Linux-kernel-4.1.0.
> > ---
> >  doc/pics-opp.txt  | 187
> > ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
> doc/pixit-opp.t
> > ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ xt |
> > 27 ++++++++
> >  doc/pts-opp.txt   | 120 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
> >  3 files changed, 334 insertions(+)
> >  create mode 100644 doc/pics-opp.txt
> >  create mode 100644 doc/pixit-opp.txt
> >  create mode 100644 doc/pts-opp.txt
> 
> As mentioned on IRC, those files should be added to EXTRA_DIST in
> Makefile.am.
> 

I have raised v1 for the same. Please have a look at it.

> >
> > diff --git a/doc/pics-opp.txt b/doc/pics-opp.txt new file mode 100644
> > index 0000000..f3bd0aa
> > --- /dev/null
> > +++ b/doc/pics-opp.txt
> > @@ -0,0 +1,187 @@
> > +OPP PICS for the PTS tool.
> > +
> > +PTS version: 6.2.0
> > +
> > +* - different than PTS defaults
> > +# - not yet implemented/supported
> > +
> > +M - mandatory
> > +O - optional
> > +
> > +		Roles
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +Parameter Name	Selected	Description
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +TSPC_OPP_1_1	True (*)	Role: Object Push Client (C.1)
> > +TSPC_OPP_1_2	True (*)	Role: Object Push Server (C.1)
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +C.1: Mandatory to support at least one of the defined roles.
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +
> > +
> > +		Client Profile Version
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +Parameter Name	Selected	Description
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +TSPC_OPP_1b_1	False		Client supports OPP version
> 1.1. (C.1)
> > +TSPC_OPP_1b_2	True (*)	Client supports OPP version 1.2.
(C.1)
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +C.1: It is mandatory to support at least one of the profile
versions.
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +-----
> > ----- +
> > +
> > +		Client Application Features
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +Parameter Name	Selected	Description
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +TSPC_OPP_2_1	True		Client: Perform Service Discovery
> request
> (M)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_2	True		Client: Authentication/PIN exchange
> supported.
> > +					(M)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_2a	True (*)	Client: Require Authentication/PIN
by
> default.
> > +					(O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_3	True		Client: Object Push (M)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_4	True (*)	Client: vCard 2.1 (C.3)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_5	False		Client: vCalender 1.0 (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_6	False		Client: vMsg as defined in IrMC 1.1
> (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_7	False		Client: vNote as defined in IrMC 1.1
> (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_8	True (*)	Client: Support content formats
other
> than those
> > +					declared in TSPC_OPP_2_4 through
> > +					TSPC_OPP_2_7. (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_8a	False		Client: Support specific set of
other
> content
> > +					formats. (C.4)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_8b	True (*)	Client: Support all content formats.
> (C.4)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_9	True (*)	Client: Push multiple vCard objects.
> (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_9a	True (*)	Client: Push multiple vCard objects
> using
> > +					different PUT operations. (C.5)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_9b	False		Client: Push multiple vCard objects
> using the
> > +					same PUT operation. (C.5)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_10	True (*)	Client: Push multiple vCalender
> objects. (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_10a	True		Client: Push multiple vCalendar
> objects using
> > +					different PUT operations. (C.6)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_10b	False		Client: Push multiple vCalendar
> objects using
> > +					the same PUT operation. (C.6)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_11	True (*)	Client: Push multiple vMsg objects.
> (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_11a	True (*)	Client: Push multiple vMsg objects
> using
> > +					different PUT operations. (C.7)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_11b	False		Client: Push multiple vMsg objects
> using the
> > +					same PUT operation. (C.7)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_12	True (*)	Client: Push multiple vNote objects.
> (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_12a	True (*)	Client: Push multiple vNote objects
> using
> > +					different PUT operations. (C.8)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_12b	False		Client: Push multiple vNote objects
> using the
> > +					same PUT operation. (C.8)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_13	True (*)	Client: Pull business card (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_14	True (*)	Client: vCard 2.1 (C.1)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_15	True (*)	Client: Exchange business card (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_16	False		Client: vCard 2.1 (C.2)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_17	True (*)	GOEP v2 (C.9)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_18	True (*)	GOEP v2 Backward Compability (C.9)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_19	True (*)	OBEX over L2CAP (C.9)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_20	False		OBEX Reliable Session (C.10)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_21	False		OBEX SRM (C.10)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_22	False		Send OBEX SRMP header (C.10)
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_23	False		Receive OBEX SRMP header (C.11)
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +C.1: Mandatory to Support IF (TSPC_OPP_2_13) Business Card Pull
> > is supported. +C.2: Mandatory to Support IF (TSPC_OPP_2_15) Business
> Card
> > Exchange is +	supported.
> > +C.3: vCard 2.1 support is required for devices containing phonebook
> > +	applications. vCard 2.1 support optional for other devices.
> > +C.4: Mandatory to support one of TSPC_OPP_2_8a or TSPC_OPP_2_8b if
> > TSPC_OPP_2_8 +	is supported. Otherwise, both items are excluded.
> > +C.5: Mandatory to support at least one of TSPC_OPP_2_9a and
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_9b
> > if +	TSPC_OPP_2_9 is supported. Otherwise, both items are
excluded.
> > +C.6: Mandatory to support at least one of TSPC_OPP_2_10a and
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_10b
> > if +	TSPC_OPP_2_10 is supported. Otherwise, both items are
excluded.
> > +C.7: Mandatory to support at least one of TSPC_OPP_2_11a and
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_11b
> > if +	TSPC_OPP_2_11 is supported. Otherwise, both items are
excluded.
> > +C.8: Mandatory to support at least one of TSPC_OPP_2_12a and
> > +TSPC_OPP_2_12b
> > if +	TSPC_OPP_2_12 is supported. Otherwise, both items are
excluded.
> > +C.9: Mandatory if TSPC_OPP_1b_2 supported.
> > +C.10: Optional to support if TSPC_OPP_1b_2 supported else excluded.
> > +C.11: Mandatory if TSPC_OPP_17 and TSPC_OPP_21 supported else
> excluded.
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +
> > +
> > +		Server Profile Version
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +Parameter Name	Selected	Description
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +TSPC_OPP_2b_1	False		Server supports OPP version
> 1.1.
> > +TSPC_OPP_2b_2	True (*)	Server supports OPP version 1.2.
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +C.1: It is mandatory to support at least one of the profile
versions.
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +-----
> > ----- +
> > +
> > +		Server Application Features
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +Parameter Name	Selected	Description
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +TSPC_OPP_3_1	True		Server: Provide information on
> supported
> > +					contents type on service discovery
> > +					request. (M)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_2	True		Server: Authentication/PIN exchange
> supported.
> > +					(M)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_3	True		Server: Object Push (M)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_3a	True (*)	Server: Receive multiple objects in
> the same
> > +					PUT operation. (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_4	True (*)	Server: vCard 2.1 (C.3)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_5	False		Server: vCalender 1.0 format (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_6	False		Server: vMsg as defined in IrMC 1.1
> (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_7	False		Server: vNote as defined in IrMC 1.1
> (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_8	True (*)	Server: Support content formats
> other than those
> > +					declared in TSPC_OPP_3_4 through
> > +					TSPC_OPP_3_7. (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_8a	False		Server: Support specific set of
other
> content
> > +					formats. (C.4)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_8b	True (*)	Server: Support all content formats.
> (C.4)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_9	True (*)	Server: Object Push vCard reject.
(O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_10	True (*)	Server: Object Push vCal reject. (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_11	True (*)	Server: Object Push vMsg reject. (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_12	True (*)	Server: Object Push vNote reject.
(O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_13	True (*)	Server: Business card pull (O.1)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_14	True (*)	Server: vCard 2.1 (C.1)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_15	True (*)	Server: Business card pull reject.
(O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_16	True (*)	Server: Business card exchange (O.2)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_17	True (*)	Server: vCard 2.1 (C.2)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_18	True (*)	Server: Business card exchange
> reject. (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_19	True (*)	GOEP v2 (C.5)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_20	True (*)	GOEP v2 Backward Compability (C.5)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_21	True (*)	OBEX over L2CAP (C.5)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_22	False		OBEX Reliable Session (C.16)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_23	False		OBEX SRM (C.6)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_24	False		Send OBEX SRMP header (C.6)
> > +TSPC_OPP_3_25	False		Receive OBEX SRMP header (C.7)
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +O.1: IF NOT Supported, an error message must be sent on request
for
> > Business +	Card Pull.
> > +O.2: IF NOT Supported, an error message must be sent on request for
> > Business +	Card Exchange.
> > +C.1: Mandatory to Support IF (TSPC_OPP_3_13) Business Card Pull is
> > supported. +C.2: Mandatory to Support IF (TSPC_OPP_3_16) Business Card
> > Exchange is +	supported.
> > +C.3: vCard 2.1 support is required for devices containing phonebook
> > +	applications. vCard 2.1 support optional for other devices.
> > +C.4: Mandatory to support one of TSPC_OPP_3_8a or TSPC_OPP_3_8b if
> > TSPC_OPP_3_8 +	is supported. Otherwise, both items are excluded.
> > +C.5: Mandatory if TSPC_OPP_2b_2 supported.
> > +C.6: Optional to support if TSPC_OPP_2b_2 supported, else excluded.
> > +C.7: Mandatory if TSPC_OPP_3_19 and TSPC_OPP_3_23 supported else
> excluded.
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +
> > +
> > +		Additional OPP Capabilities
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +Parameter Name	Selected	Description
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +TSPC_OPP_4_1	False		Abort-Push Operation (O)
> > +TSPC_OPP_4_2	False		Intentionally Left Blank (N/A)
> > +TSPC_OPP_4_3	True (*)	Multiple vCards transferred as a
> single vObject
> > +					(C.1)
> > +TSPC_OPP_4_4	True (*)	Multiple vCards transfer (C.1)
> > +TSPC_OPP_4_5	True (*)	vCards with multiple Phone Number
> Fields (C.1)
> > +TSPC_OPP_4_6	True (*)	Push vCal to Different Time Zone
> Server (C.1)
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +C.1: Optional if TSPC_OPP_1_2 is supported, otherwise excluded.
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- diff --git a/doc/pixit-opp.txt b/doc/pixit-opp.txt new file mode
> > 100644 index 0000000..b7461d6
> > --- /dev/null
> > +++ b/doc/pixit-opp.txt
> > @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
> > +OPP PIXIT for the PTS tool.
> > +
> > +PTS version: 6.2.0
> > +
> > +* - different than PTS defaults
> > +& - should be set to IUT Bluetooth address
> > +
> > +		Required PIXIT settings
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +Parameter Name
Value
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +TSPX_supported_extension				bmp
> > +TSPX_unsupported_extension				pts
> > +TSPX_client_class_of_device				100104
> > +TSPX_server_class_of_device				100104
> > +TSPX_auth_password					0000
> > +TSPX_auth_user_id					PTS
> > +TSPX_l2cap_psm						1003
> > +TSPX_rfcomm_channel					8
> > +TSPX_no_confirmations					FALSE
> > +TSPX_bd_addr_iut					112233445566 (*&)
> > +TSPX_delete_link_key					FALSE
> > +TSPX_pin_code						0000
> > +TSPX_security_enabled					FALSE
> > +TSPX_time_guard						300000
> > +TSPX_use_implicit_send					TRUE
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- diff --git a/doc/pts-opp.txt b/doc/pts-opp.txt new file mode
> > 100644 index 0000000..211e37f
> > --- /dev/null
> > +++ b/doc/pts-opp.txt
> > @@ -0,0 +1,120 @@
> > +PTS test results for OPP
> > +
> > +PTS version: 6.2.0
> > +Tested: 30-Jul-2015
> > +Kernel version: 4.1.0
> > +
> > +Results:
> > +PASS	test passed
> > +FAIL	test failed
> > +INC	test is inconclusive
> > +N/A	test is disabled due to PICS setup
> > +NONE	test result is none
> > +
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +Test Name		Result	Notes
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ---- +TC_CLIENT_BC_BV_02_I	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_BC_BV_04_I	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_BCE_BV_01_I   PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_BCE_BV_03_I   N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_BCE_BV_04_I   PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_BCE_BV_05_I   PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_BCE_BV_06_I   PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_BCE_BV_07_I   PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_BCP_BV_01_I   PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_BCP_BV_02_I   PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_BCP_BV_03_I   N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_BCP_BV_04_I   PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_BCP_BV_05_I   PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_CON_BV_01_C	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BI_01_C	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_01_I	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_02_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_03_I	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_04_I	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_05_I	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_07_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_08_I	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_09_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_10_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_11_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_12_I	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_13_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_14_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_15_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_16_I	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_17_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_18_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_19_I	PASS	Send file other than vCard
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_20_I	PASS
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_22_I	PASS	Send file greater than 2 MB
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_23_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_24_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_25_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_26_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_SRM_BV_01_C	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_SRM_BV_03_C	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_SRM_BV_05_C	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_SRM_BV_07_C	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_SRMP_BI_01_C	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_SRMP_BV_01_C	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_SRMP_BV_04_C	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_SRMP_BV_05_C	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_SRMP_BV_06_C	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_BC_BV_01_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_BC_BV_03_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_BCE_BV_01_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_BCE_BV_03_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_BCE_BV_04_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_BCE_BV_05_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_BCE_BV_06_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_BCE_BV_07_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_BCP_BV_01_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_BCP_BV_02_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_BCP_BV_03_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_BCP_BV_04_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_BCP_BV_05_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_CON_BV_02_C	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_01_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_02_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_03_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_04_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_05_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_07_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_08_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_09_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_10_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_11_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_12_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_13_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_14_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_15_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_16_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_17_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_18_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_19_I	INC	PTS issue #13842
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_21_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_22_I	INC	PTS issue #13842
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_23_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_24_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_25_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_26_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_ROB_BV_01_C	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_ROB_BV_02_C	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_SRM_BI_02_C	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_SRM_BI_03_C	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_SRM_BI_05_C	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_SRM_BV_04_C	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_SRM_BV_08_C	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_SRMP_BV_02_C	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_SRMP_BV_03_C	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_27_I	N/A
> > +TC_CLIENT_OPH_BV_34_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_27_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_30_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_31_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_32_I	PASS
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_33_I	N/A
> > +TC_SERVER_OPH_BV_34_I	PASS
> > +---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > +------
> > ----
> 
> --
> BR
> Szymon Janc
> --

Regards,
Gowtham Anandha Babu