Re: [PATCH][ATM] use rtnl_{lock,unlock} during device operations (take 2)

[Duncan Sands <baldrick@wanadoo.fr>]

> btw, you might get async device 'releases' more often than
> you would like.  some atm devices are usb and could be
> unplugged during operation (yes, that's really bad but it
> would be wise to be prepared for this.)  i actually have
> a cardbus atm interface.  i might eject it accidentally.

Right.  In the speedtouch (USB ATM DSL modem) driver, when the
device is unplugged I would have liked to be able to say to the
ATM layer: I've gone, don't call me any more.  But since there
is no way to do this, instead I do:

- refuse to open any more vccs; fail all attempts to send packets
- call shutdown_atm_dev.  This means that when the last vcc is
closed, atm_dev_close will be called in my driver.
- really shutdown in atm_dev_close

In practice that means that the vcc remains open until pppd realises
that the connection has gone down (no more echo requests getting
through, for example).  Maybe I should push a NULL skb down into
each vcc to get it to close?

Another thing: if the modem is plugged in again, and pppd relaunched,
it would be nice if connections that were open when the modem was
unplugged automagically recovered.  Is that possible?

Ciao,

Duncan.