From: Jan Hetges <tran@ms20.net>
To: The list for a Better Approach To Mobile Ad-hoc Networking
<b.a.t.m.a.n@open-mesh.net>
Subject: Re: [B.A.T.M.A.N.] two-radio nodes and alternative next hop
Date: Wed, 23 Apr 2008 17:02:33 -0600 [thread overview]
Message-ID: <20080423230233.GA20235@apoderado.ometepe.net> (raw)
In-Reply-To: <200804230954.37620.axel@open-mesh.net>
[-- Attachment #1.1: Type: text/plain, Size: 2726 bytes --]
Hi Axel
thanks for being stubborn :-)
On Wed, Apr 23, 2008 at 09:54:37AM +0200, Axel Neumann wrote:
> > > But according to the debug output there is a direct link to x.x.4.165/24
> > > (which I guess has broadcast address of x.x.4.255) and therefore the two
> > > interfaces should not see each other!!??
> >
> > there are direct links always only in the according /24 netrange,
> > because they are on different channels/ssids, so .3.160 and .4.1 cannot
> > "see" each other.
> > Note, NO .4.x node cannot see ANY .3.x node, even if they
> > would be on the same channel/ssid!
ok, .4.165 can see .3.160
> Are you also specifying the bssid? Because in order to define different
> cells in an ad-hoc network the ssid is almost useless in most adhoc
> implementations. THe BSSID is much more important!
> (E.g. use kamikaze-etc/config/wireless style: option bssid 44:ca:ff:ee:ba:be
> or the command-line-style: iwconfig wlan0 ap 44:ca:ff:ee:ba:be )
thanks, did'nt know that ^^
>
> Anyway, you mean a debug output on 3.16 like the following can not be correct?
> Neighbor outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld rid sid ) [ viaIF RTQ RQ TQ]..
> 172.19.4.165 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.165 55 ( 84 0:00:28:03 9777 1 1 4 ) [ wlan0:bmx 46 76 60]
did'nt see that ^^^^^
>
> Sorry for being stubborn: what makes you so sure that they cannot see each
> other or that the driver does not mix things up?
>
> At least from the madwifi driver (in ad-hoc mode) I know that it tends to
> ignore its assigned *bssid* and channel and switches back and forth between the
> assigned one and others.
>
> Sometimes the driver hangs on a wrong bssid and
> channel, forwards the wrong IP packets, and cannot receive any packets from
> its originally assigned bssid/channel.
>
> One way to verify this would be to run a tcpdump on interface 3.160/wlan0 and
> see if it ever tracks a batman packet with a src address of e.g. 172.19.4.165
ok, what happend: .4.165 (i386/prism2.5/hostap(-pci)) switched for some
unknown reason to .3.x/channel/essid (which explains the poor link from
.4.165 to ".4.1"(actually .3.160), and i thought it was a fast growing Guahumo tree :).
So i fixed the bssids on both, .4.1 and .4.165. And it seems to not
switch anymore... thanks for being so stubborn :-)
But that doesn't change the fact, that .4.1 still shows .4.162 as
alternativeNextHop to .3.x, where, in fact, all alternative paths inside
.4.x to .3.x lead back to .4.1 !
> > i'll make some more logs when .3.137 is back up
still down, anyways, i attach -cbd8 from .4.1, .4.160, .4.162 and .4.165
cheers
--Jan
[-- Attachment #1.2: 4.1.log --]
[-- Type: text/plain, Size: 3158 bytes --]
WARNING: You are using BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972 (compatibility version 10) !
BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972, IF wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.160, LinkWindowSize 50, PathWindSize 100, OGI 1000ms, currSeqno 10045, UT 19:20:37:09, CPU 34/1000
Neighbor outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld rid sid ) [ viaIF RTQ RQ TQ]..
172.19.3.1 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 79 ( 100 13:05:47:05 53771 0 6 5 ) [ wlan0:bmx 90 100 90]
172.19.4.165 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.165 100 ( 100 0:10:25:17 45516 0 1 1 ) [ wlan1:bmx 98 98 100]
172.19.4.162 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.162 97 ( 100 0:10:25:01 471 0 1 2 ) [ wlan1:bmx 92 92 100]
172.19.4.161 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.161 96 ( 100 0:10:24:51 14469 1 1 3 ) [ wlan1:bmx 92 98 92]
172.19.4.160 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.160 98 ( 100 0:10:24:50 48895 0 2 4 ) [ wlan1:bmx 92 96 94]
Originator outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld pws ogi cpu hop change ) alternativeNextHops brc ...
172.19.3.131 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 78 ( 97 0:16:56:07 16669 0 100 1003 10 2 1 ) 172.19.4.162 28
172.19.3.134 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 78 ( 92 0:02:06:04 30506 0 100 1001 7 3 1 ) 172.19.4.162 66
172.19.3.130 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 68 ( 88 1:07:12:16 49397 0 100 972 6 2 17 ) 172.19.4.162 59
172.19.3.133 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 72 ( 90 0:07:51:30 48541 0 100 1004 1 2 1 ) 172.19.4.162 63
172.19.4.161 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.161 96 ( 100 0:10:24:51 14469 1 100 1004 5 1 1 ) 172.19.4.162 43
172.19.4.160 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.160 98 ( 100 0:10:24:50 48895 0 100 1011 7 1 94 ) 172.19.4.162 92
172.19.3.141 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 72 ( 91 0:10:24:04 1018 0 100 952 34 3 1 ) 172.19.4.162 59
172.19.4.162 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.162 97 ( 100 0:10:25:01 471 0 100 996 21 1 855 ) 172.19.4.160 90
172.19.3.128 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 77 ( 90 1:07:12:17 748 1 100 974 13 2 13 ) 172.19.4.162 56
172.19.3.1 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 79 ( 100 13:05:47:05 53771 0 100 1023 42 1 37 ) 172.19.4.162 65
172.19.0.4 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 78 ( 96 0:08:27:17 51735 0 100 1005 28 3 1 ) 172.19.4.162 69
172.19.0.2 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 79 ( 95 0:07:57:04 14754 0 100 996 6 2 1 ) 172.19.4.162 65
172.19.4.165 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.165 100 ( 100 0:10:25:17 45516 0 100 995 29 1 3 ) 172.19.4.162 85
172.19.3.136 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 76 ( 87 0:10:24:02 41807 0 100 992 26 3 1 ) 172.19.4.162 30
172.19.3.135 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 68 ( 85 0:02:36:56 62915 0 100 986 36 4 1 ) 172.19.4.162 56
15 known Originator(s), averages: 81 ( 94 0 100 994 18 2 68 )
Originator Announced networks HNAs: moved to debug level 9...
Originator Announced services ip:port:seqno ... see debug level 7
[-- Attachment #1.3: 4.160.log --]
[-- Type: text/plain, Size: 2633 bytes --]
WARNING: You are using BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972 (compatibility version 10) !
BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972, IF eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160, LinkWindowSize 50, PathWindSize 100, OGI 1000ms, currSeqno 48894, UT 0:10:24:51, CPU 7/1000
Neighbor outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld rid sid ) [ viaIF RTQ RQ TQ]..
172.19.4.162 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.162 99 ( 100 0:10:24:49 468 0 2 1 ) [ eth1:bmx 100 100 100]
172.19.4.1 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 99 ( 100 0:10:24:49 10040 0 4 2 ) [ eth1:bmx 96 100 96]
Originator outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld pws ogi cpu hop change ) alternativeNextHops brc ...
172.19.3.131 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 73 ( 76 0:10:24:49 16666 0 100 994 10 3 8 ) 172.19.4.162 42
172.19.3.134 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 78 ( 80 0:02:06:01 30502 1 100 992 0 4 1 )
172.19.3.130 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 68 ( 69 0:10:24:49 49391 4 100 985 20 3 2 ) 172.19.4.162 0
172.19.3.133 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 71 ( 73 0:07:51:28 48538 0 100 1019 3 3 11 )
172.19.4.161 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 89 ( 96 0:10:24:49 14467 0 100 1010 15 2 13 ) 172.19.4.162 33
172.19.3.160 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 96 ( 100 0:10:24:49 10040 0 100 1003 29 1 3 )
172.19.3.141 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 70 ( 71 0:10:24:03 1016 0 100 952 37 4 9 )
172.19.4.162 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.162 99 ( 100 0:10:24:49 468 0 100 1002 14 1 53 ) 172.19.4.1 87
172.19.3.128 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 75 ( 77 0:10:24:49 746 0 100 983 13 3 8 ) 172.19.4.162 12
172.19.3.1 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 75 ( 79 0:10:24:49 53769 0 100 1007 42 2 9 )
172.19.0.4 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 76 ( 77 0:08:27:15 51732 0 100 1008 32 4 11 )
172.19.0.2 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 74 ( 79 0:07:57:02 14751 0 100 1002 11 3 1 )
172.19.4.165 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 99 ( 100 0:10:24:48 45513 0 100 1001 21 2 15 )
172.19.3.136 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 73 ( 74 0:10:24:01 41804 0 100 968 26 4 15 ) 172.19.4.162 36
172.19.3.135 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 64 ( 66 0:02:36:53 62912 1 100 1003 35 5 3 )
15 known Originator(s), averages: 78 ( 81 0 100 995 20 2 10 )
Originator Announced networks HNAs: moved to debug level 9...
Originator Announced services ip:port:seqno ... see debug level 7
[-- Attachment #1.4: 4.162.log --]
[-- Type: text/plain, Size: 3226 bytes --]
WARNING: You are using BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972 (compatibility version 10) !
BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972, IF eth1:bmx 172.19.4.162, LinkWindowSize 50, PathWindSize 100, OGI 1000ms, currSeqno 470, UT 0:10:25:00, CPU 14/1000
Neighbor outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld rid sid ) [ viaIF RTQ RQ TQ]..
172.19.4.1 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 90 ( 100 0:10:24:56 10040 0 2 1 ) [ eth1:bmx 92 98 92]
172.19.4.160 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 100 ( 100 0:10:24:47 48892 0 1 2 ) [ eth1:bmx 100 100 100]
172.19.4.165 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 98 ( 100 0:10:24:51 45513 0 2 3 ) [ eth1:bmx 36 74 48]
Originator outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld pws ogi cpu hop change ) alternativeNextHops brc ...
172.19.3.131 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 74 ( 76 0:10:24:54 16666 0 100 994 10 3 401 ) 172.19.4.160 71 172.19.4.165 29
172.19.3.134 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 76 ( 80 0:02:06:00 30502 1 100 992 0 5 58 ) 172.19.4.1 69 172.19.4.165 41
172.19.3.130 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 68 ( 69 0:10:24:55 49391 3 100 984 20 4 428 ) 172.19.4.1 58 172.19.4.165 25
172.19.3.133 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 70 ( 73 0:07:51:26 48538 0 100 1018 3 4 316 ) 172.19.4.1 65 172.19.4.165 27
172.19.4.161 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 88 ( 96 0:10:24:48 14467 0 100 1017 15 2 447 ) 172.19.4.160 87 172.19.4.165 43
172.19.3.160 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 95 ( 100 0:10:24:54 10040 0 100 1003 29 2 360 ) 172.19.4.1 88 172.19.4.165 42
172.19.4.160 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 100 ( 100 0:10:24:47 48892 0 100 1028 10 1 29 ) 172.19.4.165 25 172.19.4.1 88
172.19.3.141 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 70 ( 71 0:10:24:00 1016 0 100 951 37 5 380 ) 172.19.4.1 59 172.19.4.165 28
172.19.3.128 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 74 ( 77 0:10:24:55 746 0 100 982 13 3 397 ) 172.19.4.160 72 172.19.4.165 29
172.19.3.1 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 74 ( 79 0:10:24:54 53769 0 100 1016 42 3 364 ) 172.19.4.1 71 172.19.4.165 28
172.19.0.4 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 74 ( 77 0:08:27:12 51732 0 100 1008 32 5 254 ) 172.19.4.1 71 172.19.4.165 31
172.19.0.2 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 73 ( 79 0:07:57:00 14751 0 100 999 11 4 327 ) 172.19.4.1 71 172.19.4.165 29
172.19.4.165 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 98 ( 100 0:10:24:51 45513 0 100 991 21 3 384 ) 172.19.4.1 96 172.19.4.165 36
172.19.3.136 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 73 ( 74 0:10:23:59 41804 0 100 968 26 4 355 ) 172.19.4.160 71 172.19.4.165 29
172.19.3.135 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 61 ( 66 0:02:36:51 62912 0 100 996 35 6 72 ) 172.19.4.1 58 172.19.4.165 33
15 known Originator(s), averages: 77 ( 81 0 100 996 20 3 304 )
Originator Announced networks HNAs: moved to debug level 9...
Originator Announced services ip:port:seqno ... see debug level 7
[-- Attachment #1.5: 4.165.log --]
[-- Type: text/plain, Size: 2815 bytes --]
WARNING: You are using BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972 (compatibility version 10) !
BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972, IF wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.165, LinkWindowSize 50, PathWindSize 100, OGI 1000ms, currSeqno 45513, UT 0:10:25:14, CPU 21/1000
Neighbor outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld rid sid ) [ viaIF RTQ RQ TQ]..
172.19.4.1 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 100 ( 100 0:10:20:14 10038 0 1 1 ) [ wlan0:bmx 98 100 98]
172.19.4.162 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 94 ( 98 0:10:24:53 466 0 3 2 ) [ wlan0:bmx 36 46 78]
Originator outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld pws ogi cpu hop change ) alternativeNextHops brc ...
172.19.3.131 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 76 ( 76 0:10:25:11 16664 0 100 997 16 3 2 ) 172.19.4.162 36
172.19.3.134 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 79 ( 80 0:02:05:58 30501 0 100 983 0 4 1 ) 172.19.4.162 31
172.19.3.130 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 68 ( 69 0:10:25:11 49391 2 100 983 20 3 2 ) 172.19.4.162 27
172.19.3.133 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 74 ( 74 0:07:51:24 48535 1 100 1021 3 3 1 ) 172.19.4.162 33
172.19.4.161 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 96 ( 96 0:10:24:42 14465 0 100 993 15 2 2 ) 172.19.4.162 39
172.19.3.160 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 100 ( 100 0:10:25:12 10038 0 100 985 29 1 2 ) 172.19.4.162 35
172.19.4.160 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 97 ( 99 0:10:24:43 48890 0 100 1019 10 2 2 ) 172.19.4.162 36
172.19.3.141 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 71 ( 72 0:10:23:45 1014 0 100 960 37 4 2 ) 172.19.4.162 27
172.19.4.162 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 94 ( 98 0:10:24:53 466 0 100 985 14 2 2 ) 172.19.4.162 43
172.19.3.128 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 77 ( 78 0:10:25:09 743 1 100 979 13 3 2 ) 172.19.4.162 25
172.19.3.1 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 80 ( 80 0:10:25:11 53766 1 100 1018 65 2 2 ) 172.19.4.162 29
172.19.0.4 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 78 ( 78 0:08:27:10 51730 0 100 988 32 4 1 ) 172.19.4.162 32
172.19.0.2 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 78 ( 79 0:07:56:57 14749 0 100 1029 11 3 1 ) 172.19.4.162 33
172.19.3.136 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 73 ( 74 0:10:23:54 41802 0 100 994 40 4 2 ) 172.19.4.162 24
172.19.3.135 wlan0:bmx 172.19.4.1 68 ( 68 0:02:36:49 62909 1 100 995 35 5 1 ) 172.19.4.162 17
15 known Originator(s), averages: 80 ( 81 0 100 995 22 3 1 )
Originator Announced networks HNAs: moved to debug level 9...
Originator Announced services ip:port:seqno ... see debug level 7
[-- Attachment #2: Digital signature --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 189 bytes --]
next prev parent reply other threads:[~2008-04-23 23:02 UTC|newest]
Thread overview: 11+ messages / expand[flat|nested] mbox.gz Atom feed top
2008-04-21 12:39 [B.A.T.M.A.N.] two radio nodes and alternative next hop Jan Hetges
2008-04-21 12:57 ` Benjamin Henrion
2008-04-21 20:30 ` [B.A.T.M.A.N.] two-radio " Jan Hetges
2008-04-22 14:01 ` Axel Neumann
2008-04-23 0:04 ` Jan Hetges
2008-04-23 7:54 ` Axel Neumann
2008-04-23 23:02 ` Jan Hetges [this message]
2008-04-24 7:33 ` Axel Neumann
2008-04-24 3:55 ` Jan Hetges
2008-04-24 8:09 ` Axel Neumann
2008-04-21 20:33 ` [B.A.T.M.A.N.] two radio " Jan Hetges
Reply instructions:
You may reply publicly to this message via plain-text email
using any one of the following methods:
* Save the following mbox file, import it into your mail client,
and reply-to-all from there: mbox
Avoid top-posting and favor interleaved quoting:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Interleaved_style
* Reply using the --to, --cc, and --in-reply-to
switches of git-send-email(1):
git send-email \
--in-reply-to=20080423230233.GA20235@apoderado.ometepe.net \
--to=tran@ms20.net \
--cc=b.a.t.m.a.n@open-mesh.net \
/path/to/YOUR_REPLY
https://kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-send-email.html
* If your mail client supports setting the In-Reply-To header
via mailto: links, try the mailto: link
Be sure your reply has a Subject: header at the top and a blank line
before the message body.
This is an external index of several public inboxes,
see mirroring instructions on how to clone and mirror
all data and code used by this external index.