Re: [Patch] mqueue: fix the bad code in sys_mq_open()

[Al Viro <viro@ZenIV.linux.org.uk>]

On Thu, Feb 25, 2010 at 09:40:23PM +0800, Am??rico Wang wrote:
> 
> Fix bad code in ipc/mqueue.c.
> 
> Inspired by Andr?? Goddard Rosa's  patch.
> 
> a) do_create() and do_open() should not release the resources which
>    are not acquired within themselves, it's their caller's work;

Sorry, NAK.  Resources are either consumed by opened file (i.e. struct
file now is the holder of mnt/dentry) or released; in either case,
caller has given them up.  Your variant is broken in its current form
and will be more complicated than existing code if you fix it.

> b) Fix an fd leak;

Fixed by original patch.

> c) The goto label 'out_upsem' doesn't make any sense, rename to
>    'out_unlock';
> 
> d) mntget() should be called before looking up dentry within
>    ->mnt->mnt_root;

Not really, since ->mnt doesn't change (and remains pinned) for the
entire lifetime of ipc_ns.

> e) When dealing with failure case, we should release the resources
>    in a reversed order of acquiring, so reorder the goto labels;
> 
> f) Remove some unused labels due to reorder.

I wouldn't say it's cleaner that way.

Anyway, I've applied the patchset as posted; if you want to do something
else, do that on top of it.  I really object against your (a), the rest
is more or less a matter of taste.  (a) is just plain wrong - we want
uniform behaviour from the caller's POV and it means that mnt/dentry should
always be given up from caller's POV.  Either moved into new struct file,
or dropped.