Re: [PATCH 09/12] Input: synaptics - add image sensor support

["Henrik Rydberg" <rydberg@euromail.se>]

> This should be pretty straightforward:
> 
> 	num_fingers = calc_fingers_from_btn_tool(device); // via EVIOCGKEY
> 	num_slots = get_number_of_slots(device); // EVIOCGABS
> 	num_untracked_contacts = max(num_fingers - num_slots, 0);

Heh, I forgot we _do_ know in advance how many fingers are supported
via BTN_TOOL_*. Ok, no more issues.

> > > Maybe we have different notions of what semi-MT property conveys? For me
> > > semi-MT indicates that the device provides 2 coordinates for bounding
> > > box.  However if semi-MT is not set does not mean that the device
> > > provides true tracking for all contacts, but only for advertised slots.
> > > There still may be additional data transmitted.
> > 
> > Yes, it seems we do have different assumptions here. The more reason
> > to document it further. :-)
> 
> I'll take patches ;)

And thou shalt receive them - some day ;-)

> > To me, it seems we do need a little bit of extra information to
> > determine this new type of device.
> 
> I think we already have all we need (see above).

I concur. So, to conclude:

a) The improved synaptics behavior can be achieved by simply using
MT-B plus BTN_TOOL_*.

b) Userspace should check BTN_TOOL_* for any discrepancies between the
maximum number of available slots (always two in this case) and the
maximum number of fingers reported (BTN_TOOL_TRIPLETAP etc). Extra
actions may then be taken to support more fingers than slots.

c) The semi-mt flag is only used to signal that the two points sent
via MT-B are the corners of a bounding box.

Cheers,
Henrik