From: Jungsub Shin <supsup5642@gmail.com>
To: Al Viro <viro@ZenIV.linux.org.uk>
Cc: "J. R. Okajima" <hooanon05g@gmail.com>,
linux-fsdevel@vger.kernel.org, linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org,
aufs-users@lists.sourceforge.net
Subject: Re: Why is the length of max mount option a page size??
Date: Tue, 29 May 2018 12:57:03 +0900 [thread overview]
Message-ID: <20180529035703.GA32550@supsup-VirtualBox> (raw)
In-Reply-To: <20180529011412.GE30522@ZenIV.linux.org.uk>
On Tue, May 29, 2018 at 02:14:12AM +0100, Al Viro wrote:
> On Tue, May 29, 2018 at 09:24:56AM +0900, Jungsub Shin wrote:
> > Mount command : mount -t aufs -o br=~/tca_agent/container_rw_dir/51509032=rw:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/5a259d94211e449fd466d997b5b0b149cb2997a732fd3a838c14295e0eb93f92=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/faca908333f884648b75738571879df977339ee7615c65410c98001a463bcd00=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/67b50813aedeb67fd06b434163fa64d07fbd16f714196daea1cd139a0171b080=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/28b6f7699be037b7f80dd03b22830712aa75b88ddfbba0910dd059b522fbff20=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/c47c7125efa9172d262c5b3645594010704f67cf44005da9f6d7ea5a5d2a05db=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b91ed1b448ac52d251c785f5cfc299ca3ba4cfd68d739832b766228afa84a651=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0169cd8bc0bdbecedb30c7d995e69e832d7ccd5c435e72c40af6940db87851b7=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/e7ef7d443e31f8b3b8a0a002a6895746d3737289eb2eea18d669924c089279f2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/31bfb0cd724fda09280305b8dc1c4b0587ca01f5dd503d28afa82cff4fa92475=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/74428f0d76521fa9b9b1189cb72d303e367003c113cc8a11db125e3f7df1daa1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b20a927da14045cac0cd6a745f67fdeb88ead6d85752c670ea2773b27387f6ae=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/7dee3bce119631e3c922d78860d6b0ae160e237b63bf19f43713a05d1086c72f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/636bce8f18e8734cb98f170bdcf1fb9ae52f1b091bfadcb2bef378b0d829ceb6=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9c6fde234e701cf7b61534ef3a23cc4e0cdb6d3ffc497feaa8fcddc52e8d1fda=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/83c2f1968a932e3e284ef20b10a4ef8a9cfc01589dacf2100fb9a78e88c3888e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ec096a351601040fcd37c31edccd2f68106438097e8adf7253539366b2232de5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/6de889accecb819028355196bde150749598e982b5dfe556540e102c737bfc34=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1042cb8f2263d1030fdb57e0ca671b34a2180bb35d9448737e4a03e4987cf942=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/4fab8c997a447af2375e325467661ca1d74bf62dc6d802426f20d0134c9c43bc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ca57efb1c28464fab46af1826243c02af0a0b6cfb90bf92b30110e79028c5e68=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ad86d54176611b5117fc155e8dfbd0b59bc0abce4e2051baef12c2f1e152c92f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/f323ae7b264dcc517876e7c722ac3369baaef1a7c18cc5aae5f43f440fd646c0=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a7d1c89c8422563102bd353de46154191038f92c9ebde8b22a8b2749140029ec=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/104adb8634902678f87db6bdbdb12d43d5bd6db9909ae9b12e078286046a1298=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/00450b5308ac99846ae7e5fa47652952c4fbbe82882ac241d5153d630644f790=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/129675caf5fdc1616c619d5b5718417806a64f282d324a3a580d6df1269b4f3f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/8ce8b37ab4829a1fd34fcd38842b912d46eb3f7511365ccec0399a06670ab2fc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/57080e2e0baad381605079107f08435133d7829364a9c450fc08877f01e57601=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9ca225075a8c2bfd27ef5084e41335d781d24e7be0cbf4575ec3d42de662c6ac=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/74ec3835691908f9e6e271797f373257de3f9cc4bb408fd66dd229537ea5fcc1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/59aa8f04c38abaae9c0e430d7b1a91f6560641e429386ee2c4eec57f0af35c04=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/bc318ac48b4f7a9536b72e2b0f223726a5225e13ecc70eba4b7b00e2bf80081b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/bbfb0e8818be82ca0f17f280f7ad89497fef6c92e2bb50c40b2bd17c79347425=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/f36b94436263ce21d885d2f3f94c7b307e966a989fcefd3027c039e987d7dc2b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9103dae307f5748103f89093273329a523300b4f103a1d397c44abd766fe0015=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9bd48cc89c1fc083b0db7ed45e5d7e4fec277450b8b47f96884588930ce8c56f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/47ba0411cc8344ab1895a6b8eb0878a9ffd34410170a140ad1f210f20eedcdce=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/42b317de582399eb395b2818b4d658fb0a5987e8df1163e49ac2d8bec95a078e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/57bb07a87ab6c29b048638c65566febe800fe79672730f7bb9e70b8f2e677e5a=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b89b49aa036df19c6a2e77cc4aaef707ab3fd916d2d936b9e5e160d448d96ab3=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/d7bf931f8235cc7cc68c223b2945f77e858eb8cff4c9cb8bd64bacfd29312672=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/49a8b40dbec97066dbad4fb14d1bf388102190442679527e112b030270426ccc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/05f05d402ea8ee67da1af2c9e35d10b9619b0f0c14a56788a1a0b5eeb290d685=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b05d3f32ac4ff52a542dfcf50dbf155d060d79bd23d0ebed1439a3c6b1120731=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0d061258f32c904c95aa020a9f679790c5722c3017eef98e298d6e29b4f02089=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1f9c07049bcd59c59413c1706d0402b04c96598174eb16ef3de25b4e47413ad2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a86578a8bff61017b80eb653705c3f41136efb9b88facd6a2c67e8b3426e47f9=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/c3fdf4a694f0cc03939ee2cfdd09fb623966c5bb193778eaaea317655773656e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1b8fcd446a37050b55f57687aaae1150d74cc7f4468bbd00942535bad5ab22fe=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/6624cfa732b528cf7c1996719e30d1525aa27af7584f61a149d4d386aa8cf301=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/5b57e87f9b5859d902c4338c7a7ce5996a51fb8226a8f11ab29e10af4af5f14f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0c65112ac5c572a950e2671f903ef11e918e6e3cdbf026edda90db6c7a9c6ef8=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ce16b72d243b82ded684a547da1400b8f2d07ed7b36b114ae0cbe2f20c17b0bf=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a3937b112d7dbedfe075162862e404b7b85803d880589eaf3ebad9855629bdd5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b486d646cd9f5b8151856133ea3e81d53c3664bb727a0a87d0197cbbae9211de=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/de1b712fcfedbc3f61248c1a5fb9cba5a5ab6c7415f2c71c7ea162fd7c738c6f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/2958a858559d3091b8162c066cfe5e17012f2307772180e702ffbc89bcae8fc2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/14eae848ef41eb275ad37cc9d12dc276d3f08beeb06e041407371b9489335ee1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/d72e07c403501a4abefaa80f3b81121392c42f314fc14bbf1bb434dc84457dd5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ee0efde24e35b4e2f801ca25640169ca2f319f9b5d37dbb0917cfd43e818d1f4=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/67dfb4d7c7ce39829d36740e1ef5279e00320a0d2bfe06bb67b6571f1ff47627=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b3a1a69310f719755232ed5f8509f11f549d620d723ea293f001e3d30795108b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a3ed95caeb02ffe68cdd9fd84406680ae93d633cb16422d00e8a7c22955b46d4=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/e5ad7970bc69d2ba62d2bbb4b80627273350e1982ff43bc1ca04a3215bc6da5b=ro+wh none ~/tca_agent/container_root_dir/51509032
> > dmesg : [343090.744067] aufs opt_add:810:mount[30864]: lookup failed /root/tca_agent/image_layer_di (-2)
I think kernel at least must print warning message when mount option
overflow the PAGE_SIZE if length of mount option should be fixed.
When i encouter this problem, i found the reason hard because of
lack of kernel log and wrong infomation.
> > ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> >
> > br option is cut and aufs search cut directory. Length of mount option
> > is about 6400.
>
> The lack of planning on your part...
>
> IOW, don't do it. Use of symlinks (or bindings) might alleviate the problem
> if aufs interface is that nasty. And before you go "just read up to \0",
> consider e.g. NFS flavours with binary data structure passed instead of
> a string.
Do you mean using symlinks or bind mount to reduce length of mount
options?? I can remove "~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir" string. But the
other character means unique ID of layer and i can't compress it or
replace it to another string. This is not fundamental solution. Docker
use the same unique ID to manage layers.
As i said before overlayfs could suffer same problem because overlayfs
support multiple lowerdir options and there is no route to pass lower
dirs without mount option. So i think to support unionfs stably in
kernel, dynamic memory allocation for mount option is needed.
Thanks.
next prev parent reply other threads:[~2018-05-29 4:12 UTC|newest]
Thread overview: 9+ messages / expand[flat|nested] mbox.gz Atom feed top
2018-05-21 17:39 Why is the length of max mount option a page size?? Jungsub Shin
2018-05-25 10:42 ` J. R. Okajima
2018-05-29 0:24 ` Jungsub Shin
2018-05-29 1:14 ` Al Viro
2018-05-29 1:14 ` Al Viro
2018-05-29 3:57 ` Jungsub Shin [this message]
2018-05-30 2:40 ` J. R. Okajima
2018-05-30 23:51 ` Jungsub Shin
2018-05-29 1:14 ` J. R. Okajima
Reply instructions:
You may reply publicly to this message via plain-text email
using any one of the following methods:
* Save the following mbox file, import it into your mail client,
and reply-to-all from there: mbox
Avoid top-posting and favor interleaved quoting:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Interleaved_style
* Reply using the --to, --cc, and --in-reply-to
switches of git-send-email(1):
git send-email \
--in-reply-to=20180529035703.GA32550@supsup-VirtualBox \
--to=supsup5642@gmail.com \
--cc=aufs-users@lists.sourceforge.net \
--cc=hooanon05g@gmail.com \
--cc=linux-fsdevel@vger.kernel.org \
--cc=linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org \
--cc=viro@ZenIV.linux.org.uk \
/path/to/YOUR_REPLY
https://kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-send-email.html
* If your mail client supports setting the In-Reply-To header
via mailto: links, try the mailto: link
Be sure your reply has a Subject: header at the top and a blank line
before the message body.
This is an external index of several public inboxes,
see mirroring instructions on how to clone and mirror
all data and code used by this external index.