Re: [PATCH 00/13] clk: imx: convert from clk round_rate() to determine_rate()

[Peng Fan <peng.fan@oss.nxp.com>]

On Thu, Jul 10, 2025 at 05:10:32PM -0400, Brian Masney wrote:
>The round_rate() clk ops is deprecated in the clk framework in favor
>of the determine_rate() clk ops. The first two patches in this series
>drops the round_rate() function since a determine_rate() function is
>already implemented. The remaining patches convert the drivers using
>the Coccinelle semantic patch posted below. I did a few minor cosmetic
>cleanups of the code in a few cases.
>
>Coccinelle semantic patch:
>
>    virtual patch
>
>    // Look up the current name of the round_rate function
>    @ has_round_rate @
>    identifier round_rate_name =~ ".*_round_rate";
>    identifier hw_param, rate_param, parent_rate_param;
>    @@
>
>    long round_rate_name(struct clk_hw *hw_param, unsigned long rate_param,
>                  unsigned long *parent_rate_param)
>    {
>    	...
>    }
>
>    // Rename the route_rate function name to determine_rate()
>    @ script:python generate_name depends on has_round_rate @
>    round_rate_name << has_round_rate.round_rate_name;
>    new_name;
>    @@
>
>    coccinelle.new_name = round_rate_name.replace("_round_rate", "_determine_rate")
>
>    // Change rate to req->rate; also change occurrences of 'return XXX'.
>    @ chg_rate depends on generate_name @
>    identifier has_round_rate.round_rate_name;
>    identifier has_round_rate.hw_param;
>    identifier has_round_rate.rate_param;
>    identifier has_round_rate.parent_rate_param;
>    identifier ERR =~ "E.*";
>    expression E;
>    @@
>
>    long round_rate_name(struct clk_hw *hw_param, unsigned long rate_param,
>                  unsigned long *parent_rate_param)
>    {
>    <...
>    (
>    -return -ERR;
>    +return -ERR;
>    |
>    - return rate_param;
>    + return 0;
>    |
>    - return E;
>    + req->rate = E;
>    +
>    + return 0;
>    |
>    - rate_param
>    + req->rate
>    )
>    ...>
>    }
>
>    // Coccinelle only transforms the first occurrence of the rate parameter
>    // Run a second time. FIXME: Is there a better way to do this?
>    @ chg_rate2 depends on generate_name @
>    identifier has_round_rate.round_rate_name;
>    identifier has_round_rate.hw_param;
>    identifier has_round_rate.rate_param;
>    identifier has_round_rate.parent_rate_param;
>    @@
>
>    long round_rate_name(struct clk_hw *hw_param, unsigned long rate_param,
>                  unsigned long *parent_rate_param)
>    {
>    <...
>    - rate_param
>    + req->rate
>    ...>
>    }
>
>    // Change parent_rate to req->best_parent_rate
>    @ chg_parent_rate depends on generate_name @
>    identifier has_round_rate.round_rate_name;
>    identifier has_round_rate.hw_param;
>    identifier has_round_rate.rate_param;
>    identifier has_round_rate.parent_rate_param;
>    @@
>
>    long round_rate_name(struct clk_hw *hw_param, unsigned long rate_param,
>                  unsigned long *parent_rate_param)
>    {
>    <...
>    (
>    - *parent_rate_param
>    + req->best_parent_rate
>    |
>    - parent_rate_param
>    + &req->best_parent_rate
>    )
>    ...>
>    }
>
>    // Convert the function definition from round_rate() to determine_rate()
>    @ func_definition depends on chg_rate @
>    identifier has_round_rate.round_rate_name;
>    identifier has_round_rate.hw_param;
>    identifier has_round_rate.rate_param;
>    identifier has_round_rate.parent_rate_param;
>    identifier generate_name.new_name;
>    @@
>
>    - long round_rate_name(struct clk_hw *hw_param, unsigned long rate_param,
>    -               unsigned long *parent_rate_param)
>    + int new_name(struct clk_hw *hw, struct clk_rate_request *req)
>    {
>        ...
>    }
>
>    // Update the ops from round_rate() to determine_rate()
>    @ ops depends on func_definition @
>    identifier has_round_rate.round_rate_name;
>    identifier generate_name.new_name;
>    @@
>
>    {
>        ...,
>    -   .round_rate = round_rate_name,
>    +   .determine_rate = new_name,
>        ...,
>    }
>
>Note that I used coccinelle 1.2 instead of 1.3 since the newer version
>adds unnecessary braces as described in this post.
>https://lore.kernel.org/cocci/67642477-5f3e-4b2a-914d-579a54f48cbd@intel.com/
>
>Signed-off-by: Brian Masney <bmasney@redhat.com>

patchset LGTM:
Reviewed-by: Peng Fan <peng.fan@nxp.com>