Re: [PATCH 2/2] clk: qcom: gcc-msm8660: register PLL4_VOTE for LPASS

[Herman van Hazendonk <github.com@herrie.org>]

Hi,

Thanks, two real items here. Triage:

[High] clk_pll_vote_enable() NULL deref on orphan parent.

Confirmed: clk_hw_get_parent() can return NULL while the LCC parent
is not yet bound, to_clk_pll(NULL) is then handed to wait_for_pll(),
and clk_hw_get_name(&pll->clkr.hw) reverses the offset back to NULL
and panics in core/core->name.

Not introduced by this patch though: drivers/clk/qcom/gcc-msm8960.c
and gcc-apq8064.c already register an identical pll4_vote with the
same parent_data fw_name = "pll4" and clk_pll_vote_ops, and have for
years. The hazard already lives in mainline; my patch is a clone of
the same pattern for the older Scorpion-class MSM8x60 family.

I will send a separate one-liner fix to drivers/clk/qcom/clk-pll.c
adding the NULL check in clk_pll_vote_enable() so the cross-driver
voter pattern stops being a latent panic everywhere it is used.
That patch is a precondition for v2 of this series. I would rather
not invent a parallel non-vote ops for MSM8660 specifically when
the right answer is to make the existing one safe.

[Medium] qcom,gcc-msm8660.yaml does not allow "pll4" in clock-names.

Real, and an oversight on my part. The qcom,gcc-apq8064.yaml schema
already documents the same shape -- clocks maxItems = 3, third entry
"pll4" -- because apq8064's gcc-apq8064.c has the same pll4_vote
pattern. I will mirror that here in v2:

  -  clocks:
  -    maxItems: 2
  -  clock-names:
  -    items:
  -      - const: pxo
  -      - const: cxo
  +  clocks:
  +    minItems: 2
  +    maxItems: 3
  +  clock-names:
  +    minItems: 2
  +    items:
  +      - const: pxo
  +      - const: cxo
  +      - const: pll4

The yaml fix becomes a new PATCH 1/3 in v2 (ahead of the existing
CE2 + PLL4_VOTE driver patches) so the schema lands before the
consumer.

I will hold v2 of this series until both the clk-pll.c NULL-check
fix has had review traction and any further feedback on the v1
patches has come in.

Thanks,
Herman