From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from mout.web.de (mout.web.de [212.227.15.4]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id AD35D481FA5; Thu, 10 Sep 2026 14:16:31 +0000 (UTC) Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.4 ARC-Seal:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1789049793; cv=none; b=UEogrmEUSDE8UTga7l/zEW9UNaY9m6GEdY2ulyMAdCj0JLWZs3Tomneio43R2hXXYPc5ZECsF0/g5va2DnX3ZloYc8kmhXH7xwfou0XOvHi2KIxX9GnY7P0umSx2013CKDaWHOxiT3OIxOMniku9fP025PprS3b+oMmY0bKPSbo= ARC-Message-Signature:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1789049793; c=relaxed/simple; bh=ouLSzFPPywcWEjItXpm/BdFxmrrlx7aKIKZ1q/voZWk=; h=From:To:Cc:Subject:Date:Message-ID:In-Reply-To:References: MIME-Version; b=rTVgMIa82BuM/4R4Imq7IDOEm6Ybsmus16pmkjG5rhAjbZ4BAdxwjlzMg2qJoP38ewDpoVMXN4PtxPGYrLjNyI1syPKLvXhdQ1IFjyrgFN3KzLrZw8TCJm/eGjhnC5M5Fcbzr0AABL+F32N31d5EZsqk7jj7AzoY1oRKaXy7iC8= ARC-Authentication-Results:i=1; smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=web.de; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=web.de; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=web.de header.i=spasswolf@web.de header.b=LhvMGG5D; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.4 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=web.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=web.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=web.de header.i=spasswolf@web.de header.b="LhvMGG5D" DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=web.de; s=s29768273; t=1789049734; x=1789654534; i=spasswolf@web.de; bh=ouLSzFPPywcWEjItXpm/BdFxmrrlx7aKIKZ1q/voZWk=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:From:To:Cc:Subject:Date:Message-ID:In-Reply-To: References:MIME-Version:Content-Transfer-Encoding:cc: content-transfer-encoding:content-type:date:from:message-id: mime-version:reply-to:subject:to; b=LhvMGG5DzdYI8DqS5YqGNKz6TQL9GIVQN587L5YBWaR3ZxwGh1q3fsORx9ogHMZ7 OpLpUGtIvnnynrFZtbhDTC3bsbxkKziqvJ8cZr2xJC2Fy0Gdvwxg7rGUiGazCB4p5 lluvrmgGRm84qmsDje0Fq3sU8IpOGUyerTEExlv7HJo56G0nM0cnGGfla13fLFzVU wppgaTNr4orft7UUvOKuhcdRKlZW+nqPNZINJ6Xtg6pI4kyR1vmMf7KtU6A4Dmoyi Tav6PhyiIj/hZRgwclLtfVLvdtI3S4bVDaixSnopQjF2Y6pSfY6g+aC6eijtxNsoq 6QWXUPpXinHPVcycDQ== X-UI-Sender-Class: 814a7b36-bfc1-4dae-8640-3722d8ec6cd6 Received: from client.hidden.invalid by smtp.web.de (mrweb005 [213.165.67.108]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1MLRYd-1xM3io20cV-00XlJW; Thu, 10 Sep 2026 16:15:33 +0200 From: Bert Karwatzki To: Joseph Qi Cc: Bert Karwatzki , Chao Shi , Jan Kara , Venkat , Alexander Viro , Matthew Wilcox , linux-fsdevel@vger.kernel.org, "Theodore Ts'o" , Andreas Dilger , Baokun Li , Ojaswin Mujoo , Ritesh Harjani , Zhang Yi , Zhang Yi , Bob Copeland , Namjae Jeon , Sungjong Seo , Yuezhang Mo , OGAWA Hirofumi , Mark Fasheh , Joel Becker , Joseph Qi , Andreas Gruenbacher , linux-ext4@vger.kernel.org, ocfs2-devel@lists.linux.dev, gfs2@lists.linux.dev, linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org, linux-next@vger.kernel.org, Weidong Zhu Subject: Re: [PATCH v2 03/21] jbd2: point the shadow buffer at the frozen data directly Date: Thu, 10 Sep 2026 16:15:22 +0200 Message-ID: <20260910141524.12362-1-spasswolf@web.de> X-Mailer: git-send-email 2.55.0 In-Reply-To: <9CC2EE8A-9F67-408A-87A1-62AF671B4BFB@linux.ibm.com> (raw) References: Precedence: bulk X-Mailing-List: gfs2@lists.linux.dev List-Id: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:Ul/2rW8Q9s3i94Jp4a/pwfqq/0kVSRETu0GYy0OSrciaIrmj7oC /VGMb8bYZHZTZpM3eCw2U9OdkOxr9fhS7hB5W/AULwFivn+5qkqvwV4jR963HDqY5rw6OKb n4kIetFwotCaeKUKCRTIbwOvanzg0SOVK9CqAZymL0DXh82HsPZNW+zd+ccRyTR6RkxmBe3 iQj3Pui9AvylTp30cam/w== X-Spam-Flag: NO UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:h1+fjtsb0wA=;IFoDmys7j1uXJOqLBetdwENOFSk KjmO7xqWl67Fqp3fyO6XIwSpae1xaAex7FEPM8cEQTbsaUX8Ov3BW5lkMrVB9UpsRhrBRTl3x nPzBqyd71uSfymSakDWsMPFHcsL5d/Fe6OxHBJLh1KGkxPy+H5soYqO9AUEERDIy3x1TZ7za9 BjunaIaPFdyysW/ZK5TNCv8S5ApsrnCpSqAJXBo+q3v5fGrl9MtCfcm+lD6DaDUz3DpPF06mh 5yElci0+sMC2Ge8+6sp+mFNtd2AuNUKzjo3sNmJLLpq9vSxnciYUVbx3CQ6xEvRSifpDqIko0 n1pUz1bVakFbgdWRzrA72Rdm43Sil4CQC7LmAw/2m7d87zgwWKakHFMBEYl72YSWDW+TTGyOQ RsscsKL+2P6hfsZNUheWsbxtGNSn9Bn1HQZ6y9mejlH3dE28B9N+1DYSks5K0DNd9IuRXbCjh qWTAOyFDE9BP59bQBqSGYmmQWUNCW3uf93s3oBaxodXnb9LEh8EVD2FcoqHJsUIxz+Zr4GMKr t1LUmqBa/pzzSqURdoktCRe08mSJixy5HpNqSLIpAJSlKB6Kk9iyP08SWtHQu9yL9w3eXwv2U EcXH2PnG/qu7zhfPOEuCdJvlq7ol31jd8fvSiFyD2dKlKPQuLO/hTFOjmzh4i2BnEqBdlHzZ6 eQ6BAJzyI1jK0EsU8BYeusboUo4gwT0VcGyViwGjnGmv3xhhcXtCyKF12tbLzFMgoMB9rtxl1 ItzTrp2l8ZmFgeH+JZ1LLTz9koUJwu3wDofzI0xCkUztDroJWHrFccDl4xV473zNnDIcfOYMM A/tGzDNkneIAHYe2Md4uuJvtVEpSZYPZz/RNjHX4F8rzaQju1KTLm0goCH6sI/NVCoFRDybUF f9e52B3I4tXfrthGC56+5O8izpm95eXEYc1gwV+fZJ1TEmsYl1xaxBWHeMpJ1RxJVVPJoCqmH j4uMrn+KUQBQCDjNFsaMEnRTMUsSX6nBKBVTYaAH+YYruTuHoav/B8Lq+Em4CxWVkkl9ZuI0x 3eAIt6zcigbaKyWs+dwHv7/OH30X1yM7MAy8He4TiaIajk77fVZM6AhUKINLfQDH5xb9qco9m bfXg+0c8vy6TV5UAm475u31JDha2oh7T1O3rsIaHGV7NWvpYo9Yg03qRnBnWIqCMbHLxeJkvi jC+lBCeV+ZfJYNJKeKQAAWCnfl53autIxVXwmegEvQ6hMqEFpYi5RvIfF65F+nOBtH/NVka8D b0XEv3K/6PZcH1mukiXPRCR6DaVPOWMtD93ooE2X0OlR1+pU4FLh6PIxjV/sSgIU0s1ssYRNu i/+TvVB88+uZlcJ8JaO+M7rFXayZMCXN8YB6Rht1YJz1Z87aRCW1/AGY19qOocvhdK15MJ4zk ZhhNaFfn0jmfm/QlJcISWP4tPuf6Qqh1HUgADzJ5KscPTspdKuVUXalBsF979I6dEM59lZUNe KAe5ZQuY/0GOTrauce5DTheM9uPNYrIq74YdjUIbRcYWgcizSs7PNfjtFhUmdkyDvKqy4x1xu D3+8fa9m5uI+30H1BoNw/dDSQmmS8wXKatPPg/IrcP5yPD5igMPps22O3q521ZSfFr4lmf3T6 YQoomNg4l2n7QVhZfMioC18jglmSoGCrq5m47l2JbLaTKXNIdULKtHat9tawF1vxVUkB7zSxt R/g6gfLveEZyZG+m/QsRW8tTULmW0fHhZFfqY+nbC8fXyy07tHauOZoTI0dIZtDNRo4RuaFbR ntZ2iyeCKcAwmJWgfKSq00RKOdtYTMV/L1QbvYZcAB3fztapQSf4cF7JRynLMHLqqQ0O2D8xU pjqbl0CF41UgHc/n9MJwvMyuAgw4Twr5bV7pESVxs/kZq7vEVZK/f9Mf575+qNCeIrlN+5xxN vz2H4tUL6zIk1M7Csp0tdFQA9xUrYqNbPdGxVfYfjRR5I5SaF6cYSPtyGXb+fnbRYiemYIeA4 AfhMyB1T+5xQkA9Tu7XMKeFrYniakrcMbNSVb2T4x3n3ez0Funjm9G+sTmCEpJvmBR70KNyFz Mz3QJF7cpOI2eQCz9qtDP+ExHXADaI7lnFEWg8KeEPvndybu/Zf/CSE2FNwtLhD8h5F+torYz WxVplXq7ltr0xNE44ZeNE2x6o3MUoq8dM6stPfbDc4f4lqMGXo+fgu4Hed2eTElrdGOgA4/Pl EwicbGmd1kFWuSKrMTnzLCq38MOgy7udbMIsC4EVDaZo5Qe8IyBMtzmv5lT6Uug3ZFuljDlAk W6eEmgPvocEbUjzQLuWknKzXI36kUIvEq3nBIp2NSXIaNonHMPqJYg3VgfCM/23JVunqTFC2m SZ/BwsDXDVgiAevzlrZNgWPMDXiXXzuaVsnjX9YuZ7lAd3lzaRQnq4I3uQOVDwOlzxAeNuWP+ WaPFclojjl2sAQ4a/GnLl9qJnksJlT1kxgVu/fyxxRFpUHF3U6PFJ00pUa4mIJ8ZXFTDJs5i4 KjngqlDZTDitCNqeOmthZ65KJQFSVxd8ZqQ9bQ9I2zZK+sWPfIuELeY5YSuj/RlQ/oHoW86+s kjzuLofa54V6q08iry5pV6eU9QiRGSCiZfzO40WUi0IezmepNRLpuAyiCtpkr84goQWQExJjM lR29t3RG/TwUUVAkMs5ptXCB1LOXcCgm2MivydojkmDDyJ5XZ6Neow1ikE1pE8BXdKni6ZJ/3 CEnZr123sDtfwCuwyyyCq6L1U+62m1NE+I6HJDHtqX+X3uNpTkk6p43FCih2Xf0yUUeULz+ms h5iJwsut5+wTNcLqNdvOe600VwR/bka4Ug380s/jAMgNnnjSPuYirt4M7JtxlA7C3rouq1uay aDYWUKZZYLJQXyaYrkQR2+LydTI2Axvl3h6UVhpwf4POUMB0xetOa4YMmeLYZT3HC1imgz63x 9Mdts9mDjmvcEvRmI+Ry6oNvpUF2Xyd0Ne15QtY0K+Qwac/9WE2PG4St7Cd2BJDasTRJIgyGV AjJqGkT4EdtsDzY6pIoIss7bV4Q/sp5QNl25oEx8+WGnXe0tj76CTvluWm43yuGbz5mqIV4wQ YoQRVdJmT4JTwrf0ztfKkFViLJv/dNz12wQRowQFa3asgclFbQDEnChFT5eHcgE6kwlMQzDAQ /vd3uPzEQDqlGC9XRj7x7s6Nx832Fb/1Zwev/TWS1uv01FHNKLAu095jLVkb1VqZqNSsyt3B+ qvYFVldPZARuzQnY6mVH+XTmNVXn1g0Z1y7dAYtXDvOMBDqlDftBbXqCCVrBcUQrs4D3rkQUn sjZNXcpAEgvoBpOS7yjzJoS0YhCl6rs7S+/L2XGgP2wDmm0n6n0m2NM27Bw2kjgJKNG0A2inG 9bkRZ/XmOItrz5soR+Bo75Voz/PEvagQYMaSUZGjktAN0Cp0z6/xjEbomb7GvjX5IlgSat9te Z3L4YJraawMWy78YVzWD5U1XufAj6LFIpCKqzCsDqLPNaU5Xteu8QlZv3Brj4p5dOHCQF2ZJX 2z00QjUea3Myi36uCQr8a5rXAAznv2wDjFAmi5c6FMEI+Lsu/IkWb3EgMgguuejXLlApPgTem kFalp3NGZjs26X8c5ttpvCMBF6fh3BtfvP86yFCFTvZ3jXSTE5fD1t/hU4Ezc6XaGK6enkfNp xp0/SCa1BgJClGDjWsqH5zSGVNBO9rWbZvbKIsBWRiJ3be+PS2XvfmSb6KJo9zt7DxmG7zgWc AkRMdHhA9bA3bd4c4mtcDmwi9Go0pL7+nO4up24DYWZyY4fzl77i5p4r6G3TcnLgH8HwwDuBN mCxHpxaJApbC7AUV2vLERJT1iMWXPG8P1T8i9/9HaQ0NJbDGjQWVSUiez/1wWQacW3hdKYdq0 XQw6CO7KXC3x5hvQfTcrCW7czH/qtt2o/Sc540lHVeoKdeHE+eB8RYEMlx9p7vlLafWlPnjUI cm9BMQok+lrwBtw5sLUvSWT5xADfyz0OWULd6CxD98Y/JbvpkZaWKjkWmoDovKHLKzI6UiJSj yb9+V57X18MtPqd5MYgJZsSSzeAKj0D4RFg/f6zPmB+eD7RHb4o1vm5vcirjawnFjLm5WZ+ur K/kXMWevIp7r3k0x72fhLyYElSN+FK7Ks+dfURVCDCriOSR+JbUKZz3QLoyFjAYqWY6DvdSWl vhZKwuD7oKGIaQhj0MpR6iuXFxqRO1s3Atpd6UQAHoovFpGWV6mwuBpWszPr61JUN0ftFYtsB sdZjsW+L/qJgyxxoYMI/rD4Er9XyqwqJOo58dYCjwD39/cSnP6+/FUB5w29sBMIqV+AoaHHE1 Ww1RskybhIR2198ud2jXFf3jhSXyGCRXJ17CjyVOpb+2HD5ZZ6shu5Bqr9yeKl4110L5UHt7X ysLZi1UCr4DuvviTnXtrRB1mpqHTTfXfiVVY1dILNk+WVb1aCcADRSNmc1rFM5rjVolcXaY3I uxX+Dx2DW43YIGkPTO+txJCx+kptxmfEpDVx3tQrMuWUi8rJp9bd11RM9bP5UxIimDvsTFVrg vcC/TXO+7E7knJsviRutGhzgaV6/qwk+suAanBiEP7EAZQzkpmuNDokAQJDLMH3epygV5plit rcv+iCQ5HN2o0xWifMv5SCtf1AsTPsdwqSuNTjsRY0lc6poZlvFk64XlnD9abyNk//OIgV2RZ YeiIo5rvBmo5EMKYRryhpqjp+ukkXEaZL4u06iNW1ZyywRu7BaOZi8CkCHjvHKxZQzxNgp/IA cEbP8985NiwHnDcQvLFgl3YGs/M0Y43CAwMf0S7I1Hklgh7PusaI2qKohXjK/XuwTkifenT4q mjnuivfFWaFiyVGfeUMNccw/Fsu9wvVmuAvWgM/OOVKvIY4Cv/MhaNz0v5ofMrKSEvE4x/V+p cArJKHt/6U2mKboy2dw9LROfviB1Uf6NNhTc9Xsxlvyd5AfWxYAapIzSceoXkYYyLtjF/9jLW KaXvMxQqrbSCCQhFZYrVNcgSb44dDiEp9cv85R1YRrDF1LI8Uijx+o93A5MY9+32vnOOFS2Tk WHdxGTF3LEFGUoPBicGXQtNPJUt2gm+ILdLS9mj/5cxJ3t8bnGoQhdd/CBoYP4G3UpUcPR37g MQ0SHYLRbUmTqz5V+nqmajIVhuWGeqvvcqUYAriGF5Fc5LyHX9y8icyPgRH9mm2lEaOY6ZGlk MBdr5MByZmZhs6uYnrFrfPJBw84vccAs9J4krpQoUhI8o4Ajn4ivZX1VwgNK7pQGLL+5EjfZe 2zZ0YmhHXi9CI9Mw6nNew38s1sn2EqRPe9BPn/2ZztLvHf96p6odD7fvbM2G0UVRsY/8BzyCd c0tTD2NpA9lwX6XVUJQdOUVOeEgQSa2QmyqyvCptV5cgQ67TwxRhPbh0I2VHx3XfUOg2g5n50 PwuaApQV9+269+DmjRYozrJBC6N6hkqT9ZyrUmZlGIEoQAWnFlP1JgwBvd55ZEibBy53C58oB 7q30thYF2AUEF+GFjsB6ppiEdjPGEm8jOgRB/8LBT0lxzX52vFy8R7CuKGjZyKazmZngQ5m5K rMMxu8T+qs8Fdcvcy18hFoYx48X7ZS+jXmBOHmsQAJmfOfjZDN0qJKw+LDxrTrOnuFDZFAlQl oqmZkOjEz95FjvTkiL5krMCXro5Nzv5xxU4LH4fDn5R3SqU8l7JQR3XKDVmLkzOxvJc8+ejiI irbNlv+ZKtX/En8nYiehSnu1Urf2SwAid30dVp/67ZeK501QUdRLbyogj/f01dHfTUBChqK9C r2D6iJRnVOD2wdHXJ7QILuJq+iw4ntDms7us4uoET1dqnYgR6C0/LW1NBQGQvcM6Q6XJtzCWd Lm0lnys9JrhchWlQv4H5fDszFiICH9lqTxB3b6P2k1/+R5e5FG2dm7FrSwY7nzieWAHS8rVEX v30fLMm52O+HQTPjUSiYXOHl/NyTa08W6CtKfSAlRMoX/8SKMLJhdN18qqdaAHymPqIjO2W/I 6FnjcJDHwmJALc+iVeyN1Y2HGlbEgJLzmioQh2aHG5PxLOU6h6bzX/Pp3ky9nv2RgSKX+oOIR BT+R5JtaS/LCg3SdKU21pgAj6r82VQoW5gvAENaVw7gIF0cHjSKHlFhF6DzE4fwV4p3X1CVMj zUWsIITmZ50NNT+vnQw9BWjXoBKqChQcrDBFZFxmM0a8gLSveaBxNLS+B0wPvkzQqHdcJXXQQ sgbKgsZiN7mqLforSoJ3PlM3Vrs4pT4N3Bu68WyiINN590xOA46Vwq+dQB67nocFB+MdFlMYI mbteIBUpUs= Just a quick reminder, in linux next-20260909 this has not been fixed, yet. Bert Karwatzki