Re: pvmove thin volume doesn't move

[matthew patton <pattonme@yahoo.com>]

> If the tool would have known 'which areas' are  mapped  (which knows thin-pool 
> target internally) then it would need to copy only those blocks.

no doubt. but if lvmthin is basically a private implementation that LVM (aka thick) doesn't actually know anything about and is just being used as a pass-thru to thin API, I'm not sure we want to expose thin internals to the caller. I obviously haven't read the code implementing either thick or thin, but if thick does a thin_read(one 4MB extent) then thin should just return a buffer with 4mb populated with all the data converted into a thick+linear representation that Thick is expecting. Then the traditional workflow can resume with the extent written out to its destination PV. In other words you're hydrating a thin representation into a thick representation. Could you take that buffer and thin_write(dest thin pool)? I don't see why not.

Or you could just punt and say pvmove() of a thin is necessarily a hydrate operation and can only be written out into a non-then PV, tough luck. Use offline `dd`if you want more.

I haven't been particularly impressed by LVM caching (it has it's uses don't get me wrong) but I find layering open-cas to be more intuitive and gives me a degree of freedom.