From: Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan <ananth@sgi.com>
To: Linus Torvalds <torvalds@transmeta.com>
Cc: Kanoj Sarcar <kanoj@google.engr.sgi.com>,
linux-mm@kvack.org, "David S. Miller" <davem@redhat.com>,
Rik van Riel <riel@nl.linux.org>
Subject: Re: Oops in __free_pages_ok (pre7-1) (Long) (backtrace)
Date: Thu, 04 May 2000 10:19:45 -0700 [thread overview]
Message-ID: <3911B131.4A565CE0@sgi.com> (raw)
In-Reply-To: Pine.LNX.4.10.10005040808490.1137-100000@penguin.transmeta.com
Linus Torvalds wrote:
>
> On Thu, 4 May 2000, Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan wrote:
> >
> > I did some testing of this patch with dbench.
> > The kernel starts shooting processes down pretty quickly
> > ("VM: killing process XXX") on a 2 CPU 64MB system,
> > with nothing but dbench (8 clients). A concurrently
> > running vmstat shows very low free memory with some swapping,
> > and the buffer space remaining around 50MB.
[ ... ]
>
> Rik, I think the kswapd logic is wrong, and I suspect you made it
> worsewhen you added the while-loop. The problem looks like that while
> kswapd is working on one zone, it will entirely ignore any other zones. I
> think the logic should be more like
[ ... ]
> What do you think? I suspect that the added do-loop in pre7 just made the
> "lost wakeups" problem worse by concentrating on one zone for a longer
> while and thus more likely to lose wakeups for lower zones (because it
> already looked at those).
>
> There might be other details like this lurking, but this looks like a good
> first try. Ananth, willing to give it a whirl?
>
> Linus
I haven't looked at the code, but I replaced the whole while (1) loop
with the new for(;;). Things still remain the same: when running
dbench VM starts killing processes. Following is a vmstat trace during
the dbench run with the latest change to kswapd. For some reason,
the system seems to swap more with the change; I've attached a second
vmstat trace as of early AM today before the change. Again, I have
a 2 CPU box with 64M memory ... the tests are very controlled, nothing
changes except what I want to change (kernel bits).
------------- vmstat trace with kswapd change ----------------------
[root@delilah /root]# vmstat 1 1000
procs memory swap io system cpu
r b w swpd free buff cache si so bi bo in cs us sy id
0 0 0 0 41664 968 11144 0 0 12 2 55 14 1 1 98
0 0 0 0 41664 968 11144 0 0 0 0 106 13 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 41664 968 11144 0 0 0 0 105 8 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 41664 968 11144 0 0 0 0 104 8 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 41664 968 11144 0 0 0 0 107 26 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 41664 968 11144 0 0 0 0 110 36 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 41664 968 11144 0 0 0 0 114 46 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 41236 968 11144 0 0 0 0 108 42 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 41216 968 11144 0 0 0 0 105 23 1 0 99
0 8 0 0 38324 1036 13260 0 0 142 85 203 356 2 5 93
0 8 1 0 24376 1096 25548 0 0 33 3378 239 705 1 21 78
0 8 1 0 21340 1116 28220 0 0 26 2482 304 1960 0 7 92
1 7 1 0 11540 1160 36896 0 0 41 2623 318 5384 1 17 82
0 8 1 0 6212 1180 41568 0 0 20 2813 332 3467 1 8 91
0 8 1 0 3040 1192 44360 0 0 6 2727 271 803 0 7 92
0 8 2 432 1208 1148 46484 0 432 60 6968 754 4099 0 7 92
0 8 2 648 1112 1164 46780 0 216 14 3249 348 2720 0 9 91
0 8 0 3948 1240 1112 49984 0 3300 44 22247 2210 6100 0 5 95
0 8 0 4336 1540 1076 49896 0 388 28 4597 317 222 1 12 87
3 5 1 6132 1200 444 51400 1736 3892 1872 31316 5098 2307 0 15 85
0 7 0 6612 1092 452 51528 172 908 329 7872 862 463 0 21 79
procs memory swap io system cpu
r b w swpd free buff cache si so bi bo in cs us sy id
0 5 1 6944 1548 456 51148 192 1052 339 8263 1362 405 1 14 86
2 4 1 7212 1532 436 51216 16 668 35 7667 678 470 0 24 76
2 6 1 7072 1540 436 51136 360 808 224 8202 1170 756 0 21 79
1 3 2 7048 1260 448 51320 28 328 61 4082 484 126 0 20 80
2 1 3 7012 964 460 51720 24 180 46 2545 310 90 0 7 93
1 4 1 6984 992 472 51664 24 192 29 2917 320 91 1 17 82
0 1 5 7064 1508 468 51116 32 248 28 2062 345 85 1 16 83
0 3 3 6956 1540 456 51004 32 288 188 4072 525 183 0 14 85
0 5 1 7168 1516 464 50864 84 628 454 4657 824 249 1 10 89
0 7 0 7500 1108 496 51204 20 672 204 2668 412 171 4 9 87
2 5 0 7484 756 504 51476 0 404 179 3601 558 312 1 6 93
0 7 0 7476 1244 488 51076 4 228 342 1557 402 194 1 5 94
0 6 1 7456 1244 496 51076 4 120 691 1530 399 118 3 5 92
0 7 0 7372 1416 488 50780 28 344 1068 1086 351 178 1 6 93
2 4 0 7352 1448 500 50740 0 244 893 506 413 152 2 3 95
0 6 0 7252 1200 500 50944 48 124 1411 289 225 166 0 7 93
0 7 0 7324 1404 488 50796 72 124 708 531 455 526 1 1 98
0 7 0 7364 1480 488 50804 12 224 858 225 965 892 1 4 96
0 6 1 7284 1424 500 50736 16 240 1986 140 218 192 0 10 89
2 4 0 7420 876 500 51476 4 352 1424 588 599 511 2 10 88
1 6 0 7424 1356 496 50944 68 168 679 1042 695 337 1 3 96
procs memory swap io system cpu
r b w swpd free buff cache si so bi bo in cs us sy id
0 6 0 7312 1228 520 50936 44 176 513 2044 476 210 4 8 88
0 6 0 7408 1464 516 50812 12 264 135 1566 277 94 3 12 85
1 5 0 7384 1228 536 50952 0 120 208 2530 312 147 1 6 92
0 6 0 7512 1332 528 50996 0 212 104 1553 326 104 0 10 89
0 6 0 7548 1544 536 50908 16 236 132 2059 430 110 1 7 92
2 4 1 7740 1360 552 51156 64 540 427 4635 614 232 3 6 91
0 6 0 7564 1204 552 51172 56 124 217 1031 333 98 3 3 94
0 6 0 7460 1064 560 51112 12 116 718 1529 423 195 6 7 87
0 6 0 7516 1212 580 50968 16 236 662 559 258 176 2 7 91
0 6 0 7472 1448 596 50580 16 0 638 1000 232 182 5 10 85
1 5 1 7556 1380 608 50700 16 124 354 531 306 147 2 5 93
1 5 0 7604 1204 624 50912 12 180 712 2545 470 139 3 6 91
1 5 0 7612 1372 636 50688 8 292 1082 2573 507 199 2 6 92
0 6 0 7600 1516 652 50548 4 168 392 1042 264 125 5 4 90
0 6 0 7592 1356 676 50756 0 108 442 527 286 157 5 8 87
0 6 0 7488 3400 704 48556 0 0 659 0 213 186 4 2 93
0 6 0 7392 7188 712 44660 0 0 745 0 221 220 11 13 76
0 6 0 7392 2588 724 49252 0 0 302 3000 306 486 14 13 73
0 6 2 7420 2004 732 49944 0 136 130 1292 292 3150 7 7 85
5 2 0 7520 2040 732 49988 0 104 38 2268 333 357 1 2 97
4 3 1 7808 1144 724 51068 8 408 371 7555 844 3960 4 8 88
procs memory swap io system cpu
r b w swpd free buff cache si so bi bo in cs us sy id
4 2 2 8116 1480 728 50852 24 692 190 5143 664 335 3 6 92
1 5 0 7860 1516 736 50608 24 100 122 3083 452 228 3 9 88
0 6 0 7760 1132 744 50780 4 100 352 44 423 99 3 3 94
4 2 0 7676 2516 744 49292 0 128 610 1032 271 189 15 15 70
3 1 5 8352 852 756 51380 28 1112 624 11778 1640 3164 3 9 88
4 2 0 7928 1420 760 50480 8 264 225 1566 483 306 7 10 83
0 6 0 7876 4504 764 47252 0 0 425 1500 328 144 10 16 74
0 6 0 7876 10068 764 41664 0 0 265 2000 418 124 19 21 60
2 4 1 7876 6608 764 45124 0 0 208 3137 266 1170 18 26 55
0 6 1 7872 1712 764 50000 0 0 255 1943 327 4264 8 14 78
3 3 2 7864 1540 764 50364 0 204 21 2003 357 3479 7 16 77
0 6 2 7716 888 764 50992 0 68 147 2071 306 3040 8 10 83
2 4 2 7804 900 772 51016 0 272 270 3982 599 3871 8 14 78
1 5 1 7688 7028 780 44668 0 8 120 2416 326 1194 25 25 50
0 6 1 7688 3152 780 48540 0 0 189 2364 335 10084 17 39 45
0 6 1 7688 1352 780 50332 0 0 185 1843 381 6073 16 20 64
4 2 1 7708 2636 776 49132 0 120 40 4975 298 2135 6 12 82
4 2 2 7832 3856 792 48100 0 348 259 8521 714 6546 6 10 84
4 2 1 7816 5792 792 46028 4 152 145 5785 377 1006 13 16 71
1 5 1 7804 2348 792 49380 52 0 223 859 247 4483 13 19 69
1 5 1 7828 2624 792 49156 0 112 104 2323 314 3228 11 15 74
procs memory swap io system cpu
r b w swpd free buff cache si so bi bo in cs us sy id
2 4 1 7760 6600 792 44908 0 0 204 2878 361 1783 17 21 61
2 5 1 7736 4428 792 47224 220 0 297 3065 417 4822 27 38 35
0 7 1 7728 5128 792 46468 60 0 102 1865 434 2128 7 8 85
4 3 1 7724 2768 792 48844 12 0 169 3404 498 7431 11 16 73
2 4 0 7696 4128 792 47472 0 116 132 7416 444 4061 13 24 63
1 5 1 7692 5016 792 46572 0 0 8 1500 220 63 11 12 76
0 6 0 7672 5000 792 46564 0 0 12 2000 224 102 8 8 84
5 1 0 7672 4720 792 46860 0 0 69 2000 258 796 7 12 80
0 6 1 7672 5080 792 46484 0 0 115 3114 302 1880 28 34 38
0 6 1 7672 4308 792 47256 0 0 7 1718 286 2861 4 10 86
0 6 1 7672 6528 792 45020 12 0 114 1461 330 1508 3 5 92
0 6 0 7672 9080 792 42468 0 0 7 707 296 233 0 3 97
0 6 0 7672 11948 792 39592 8 0 30 3500 317 182 11 14 75
0 6 0 7672 35396 792 16144 0 0 69 0 273 169 0 7 93
0 6 0 7672 39716 792 11824 0 0 119 0 223 246 0 4 96
0 1 0 7628 41828 792 10520 768 0 532 0 216 248 1 1 98
0 0 0 7616 41320 792 10956 320 0 212 0 124 44 0 1 99
0 0 0 7616 41320 792 10956 0 0 0 16 119 12 0 0 100
0 0 0 7616 40580 792 11252 196 0 159 0 127 69 1 0 99
0 0 0 7616 40568 792 11252 0 0 0 0 106 23 1 0 99
0 8 1 7616 28856 792 22556 0 0 50 1045 137 239 2 17 80
procs memory swap io system cpu
r b w swpd free buff cache si so bi bo in cs us sy id
7 1 1 7616 19400 792 32076 0 0 5 4999 307 1382 1 17 83
0 8 1 7616 8604 792 42832 0 0 10 5133 312 1871 0 19 81
0 8 1 7616 4616 792 46816 0 0 9 4186 295 758 0 8 92
0 8 1 7616 1032 792 50404 0 0 5 3804 325 803 0 10 90
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------ vmstat trace as of pure 7-4 patch ----------------------------
[root@delilah /root]# vmstat 1 1000
procs memory swap io system cpu
r b w swpd free buff cache si so bi bo in cs us sy id
0 0 0 0 45176 712 8144 0 0 62 8 71 60 3 3 94
0 0 0 0 45176 712 8144 0 0 0 0 106 12 0 0 100
0 1 0 0 45160 716 8144 0 0 1 0 106 14 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 45024 732 8252 0 0 34 59 140 49 0 1 99
0 0 0 0 45024 732 8252 0 0 0 0 121 8 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 45024 732 8252 0 0 0 0 104 10 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 45024 732 8252 0 0 0 0 121 76 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 45020 736 8252 0 0 6 0 117 55 1 0 98
0 2 0 0 44640 772 8324 0 0 27 65 157 84 1 0 98
0 1 0 0 43436 908 8900 0 0 182 0 231 240 5 1 94
1 0 0 0 40604 940 10584 0 0 402 0 173 150 17 2 81
1 0 0 0 40452 952 10896 0 0 84 0 117 80 42 4 54
1 0 0 0 39072 952 10980 0 0 4 0 108 41 50 2 49
1 0 0 0 40476 988 11264 0 0 111 13 146 115 26 3 70
1 0 0 0 40916 988 11196 0 0 8 0 110 76 47 2 50
0 0 0 0 41576 988 11220 0 0 0 0 108 51 17 2 80
0 0 0 0 41576 988 11220 0 0 0 0 104 8 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 41576 988 11220 0 0 0 0 103 8 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 41576 988 11220 0 0 0 1 108 18 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 41576 988 11220 0 0 0 0 115 48 0 0 100
0 0 0 0 41576 988 11220 0 0 0 0 110 32 0 0 100
procs memory swap io system cpu
r b w swpd free buff cache si so bi bo in cs us sy id
0 0 0 0 41140 988 11220 0 0 0 0 110 43 0 1 99
0 0 0 0 41128 988 11220 0 0 0 0 111 25 0 0 100
8 0 0 0 30488 1072 20260 0 0 73 0 126 186 1 13 86
0 8 0 0 20308 1120 29148 0 0 4 8500 203 66 1 16 83
0 8 1 0 11632 1160 36792 0 0 30 4599 267 395 0 15 84
0 8 1 0 2240 1208 45052 0 0 8 5787 346 981 1 17 82
0 8 2 0 1228 736 46520 0 0 14 2806 298 735 1 17 82
0 8 3 0 1144 388 46648 0 0 13 5154 392 871 1 15 84
5 4 1 1068 1080 384 47832 0 1068 17 15921 1059 1134 0 11 89
8 0 2 2220 1456 404 48616 0 1152 9 5788 487 123 0 10 89
0 8 2 3044 1028 408 49572 0 840 5 4210 264 95 0 17 83
0 8 1 3540 1100 412 49964 0 500 2 8125 222 89 0 8 92
0 8 2 3852 1088 416 50188 0 312 8 3359 224 89 0 9 91
0 9 1 4048 1072 448 50208 84 204 65 770 350 168 1 22 77
0 8 2 4016 1132 460 50068 200 0 88 5464 376 808 1 31 67
0 8 3 4016 1072 476 50112 56 0 25 4052 363 668 0 11 89
0 8 3 4016 1100 484 50080 0 0 13 4529 356 583 0 11 89
0 8 2 4384 1032 452 50504 0 372 4 9637 345 569 1 10 89
0 8 0 4432 1536 448 50052 0 48 0 1923 219 206 0 2 98
0 8 2 5004 1540 444 50628 0 572 71 6836 416 86 0 7 92
1 3 6 5280 1188 432 51168 0 332 21 9390 714 6872 1 11 88
Killed
[root@delilah /root]# vmstat 1 1000
procs memory swap io system cpu
r b w swpd free buff cache si so bi bo in cs us sy id
0 4 0 5672 30508 760 21128 12 31 85 710 114 159 4 8 87
0 0 0 5608 31360 760 20740 436 0 172 121 210 227 0 2 98
0 0 0 5608 31360 760 20740 0 0 0 0 168 10 0 0 100
0 0 0 5608 31360 760 20740 0 0 0 0 104 8 0 0 100
0 0 0 5608 31360 760 20740 0 0 0 0 105 8 0 0 100
0 0 0 5592 31324 760 20756 28 0 11 0 112 24 0 0 100
0 0 0 5592 31308 760 20768 12 0 3 22 124 26 0 0 100
0 0 0 5592 31300 760 20776 8 0 2 0 108 20 0 0 100
0 0 0 5592 31300 760 20776 0 0 0 0 103 8 0 0 100
0 0 0 5592 30860 760 20780 4 0 1 0 106 32 0 0 99
0 0 0 5592 30848 760 20780 0 0 0 0 106 25 0 0 100
1 7 1 5592 16064 760 35156 0 0 63 2365 176 1593 1 23 76
0 8 1 5592 2608 760 48632 0 0 38 5350 448 3538 0 28 72
0 8 2 5820 1060 744 50576 0 252 14 4888 409 848 0 10 89
0 5 4 6196 1208 744 50760 0 384 2 10556 543 1439 0 4 96
2 4 3 6080 1120 520 51372 100 1308 399 30927 2351 6011 0 36 63
0 8 2 5792 1056 552 51092 416 0 389 4967 776 6246 0 41 59
5 3 3 5344 1540 564 50908 188 1052 597 22696 2076 2402 0 25 75
0 4 0 5308 1536 576 50724 100 208 731 5552 732 243 1 7 91
0 5 1 5300 1348 588 50900 120 180 968 7045 809 1056 2 12 87
0 5 0 5200 1356 584 50760 56 0 299 1500 416 108 1 2 96
procs memory swap io system cpu
r b w swpd free buff cache si so bi bo in cs us sy id
0 5 2 5100 1524 544 50644 24 56 169 4347 301 406 2 11 87
0 5 0 5128 1392 556 50896 48 68 225 2184 398 198 3 4 93
0 3 1 5032 1368 560 50884 32 0 306 1000 334 109 1 5 94
1 2 0 5100 1048 572 51256 0 96 327 2024 266 104 1 8 91
0 3 0 5080 1376 556 50900 12 40 386 2510 277 90 2 11 86
0 3 0 5160 1332 580 50892 0 120 1105 2030 220 148 4 10 86
0 3 0 5108 1228 588 50944 0 0 286 2500 349 76 2 5 93
2 1 0 5108 2488 604 49672 0 0 645 0 251 162 10 6 84
0 3 0 5140 1028 604 51248 0 232 365 2058 262 148 10 20 71
0 3 0 5452 1172 604 51304 0 392 262 4098 342 160 1 4 95
0 3 0 5324 1160 600 51152 0 0 194 1500 455 67 5 7 87
1 2 0 5308 1500 608 50736 0 0 204 2000 310 83 5 7 88
2 1 1 5228 1260 612 51024 0 92 1408 2023 220 209 33 42 25
0 3 0 5200 1084 616 51148 0 0 5 2000 308 721 7 7 86
0 3 0 5004 3116 616 49120 0 4 0 2001 263 48 5 3 92
3 0 0 4956 4336 616 47868 0 0 588 1500 217 106 31 34 34
0 3 0 4848 1496 616 50676 0 0 145 2000 242 62 14 16 70
3 0 0 4848 3684 616 48500 0 0 385 500 219 64 23 26 51
0 3 0 4848 1280 612 50888 0 0 140 3500 212 64 16 14 70
3 0 0 4848 5464 612 46760 0 0 225 0 201 52 8 23 70
0 3 0 4848 1396 616 50768 0 0 293 3000 207 74 20 26 54
procs memory swap io system cpu
r b w swpd free buff cache si so bi bo in cs us sy id
1 2 0 4848 4236 616 47936 0 0 0 1500 258 49 6 4 90
0 3 0 4848 1956 616 50216 0 0 310 2000 209 81 24 27 49
2 1 0 4820 1488 608 50692 0 0 196 1500 303 58 10 8 81
0 3 0 4820 3896 608 48308 8 0 281 1000 237 127 18 22 60
0 3 0 4816 33088 608 19068 0 0 178 0 224 261 1 9 90
0 0 0 4752 34680 608 17808 144 0 232 0 168 121 0 1 98
0 1 0 4748 34600 608 17888 4 0 79 40 138 24 0 1 99
0 0 0 4736 34584 608 17884 8 0 2 0 109 16 0 0 100
0 0 0 4736 33996 608 18036 32 0 134 0 131 66 1 1 98
0 1 0 4736 31912 608 20056 0 0 55 0 132 74 1 4 95
0 8 0 4736 15540 608 36272 0 0 72 10000 217 121 0 23 77
4 4 2 4736 5060 608 46716 0 0 9 1670 222 107 0 20 80
0 8 1 4736 2728 608 48856 0 0 22 1653 225 593 0 8 92
2 6 2 4876 1184 600 50744 0 244 35 10361 400 640 1 10 89
3 5 2 5084 1204 608 50908 0 272 93 9176 647 6848 1 7 92
Killed
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
To unsubscribe, send a message with 'unsubscribe linux-mm' in
the body to majordomo@kvack.org. For more info on Linux MM,
see: http://www.linux.eu.org/Linux-MM/
next prev parent reply other threads:[~2000-05-04 17:19 UTC|newest]
Thread overview: 45+ messages / expand[flat|nested] mbox.gz Atom feed top
[not found] <8ener4$6djpb$1@fido.engr.sgi.com>
2000-05-03 3:11 ` Oops in __free_pages_ok (pre7-1) (Long) (backtrace) Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-03 3:47 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-03 5:26 ` Kanoj Sarcar
2000-05-03 6:22 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-03 16:11 ` Kanoj Sarcar
2000-05-03 16:19 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-03 16:35 ` Kanoj Sarcar
2000-05-03 17:16 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-03 17:31 ` Kanoj Sarcar
2000-05-03 18:17 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-03 18:37 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-03 18:37 ` Kanoj Sarcar
2000-05-03 19:41 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-03 21:28 ` Jeff Garzik
2000-05-03 8:11 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-03 8:31 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-03 16:08 ` Kanoj Sarcar
2000-05-03 16:14 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-03 16:24 ` Kanoj Sarcar
2000-05-04 1:38 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-04 2:44 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-04 4:05 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-04 3:16 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-04 4:10 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-05 4:46 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-04 7:42 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-04 15:33 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-04 15:57 ` Rik van Riel
2000-05-04 17:19 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan [this message]
2000-05-04 17:41 ` Rik van Riel
2000-05-04 18:18 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-04 18:43 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-04 19:00 ` Rik van Riel
2000-05-04 19:17 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-04 21:16 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-04 21:51 ` Rik van Riel
2000-05-04 22:21 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-05 0:47 ` 7-4 VM killing (A solution) Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-05 1:30 ` Rik van Riel
2000-05-05 1:47 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-05 5:13 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-05 6:44 ` Rajagopal Ananthanarayanan
2000-05-05 6:51 ` Linus Torvalds
2000-05-05 10:23 ` Rik van Riel
2000-05-04 20:40 ` Oops in __free_pages_ok (pre7-1) (Long) (backtrace) Roger Larsson
Reply instructions:
You may reply publicly to this message via plain-text email
using any one of the following methods:
* Save the following mbox file, import it into your mail client,
and reply-to-all from there: mbox
Avoid top-posting and favor interleaved quoting:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Interleaved_style
* Reply using the --to, --cc, and --in-reply-to
switches of git-send-email(1):
git send-email \
--in-reply-to=3911B131.4A565CE0@sgi.com \
--to=ananth@sgi.com \
--cc=davem@redhat.com \
--cc=kanoj@google.engr.sgi.com \
--cc=linux-mm@kvack.org \
--cc=riel@nl.linux.org \
--cc=torvalds@transmeta.com \
/path/to/YOUR_REPLY
https://kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-send-email.html
* If your mail client supports setting the In-Reply-To header
via mailto: links, try the mailto: link
Be sure your reply has a Subject: header at the top and a blank line
before the message body.
This is an external index of several public inboxes,
see mirroring instructions on how to clone and mirror
all data and code used by this external index.