From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 From: Corey Hickey Date: Fri, 12 Mar 2004 09:54:30 +0000 Subject: [LARTC] for testing/examiniation: updated esfq patch for 2.6.4 Message-Id: <405188D6.9000901@fatooh.org> MIME-Version: 1 Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="------------040505080401030201060207" List-Id: To: lartc@vger.kernel.org This is a multi-part message in MIME format. --------------040505080401030201060207 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Since I admin the gateway for a network of bandwidth-greedy machines, I figured that esfq with "hash src" would be a more fair allocation of bandwidth than sfq. Unfortunately, there didn't seem to be a recent patch for 2.6, so I endeavored to build one. The three patches I made (described below) are available within the attached tar.bz2 or at: http://fatooh.org/esfq-2.6/ 1. I downloaded the combined esfq + imq patch from Jim diGriz's QoS Script, at: http://www.digriz.org.uk/jdg-qos-script/ 2. I don't know anything about IMQ, so I extracted the parts that relate to esfq and madified the patch to apply cleanly to 2.6.4. The resulting file is esfq-2.6.patch.old, which seems to work but is marked unsafe upon insmod due to use of deprecated MOD_INC_USE_COUNT/MOD_DEC_USE_COUNT. 3. There have been several updates to sfq since esfq was forked, viewable at: http://linux.bkbits.net:8080/linux-2.5/hist/net/sched/sch_sfq.c?nav=index.html|src/|src/net|src/net/sched I did my best to apply revisions 1.5 - 1.13 to the esfq patch, and the result is esfq-2.6.patch. I made an incremental patch between esfq-2.6.patch.old and esfq-2.6.patch: esfq-2.6.patch.incr In order to use this, you'll need: 1. Some Linux kernel source similar to 2.6.4. 2. esfq-2.6.patch from the attachment or: http://fatooh.org/esfq-2.6/ Patch your source, compile, install. Note that this may prevent tc from using egular sfq until you patch your iproute. 3. Iproute2 source. I used the debianized source from: http://packages.debian.org/testing/net/iproute ...but the vanilla source should work fine. For some reason I can't find a working download right now. 4. The esfq 0.2 patch from: http://www.ssi.bg/~alex/esfq/ Extract the tar.gz and use iproute2-2.2.4-now-ss001007-esfq.diff to patch your iproute2 source. Beware that this may not compile if your distro uses its own headers in /usr/include, and iproute2 needs to reference the patched pkt_sched.h. I don't know what the best way around this is. Please note that I don't really know what I'm doing. The process seemed straightforward enough and so loading and using the new sch_esfq module hasn't caused my computer to crash, complain, melt, or walk away. Actually, it seems to work as expected; however, don't blame me if you use the patch and something starts setting the evil bit on all your packets. I'm posting this partly because I hope somebody who knows about this stuff can fix any problems in the patch that may exist... :) Thanks, Corey --------------040505080401030201060207 Content-Type: application/x-vnd.mozilla.guess-from-ext; name="esfq-2.6.4.tar.bz2" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: inline; filename="esfq-2.6.4.tar.bz2" QlpoOTFBWSZTWf7m7ZkALA3/kPrwAyB9f////+////////8EAAAIYCj++AAAAAAAVQAAAAAA oBQAAEgAAAEqAAAFAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAKAAAAAAAAAAjhiNNNBoA0AAAANBkGmgaADRoAxDQH DEaaaDQBoAAAAaDINNA0AGjQBiGgOGI000GgDQAAAA0GQaaBoANGgDENAcMRppoNAGgAAABo Mg00DQAaNAGIaARSRFPYknpHqaeo00yZpkmJoDNRkDQMnoj1AGhtIAAFSJAgJoBAAJoAKabS aYQwTFJk8p4mp5TYUbT0TU/2JIxNWOf2Zuj0GyFFiBEikVDRhRawsIS+DXwZpsVnKy+T4bfJ 8ctO+jOG8VBLllJJf0D4IMqQf6PMMmFD+B8Xg0f6v7nlf6GRonDeqlUcFGFI+1laqKoqkTIp F0iVQVKR2NFtFmbBnSyklKF0tQulkpSlKJUooXSx9SklsLRSpVKqaqQtgWSUpKaLLRTFJSkU pNz+Jeubk3P9i31pNEkzdZS1llqb7W6ymSjDKlpT2Lex/g7VLWyMkW/9LLUpSlHYZNXY6XVO sq1rumFJhRbRZScFrgolFJSi3UwpgtM16Wu8LMKwtdKukM6KlJlKMlZYmWDJWVrvNbKjMikp FMJaLCopSjClqUpdJLUui1SXUllJLqZUi6VQwSOilpakLLUtUilFDFCx7mMMFKklLstUkUul pRalqKUqRhQ0MsmJKXZaXZZS6Wouyy7LU3rS1JSik2VtTApSkzpCyl0hs3LYUqlUUUKUklMi 0SkpFFHtdJ11Fdl/yXZd2luVOjbdh9TTaYzzt1dNJioqsraVj9LDMpif8KYZsY/CyXiK6OLR or8cb06utthm//hfdm0jHmeGw5vxW0SjotZZRazIwYUOij73/A0YiqRTRowUwoO5gO9RRS1L ZmQmClHFSGiYUtablphKUUYKUpTVLGFIpKQye1btUwolFLPIydbcW/1eB6XWtX9CkdSpOVDo 71KKcnNlnWa1mbN1FsmhTDDC1HnepbVTZdLKbjZhFJRiMmxhhmtkomxmZpRhS1p2KLUaKKUH TF4KRsUwUlKUUaFIUpLqSlIpSaqMmGTC1smbamzo2YUGyUtaU2av/hmzUozUhTN/Mo2O9mbK RRQcFOpSMNuNKwmGFkWolNnoZLZZYYLmFKVJVSW/ztGCv/LZq9bvfIycVGbNLf9vo3cWiUqS Rm+hM5k97uW5p2dPEw5PcetrP2bNur4M0yqqqoqpPhUOGdw8VZP/Le1Qav9HOSblSHmm9VlU rpR8JTFc87aeNd294/Q+l6Humc8K5+ZtRydXlVhpxxn13O1h8HlbQ2SfRERhWntZGIxKkt7C h7CkVEwmFPgwelSM5RPQ1d5+9snkjJ7J9j0j1IbKPQqdSknN/kpTEmJI+qKSTR7nFqSZH8b4 B2pSYdS0zPhIfNvanzH+586j62byNTzP+6mbyNGDewy61ubNhlvZ8XnWd46kh8yNtArlshqA 7oBedgMEEQEEbG1LdnNniWg97reQ/7H/6+91KSdJUNy4d4/gP7h2DvgaY6YazeS4Vy+TVQJC ka5oEEg14II9RB1Cmyanyj1p97yuf430DWPnUfB2tZO9a5InsND+EhS3yzb6mS1qX6FP4GU9 q3rZmZmPtPkYZ6KrVg2mR4J8j/dmcibmRbCyarcmicH6Jmo0lmxab5slNzm5tjmmrE4xrJa1 ObIpLjI4uJwM2Ryo3FFFuTSTacWalKU3qTicZo4NZT8rDm3Kcz6v1fVdrnyfXfdWdZP61y76 3qPwuK3/hTzKKfxJ/8yz0kp8Gb/w3LRk7nsW+JPezkfreVyaMlGr7Nnzs03n5SjIpg9rukS5 /K9RbQ/tjiYe1q6mzJmzO9kw2lH7WhkpRTN2PoPe9hTY3uLvOtOTonxnF8WR1P531FPA/Ypy cnU4rnU5MMHWyavatOj87reU5rcjkpqfyGzRkaFrcjRgzehmwzdpNSh6XfOuehnMzE5vK3pk jNyeRiOx5GTk5O52ujScGymr9T9iOk7ng795Ob0GjedFLjaLYKllMJR2EssoplOJiSSZNSzZ yYOtk+9h9anBuZyp2GI9ThFSUOLtczc0Zvnfgani/1f/hwZJrPJJZ1Lk/Q73I6zNRqww4JOp UpSltx+RRZqpTtazeZP6WFmUtvelsRT8LR3KpWjeflclKUpSnJ4qetTRToqtPfrIzmzZyPKc j0MzpJmlNzeelk0aHpYe16yfI+DV3NnodbdHNmzMn6phq7WjR3MNnucJFp/K73fPldjqcHMd 5T1sPOpwfUWtE/7uwuJ6JT51JShSngqIwlKUkmze3PqfS7HtaPFUtTymx6hvaKSmbJhOjcYU /a73e2KTsaSRQ724b1JRxZzSUpyU9amTcyetvPSopSW9qbhs6O51KcGTe4mrk2PK5y5s7m5m ow4rbH0vcybk5uDRq4NHQyfQ/2dspTo1dRvbnvcmbo8im458FWq6qqVbotvUdqk908SidhLg sp2Pndjmow9qPKKbipKUkpSLr7BcjZ4z3PMUTU9c6PMZs5R/Se310pVVWLJKULqLpVKpFpPc xFRUnNonRbDAVKVKKD7p5E8yTm7Xodb3tGxufQ1cYyPmM396TDyp8FyGhqcGJJ+JT+dUjN/9 lnJG0+Jd0lHxMmjsObDDBoMMMRhiTVTJWRRay0tSri4lPrbFHyJkZv0xufYNU/I72r5m9wdq 5a2TgqQ25lSjnKdTM1KaHi5tx7WU9Boy1UpWRwmqbRjJGE0i9m2aek6GXOapBWOEtFY3SkrF JAZZzVpZZYwcmbDi1cCmrDKcpdJkyYfiWmZwWlLrI1MjwZlOtsZH4r1LW/bTDIws5LZOT4r8 zzvQc/Bks4Pa2joauZZzU7S3tcH6n9U737mmvL6nZjl5Wbqbjcn7jqcG5wbG7+HBhhubzteQ nBPQ3tnAyTDJkw5MmHc4OWEw4HW0OLc6+PVa74Yw2Yjh4yR6JPSH51EpSlKKUpSJKfEUb1qX Ih6FE+d2PE/jZHqilpRSkRBCNsrBbICZAwIqqwFCEKSBWTKVDqkuHRG4tJnCM0VJuSUwidrV OEphoUkD8HzvP9SlvIp1MPRHmZM2Wnxe9nnSu1ru3aq372/dupW22tPOmp6jBMNH3rbJ5TEy UTsVHNFTxcnGHrbmx9D2mxxN5dKVSlE+L9z9Px/c9H73bVqYU/e0Z6553Wuu2NmGmueVUyU5 t73KcVPTIfkUe0uFItP90mJHgxD3vtGzNq4uTmOjJzOcX2pSkUk+kh0ks3JUb0UxCcDvVIXC JSfUYUWwhLFJJbCLJgUQYGC0mCpCYTClKSWkTBUTfGDJRMQlqgzgcDpNlZGUL5gsXg9D1Nz7 H0M2b0nct+F1ujDzgw6HoehOtlnHkkR5HztzmR5jKUcVMhRgYVPcMvr7bYWt2OxTVhqf0PU2 9GbeatmVN7DTSW73R97bKc3kp2LMMPcJm2djZTo4N3cG5hxnBwiMlRsVJSKYYPK7TT7T7kgp 9h62sItUspLLKLfQ7kO+e83Sk8jrKWnNUnkFRhkUUUU1/XasMZFKGhYWsFKUNlSll54uIDPk iEoYjwFWkNdL5nZMXTeAChEbBqHjJlBuC+Tr/P7bYnE47IhNlQlI5AWgCMh2GXYdTUxGTJO/ BqYWlKG6ple7JmzjCVoMKD9sn/t+Y/c0zU2WfQqFqqM3l5vweV5W5yTc1c8A8+bsP8tTlx/e tPYDC21N9DQ9WRvrgc+/JubL3YxKlMRUuPFlj4uCaPJlgp3ntTm/g3dzq2FN6bJlRUjg+daK Yixx06UOUiPsV03BXBOmWK6uWMX2Oy5NXHCqcDc+h1TqOvNuVPJvZ9bMOSa737XOok+oy6aa cdtuprwlp0TvLuprmpinY89VuewzL087fc5c+DmlcJuXx2012OzPXTsn+cpmz38Nd+/Ca5WZ sZ55aZUWlbnW553JP9meOgOFH9CpMsZKueuY6N3nNjs4BuNPJad7g50McdOzLJjZtkxrxwwt bSqpg0ZYzvJjeoep9zmU+3B+l+pTB+Y/c8x/Eo9bM5uKnV2KWO9LMqTNyT2vyPyuxkp/GcXN q6T8y7fjpXttWNd36c9XX341rwvOf2PyVeuen1076dTB1FDe8Wbg72Ht41WnU3mzeoyLdr+Z 2MMPFa2rU3mTcphubHW/g8GjRPUfMdymDPdVdHkcHN+lq8DM4tzweDR5lP0N7JmyT0KdynRR zdTozeK0zSd6kzUjqKJfio9zDm3s2zsYNTyHNhh0cXpW4T/o3r0yWnpqTXtVb+Z2tlHa7HJk 63Y0eVuLLb2jtUek0ZOCnn66rJqp62G9vvg86mjwZMOylvU63RnvbOb0OL0nPgqWpxcXa2f3 t+tFUwwvxw7cTg/pWxR6HqW5+Xt6t91kuc1MSed8JPYo4s1pB/YZR95Jg/qf4rSSj880YJcl FE/IzWxEKRSTNSJLiokmSpBao65SQIZxIJEKtCwglK3TtElRmdYgoGA45OFCoJ1oVFGc3vcQ SAzz4CDJB30nxe57T8cmb+9/VB88P3ltIfcpUGj0iBJiYwGEnMIfkgghrqExJ1BTgR3BYDM+ zaq1KTy5o3v8S0uR0f+na63KZNuwyOjzycyaSW7Jo6J/ek5v7lO1Q3uTBwRLOE7Xe9Z2KdrV J/kTaId78rdDco8rJaTqm0PKkwdkOuC1u4p/W/6v+qnOGaihmUspNCebEO6dEm89Eni3NjJQ U8X+j0O4zd6pGzUmroMn+Dkp/hKWciUTxf4y1LU7YWat8XKmS0OxkimT+BhavtdRZyFJ7RvP K6yZGylIpSj0pMnVC1TkelmcCU0k2Wt7XpeV4yOLkk0W2DuZGgdpobmSlMGHGUGzwDqdGGSj zEs6ix7FI0SpDBDcU3NzxaJLDKHY5tXY3OKRct2m5spSUzUtcG+DWGHRmMymcNGRzaI4NmbV ZvNjskb2xsqKUpS09anVJ1MmbeYW60O5zM0TJoUpSk63eObgdp972u6TNDkaHJzMpOxxeumh T1D6X8p8qfRFRh/RMSlTCYmCxRTC0lwmCiYkwKlFSPtfrn6E/Ut9ZU+9iYG4os/PdKZNFmbc WqXJZmt+dhUYuqqkZykq9TxftMjJkalzCp0JyTrR1w9B6jvPB5n0tEecXBhh5g0jWW+D3JLZ M1KN6RS4KTcUUfKZH5yWgS6DyF3w3FTbV4ALi5QV1VmB5wD9a0mchRKVEoj/Fo4pszSbSUM1 MlLW95iJJq1aM2SijCMok88YJszNXsZDZP53qfBJyQZGccG9LQyTcWSkVJJMhoP2OA5E95bM 1b3AtZvSTJKarS00fKaJJO6TR988IXMksqigtT+1Co6KT5Wb+t+lxd8TJyScU+V0ci1s0zcX FCeRT8KZH/R9g0Wng/a3Dc8pmTD9ZPzqiWecbnUo3tmanN5jET1tGA/wZnjEnW1M2R8zxYam b979LsYHlc4TVPnSilJSkRPCTk63tkWyTYp7HnkiOqdZwdrcwIw9MnBhcjVaHmOboHnT6m91 PiclJ6XxXDCkQpBSUklDNaGabOD2vzz/FJ8G8eop5j4SHJR/h8pybKHBzlRPfEySYVIYlrgw nF6YxFTymEVapTDJGjk1ZMKZJOg3DmjlJODRubnBgoopTzN03sLWhFKkkZODccCim9M5IktN VmG9SVCpRTRpJwamyQUeVoSx+tP0LW7mxhNe6EHWXJxfc4vJJqPWUUUS3Wtq5x5cm43hnMML MypKKaTcwuW3JqmrRYpbZhFpUlIpH5hUjJKFRQ3MtmS5KblKMjKWfTKaEpQbNFhRhKKZqWta lqzgzkzkklSaLSzsT6DpIk7pRcRueRsnWUh2JJORQ1Jo3GS3scXYfwUdZyJ3Kkhg7DhGEpaU taKSUllXdy0lsLjFDsKOtmjgaMMJozTyuxhrJJP+Z+1MHR+OJ9yUiiikwdanBOLit/aqOajC mbi+dHeSlGzKZksYbjQyZmzZxRNE2aSaPwPMeRP+XJhRs9rDvKNFKamTqSSaneo9zrWzKN60 cH2tj5X0m9xbmyhTetbJlHBzcnNrN6mz5n1MzKfgOtbRszTDkmjByM2g5JsiUwpMzrWTVg0c W5hzOboNJxTNZLaIwm4pOJLU5JMMylKak1NQ3GH4DVkMFQdFQ1KODZvaNYJOjgyMJmwSNU0R btbxhhORkzmR2ODczRapxiJsW9jJ7TmfjZvI8idpudxTmW+h4yRghHFTNSUUqqrrU63JLdbR uRFujrYMk2Zj4GyDId06+aifOyTypoQnW4vBzGjrGDNhbRyVpSvM3Mmw/UnCf7/8ez4/Sdbz EUnvFJ3LLUilFSi1FolFFSSUSj6iyyUlqUqH+SZMilGJJJyeVSjwW7J4A86Pa80KTVcpJGFP Qc3ctmZN0SSnmkiXI1SieVaZJUkTzlFNw9YySQ7uyqqrHvbEJ6iT5HwKfUp/SpMLZsM1SLiU S3vYWcXkamTJbrkMQ1WlsKSZFKRwSYH3qaodT1LedbZwk80ZSZo8skkhot4oKnMqbpRuRxUU initFoW6OxlIdcmbqSkieA5k4NHn4pxi3nTRalyOhZSlp8CizJkNFDJ2LGSoYasE9TZkMM7L fOwWME0FLktZmYhKIpJRRMlbys2pvRYzamdH5Gy0mFJkVDVwSSU1aM4mcikk0EqJKIpKblJP zKaJ4KOCjxkxIt9yi4fcMpLkmapHJ1LTCkpkmjZOLk6lkn5lFFRSpNEnU0kiT2Mk2TJb7EpN VKKdzwWjZKaI4pzbhzidapJyPkZJOw2XDvkwehkpwTyKPgohlI9j6T95T6mDzO9JOR3MicHy neGakkKVE+Z9rKJ/qjqMKYbJOtDokTwfAJknQp60p6TI1fOm8J0EYZOiOp4HvavOOtJJmPD5 Yn80oM4ibjqciNXxWfKt1TVvUGjZ5DYj0MJmjRmmEpKkU+H04YTZubpEiiHldYlKKVE6mrR7 j87B7lPxrU/sf5MKWyOj4re83smHrHpTynsZKKhRSUoUe6SR3Pkkko7z1pk+prPakp7mFlMM LSpZVpaSlJSe9PY2GT65bzpukk9ESZJN47WhvU+V3m5kLKRktTZ2lECmShrMw9SD2xJbeTR4 I+xwPpkOSUnB3lDBcw8WGcWoHbPxM2bJa1QcWZUji4NzT4qI1O1SUpRSYSUomjVTQ3x1RR0K h86hTOUWuW1bnU/lKFubMnpWs1UfWotvWp0dyUpHAzchhKLIdwO8VJOLDJ2Gs5ySOpR1pMze 1SeDJQ/MuJLHrQtSdjgpG9wTvSDiM3Bk8iiUyeMZsHn3KcZNYO5onykyeEjJUzb29q8xuWkj I7FKLRHhNG5kdxRk+ZgpRhN8NE5z0P62iZDKMiSoWjclyPiphMicHFSlwwqPYotkyYllJTCf +1NFKFMLcVSqMKVaKtSqWtc+6TJP7Gy0ZrKLkg5yWxMMKhS1qSoUtaKYeZkwyg+9QjMyUWkf FIm9OM5M1pm9idyRopP82H5WTsZsMJ9z4nnVCkfcuTxUmCR4JOIpSpKnWFy2D+lYTuUFDJ0c HJ1vWoatZqMFpEswTCoSiim9MMMFNWDDKJKYWykSKOCT9z2PYn8hQn1KPg2bnuUj5UmaUm0l k5RoR8ihb43wWwLkql46JScsqOmK2SkZwgbeYVSfCSnraTucGw6EaGFwmEnYTJyTJkjdGbsT dGiidAoXPrcZRSnrLT7XG1PYSk9TqW5SWi1qU+9SYkPIncGb4j4jrR3PFPsd4npVJO9azYmC WPnRk2ZJ1Mjm+xks1Jq5rSZDg6nUdj1KLZTopGczRa5VVlDVmzYSpIfTJ8GJG9SpzMzCedBR 4vnLMHzDVRHNSSZKkyYUsraOAjmn3DzI2ZFN0RuWpsww3E6SJaUg5qRzkRKOEybk9Eh5x0iy USooKXJxf3shZSoWsaQwKlQopQfIwLtRKVOyLkyZs4dsYRcmhS5KWtkxCzBUlKKJa4tSpTDA wMplCxQYSyepJiIspjNUMlSplKhQspklRKkLTODZB1JKSQOsOp1kljJJyUIwo2KiZvFTeihZ RVKpqmHtw+Z2qKke8958BgYSmakeK1KSylKBUN60MhTC0tY9Ek1YH87rW9zgczgkR64UwzU3 rUYWYew6HtbyTiUKYnVVK1OZ3OSegWtOs6O+JJ75I6k4utCmFSjggswMKGTJ1oKSpEqcE4tG p1ThCc2RKT1sxtJNxQ4KTeWWko8Y1PSySI8exuhBzcXgaKfBmzUySZnwSx8jRzU2O1MPkUdq jcVHBwaN7Ipg0MHvWZGDNQ+yUwpweZOUnBXNUsrgsU1ZqaMItlzdzEwwycnQzdTZvU4MmEFp 3Hkc5EetPAe0lyfikLTyFNCMTM8wURg9KMIKkknamSbjvd6eKPOeZ2LWM2Uk1MnJoMKg3qJS kpRSi1REixUiGaA3KcWbRR5JJuSJ3puZGcdZajUo7GJIwyUmYzTCZCiWW61JMPwsMGUlMzRS lJ2MIcZPO62UmRk6pJNVvM/VMzJ2JP43e1icHYU3mkgs7TvMjxI4UlUTvJ9DJN6bluksc3hE 3FFeut+SmSlSFyFSRRgllwpayaOb6G5uc0yeZZUw62cwU0MPOwYhQ1M3W+MiehvN0tqwmJUm SUYLkkmRvjJmphke1oo7GbNTcoW1ambZckZTNY3KeVhvalI1eYuTm5uDmowYMo5GMxaimTDN a1sGrRVVWFExFKTBarFCOSDgatGrVjNQtSU1atEykaSS5cRRRwNGZ9qLOMkRwjsTxhObtXIb Nz8LqInJRNybNw38Cm5R2FGrm1YYTVknBqeQ8gOyROCgjVqKIYaFksW4NybxG9yU1cSRTN3N FKipSUU4KkUs3tVyI2NXWpLJRPsSyZu5Mms9KcU4qVNxqXBDY5qYWtyJak+CZRJ2pEZRJPkK dJyehTzzvHA2pOpOp97pNimE9JNW58Ik/a5MoQepIOolKkhRSmZP0ygUUp9KSdTNT3A7Z53i eDuiSmcM5NB2nYO2RLkoop2wpTV0aG5IinRcST+Zybh/ydGqlPa3yJHvfsdsGZ4JZPU3ijvY YTC0qSSzz+iw7RsaFCmHWUdxR6imZktLSZkuTM0MRDBKKJ7ZEj+pLiMKU/ignILFJSSR+NST c862TvYdzyqYTJonkdU9DikuHW1f1u+JOs0hJ2ncUtYin9w/jWMlJSIyIUtSKlin88Af+LuS KcKEh/c3bMg= --------------040505080401030201060207-- _______________________________________________ LARTC mailing list / LARTC@mailman.ds9a.nl http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/