Re: [LARTC] please advise me in HTB and HFSC

[Andy Furniss <lists@andyfurniss.entadsl.com>]

*~ r a K u ~ * wrote:
> now i'm read a lot of knowledge paper about traffic control in linux because now 
> i'm try to develop and research about traffic shaper so can everybody tell me 
> about my topic ... Is it can do for real????
> 
> my topic is "
> now, many organization use traffic shaper for control traffic and bandwidth 
> because don't want something example
> some mac address, ip address, traffic in that port or that application use a lot 
> of bandwidth more than it appropriate should use  example if people in 
> organization try to use p2p application ,it may make a lot of problem for all 
> bandwidth in organization
> 
> now most famous algorithm to manage queue in mastershaper is "HTB" but i have 
> just read some paper their tell about
> "HFSC" algorithm ,it's very good to manage real-time application traffic so i 
> think may be performance when HTB manage real-time application are not work if i 
> comparable with performance by HFSC"
> 
> so my project is ... i want to develop new traffic shaper that use 2 algorithm 
> simultaneously (HTB for manage general traffic and HFSC for manage only real 
> time application) by when the package come in my shaper outbound i will have one 
> filter for
> filtering that package about what kind of that package??(general or real time 
> application package) and then after filtering it will continue send that package 
> to appropriate queue to mananage shaper later"
> 
> sorry for my bad english so much
> may be you don't understand my project topic so looking in my picture.
> 
> 
>                        ________   (general package)
>      outbound    |             |------------------------------ HTB
> ------eth0-----------     filter  |
>                       |_______ |------------------------------- HFSC
>                                         (real time application package) 
> 
> now my problem is... i read a lot paper they tell if i want to use traffic 
> shaper in outbound side. In linux i must use tc command for setting it, but it's 
> telling me about setting algoritm will start to set in root qdisc and root qdisc 
> is outboud side
> so i fear about i can't setting 2 algorithm simultaneously
> 
> so please advise me , if you think i'm misunderstand and Is it can do for 
> real??? what should i do???

You only have one link so should only normally use one shaper.

Andy.
_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list
LARTC@mailman.ds9a.nl
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/lartc