Re: data corruption with nvidia chipsets and IDE/SATA drives // memory hole mapping related bug?!

[Christoph Anton Mitterer <calestyo@scientia.net>]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 2748 bytes --]

Robert Hancock wrote:
>> What is that GART thing exactly? Is this the hardware IOMMU? I've always
>> thought GART was something graphics card related,.. but if so,.. how
>> could this solve our problem (that seems to occur mainly on harddisks)?
>>     
> The GART built into the Athlon 64/Opteron CPUs is normally used for 
> remapping graphics memory so that an AGP graphics card can see 
> physically non-contiguous memory as one contiguous region. However, 
> Linux can also use it as an IOMMU which allows devices which normally 
> can't access memory above 4GB to see a mapping of that memory that 
> resides below 4GB. In pre-2.6.20 kernels both the SATA and PATA 
> controllers on the nForce 4 chipsets can only access memory below 4GB so 
> transfers to memory above this mark have to go through the IOMMU. In 
> 2.6.20 this limitation is lifted on the nForce4 SATA controllers.
>   
Ah, I see. Thanks for that introduction :-)


>> Does this mean that PATA is no related? The corruption appears on PATA
>> disks to, so why should it only solve the issue at SATA disks? Sounds a
>> bit strange to me?
>>     
> The PATA controller will still be using 32-bit DMA and so may also use 
> the IOMMU, so this problem would not be avoided.
>   
>   
>> Can you explain this a little bit more please? Is this a drawback (like
>> a performance decrease)? Like under Windows where they never use the
>> hardware iommu but always do it via software?
>>     
>
> No, it shouldn't cause any performance loss. In previous kernels the 
> nForce4 SATA controller was controlled using an interface quite similar 
> to a PATA controller. In 2.6.20 kernels they use a more efficient 
> interface that NVidia calls ADMA, which in addition to supporting NCQ 
> also supports DMA without any 4GB limitations, so it can access all 
> memory directly without requiring IOMMU assistance.
>
> Note that if this corruption problem is, as has been suggested, related 
> to memory hole remapping and the IOMMU, then this change only prevents 
> the SATA controller transfers from experiencing this problem. Transfers 
> on the PATA controller as well as any other devices with 32-bit DMA 
> limitations might still have problems. As such this really just avoids 
> the problem, not fixes it.
>   
Ok,.. that sounds reasonable,.. so the whole thing might (!) actually be
a hardware design error,... but we just don't use that hardware any
longer when accessing devices via sata_nv.

So this doesn't solve our problem with PATA drives or other devices
(although we had until now no reports of errors with other devices) and
we have to stick with iommu=soft.

If one use iommu=soft the sata_nv will continue to use the new code for
the ADMA, right?


Best wishes,
Chris.

[-- Attachment #2: calestyo.vcf --]
[-- Type: text/x-vcard, Size: 156 bytes --]

begin:vcard
fn:Mitterer, Christoph Anton
n:Mitterer;Christoph Anton
email;internet:calestyo@scientia.net
x-mozilla-html:TRUE
version:2.1
end:vcard