Re: [patch 6/6] Guest page hinting: s390 support.

[Jeremy Fitzhardinge <jeremy@goop.org>]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1474 bytes --]

Martin Schwidefsky wrote:
> The state transitions (a diagram would be nicer but that is too hard
> to do in ascii art...):
> {Ur,Sr,Vr,Pr}: a resident page will change its block usage state if the
>      guest requests it with page_set_{unused,stable,volatile}.
> {Uz,Sz,Vz}: a logically zero page will change its block usage state if the
>      guest requests it with page_set_{unused,stable,volatile}. The
>      guest can't create the Pz state, the state will be Vz instead.
> Ur -> Uz: the host system can remove an unused, resident page from memory
> Sz -> Sr: on first access a stable, logically zero page will become resident
> Sr -> Sp: the host system can swap a stable page to disk
> Sp -> Sr: a guest access to a Sp page forces the host to retrieve it
> Vr -> Vz: the host can discard a volatile page
> Sp -> Uz: a page preserved by the host will be removed if the guest sets 
>      the block usage state to unused.
> Sp -> Vz: a page preserved by the host will be discarded if the guest sets
>      the block usage state to volatile.
> Pr -> Sp: the host can move a page from Pr to Sp if it discovers that the
>      page is dirty while trying to discard the page. The page content is
>      written to the paging device.
> Pr -> Vz: the host can discard a Pr page. The Pz state is replaced by the
>      Vz state.

I created the attached .dot graph based purely on this description.  It 
looks reasonable, but I didn't see how a page enters a Pr state.

    J

[-- Attachment #2: gph.dot --]
[-- Type: text/plain, Size: 1039 bytes --]

digraph gph {
	Ur -> Sr [ label="page_set_stable" ];
	Ur -> Vr [ label="page_set_volatile" ];
	Ur -> Ur [ label="page_set_unused" ];

	Sr -> Sr [ label="page_set_stable" ];
	Sr -> Vr [ label="page_set_volatile" ];
	Sr -> Ur [ label="page_set_unused" ];

	Vr -> Sr [ label="page_set_stable" ];
	Vr -> Vr [ label="page_set_volatile" ];
	Vr -> Ur [ label="page_set_unused" ];

	Uz -> Sz [ label="page_set_stable" ];
	Uz -> Vz [ label="page_set_volatile" ];
	Uz -> Uz [ label="page_set_unused" ];

	Sz -> Sz [ label="page_set_stable" ];
	Sz -> Vz [ label="page_set_volatile" ];
	Sz -> Uz [ label="page_set_unused" ];

	Vz -> Sz [ label="page_set_stable" ];
	Vz -> Vz [ label="page_set_volatile" ];
	Vz -> Uz [ label="page_set_unused" ];

	Ur -> Uz [ label="host evict" ];

	Sz -> Sr [ label="guest write" ];
	Sr -> Sp [ label="host swap" ];
	Sp -> Sr [ label="guest access" ];

	Sp -> Uz [ label="guest discard" ];
	Sp -> Vz [ label="page_set_volatile" ];

	Pr -> Sp [ label="host discard dirty" ];
	Pr -> Vz [ label="host discard clean" ];
}

[-- Attachment #3: gph.pdf --]
[-- Type: application/pdf, Size: 14976 bytes --]