Re: MACHINE_EXTRA_* and MACHINE_ESSENTIAL_* documentation

[Darren Hart <darren.hart@intel.com>]

On 09/21/2011 02:29 PM, Darren Hart wrote:
> This is something I've run into frequently and have been putting off
> trying to resolve. Hopefully the following will help illustrate the path
> a BSP developer might go down trying to use the MACHINE_ESSENTIAL* and
> MACHINE_EXTRA* variables. If someone with more knowledge on the subject
> could fill in the gaps noted below, I'll be happy to test and work with
> Scott to improve the documentation.
> 
> I am unable to discern from the following text in the reference manual,
> which variable I should be using to include a firmware package in the
> images for a given BSP.
> 
> From
> http://www.yoctoproject.org/docs/1.1/poky-ref-manual/poky-ref-manual.html:
> 
> "
> MACHINE_ESSENTIAL_RDEPENDS
> 
>     List of packages required to boot device
> MACHINE_ESSENTIAL_RRECOMMENDS
> 
>     List of packages required to boot device (usually additional kernel
> modules)

As Saul points out, these should be:

MACHINE_ESSENTIAL_EXTRA_*


> MACHINE_EXTRA_RDEPENDS
> 
>     List of packages required to use device
> MACHINE_EXTRA_RRECOMMNEDS  (<-- typo still present)
> 
>     List of packages useful to use device (for example additional kernel
> modules)
> "
> 
> From the above, I don't learn anything about what the impact of using
> each of these variables is. Which ones add the packages to the rootfs,
> which only build them, do they impact the initrd (one might assume a
> package required for boot should be in the initrd). The difference
> between RDEPENDS and RRECOMMENDS is unclear. Three of the four use the
> term "required" while the other uses "useful" in the description.
> Neither semantic split (RDEPENDS vs. RRECOMMENDS, ESSENTIAL vs. EXTRA)
> can be understood from the available descriptions.
> 
> The firmware I want to add is needed for wireless functionality. This is
> likely not required for boot, so I added it to MACHINE_EXTRA_RRECOMMENDS
> as it is only needed if the wireless driver is used. This resulted in
> the package being built, but not installed. In practice this would mean
> that people building the BSP would need to manually add the firmware
> package to IMAGE_INSTALL or install it manually later. This strikes me
> as unnecessarily complex.
> 
> This was also unexpected given the definition of RRECOMMENDS in the
> manual, which would have led me to believe the package should have been
> installed:
> 
> "
> RRECOMMENDS
> 
>     List of packages which extend usability of the package. Those
> packages will be automatically installed but can be removed by user.
> "


Paul E. explained that RRECOMMENDS differs from RDEPENDS in that if a
RRECOMMENDS package is not available (because the providing recipe
doesn't build it - like a custom linux kernel not building a particular
module) the image build will continue and not error out.


> I wasn't able to find a general meaning for the term "EXTRA" by
> searching through the manual.
> 
> I then tried the remaining 3 variables, doing the following after
> setting each:
> 
> $ bitbake -c cleanall task-machine-base task-core-boot
> linux-firmware-core-image-sato
> $ bitbake -u depexp -g core-image-sato
> $ bitbake core-image-sato
> 
> I then determined if the linux-firmware package appeared in the list
> presented by the depexp UI and whether or not the linux-firmware package
> was built and installed. The results follow:
> 
> MACHINE_EXTRA_RDEPENDS = "linux-firmware-iwlwifi-6000g2a-5"
> # appears in depexp with no rdepends, builds, does not install
> 
> #MACHINE_EXTRA_RECOMMENDS += "linux-firmware-iwlwifi-6000g2a-5"
> # does not appear in depexp, does not build
> 
> #MACHINE_ESSENTIAL_RDEPENDS = "linux-firmware-iwlwifi-6000g2a-5"
> # does not appear in depexp, does not build


If I use the appropriate MACHINE_ESSENTIAL_EXTRA_RDEPENDS here, the
package is built, but it is not included in the final image.


> I've tried searching the sources for these variables, and quickly lose
> their scent. Here is what I did find:
> 
> task-base.bb:
> #
> # packages added by machine config
> #
> RDEPENDS_task-machine-base = "${MACHINE_EXTRA_RDEPENDS}"
> RRECOMMENDS_task-machine-base = "${MACHINE_EXTRA_RRECOMMENDS}"
> 
> task-core-boot.bb:
> RDEPENDS_task-core-boot = "\
>     ...
>     ${MACHINE_ESSENTIAL_EXTRA_RDEPENDS}"
> 
> RRECOMMENDS_task-core-boot = "\
>     ${MACHINE_ESSENTIAL_EXTRA_RRECOMMENDS}"
> 
> 
> How these should impact the final image is not clear to me.
> 
> 
> Thanks,
> 


-- 
Darren Hart
Intel Open Source Technology Center
Yocto Project - Linux Kernel