[RESEND PATCH 1/1] clk: add DT support for clock gating control

[robherring2@gmail.com (Rob Herring)]

On 07/13/2012 04:42 AM, Sebastian Hesselbarh wrote:
> On 07/13/2012 05:19 AM, Rob Herring wrote:
>> What's implemented in Linux should not define the binding. The binding
>> should describe the hardware.
>> [...]
>> True, but not your problem to implement. A binding doesn't necessarily
>> mean there is a full Linux implementation. We just don't want to create
>> something only to find others need something completely different.
> 
> Ok, what about a DT describing the following for a simple register-based
> clock gating controller and the corresponding gated-clock independent of
> the controller. I am sure there are a bunch of SoCs out there that
> control their clock gates by writing some bits to a register. If that
> DT description matches your expectations, I ll prepare patches with
> documentation and implementation for common clock framework.
> 

Clock gates are just 1 part. There's muxes, dividers, plls, etc. I'm not
convinced that it makes sense to define clocks at this level. For
complex chips, I think just defining the chips clock controller module
as a single node with lots of clock outputs. The primary need is to
describe board specific changes not SOC level clock tree. Much of it is
static and generally only a few clocks may change config board to board.

> Sebastian
> 
> -- 
>  /* Simple clock gating controller based on bitmasks and register */
> cgc: clock-gating-control at f1000000 {
>   compatible = "clock-gating-control-register";
>   reg = <0xf1000000 0x4>;
> 
>   /* Clock gating control with one bit at bit position 0
>      enable with (1<<0), disable with (0<<0) */
>   cgctrl_usb0: cgc_usb0 {
>     clock-gating-control,shift = <0>;
>     clock-gating-control,mask = <1>;
>     clock-gating-control,enable = <1>;
>     clock-gating-control,disable = <0>;
>   };
> 
>   /* Clock gating control with two bits at bit position 1-2
>      enable with (2<<1), disable with (0<<1) */
>   cgctrl_sata: cgc_sata {
>     clock-gating-control,shift = <1>;
>     clock-gating-control,mask = <3>;
>     clock-gating-control,enable = <2>;
>     clock-gating-control,disable = <0>;
>   };
> };
> 
> /* Generic clock gate description that can be used with
>    any clock gating controller */
> cg_usb0: clockgate at 0 {
>   compatible = "gated-clock";
>   #clock-cells = <0>;
>   clocks = <&osc>;
>   clock-gate-control = <&cgctrl_usb0>;
> };

I don't see this scaling to ~50 clocks.

Rob