Re: [Celinux-dev] [PATCH] LDT - Linux Driver Template

[Tim Bird <tim.bird@am.sony.com>]

My apologies.  As celinux-dev list administrator, I messed up my
moderation and this response from Greg got discarded instead of
sent to the list.

Here it is, sent by me on Greg's behalf...
 -- Tim

On Wed, Nov 14, 2012 at 02:14:58AM +0200, Constantine Shulyupin wrote:
> On Tue, Nov 13, 2012 at 9:01 PM, Greg KH <gregkh@linuxfoundation.org> wrote:
>>> +#define pr_debug_hex(h)      pr_debug("%s:%d %s %s = 0x%lX\n", \
>>> +     __file__, __LINE__, __func__, #h, (long int)h)
>>
>> This is not needed at all, just use the proper printk() attribute.
>
> Macro above allows tidy tracing code:
>
>         pr_debug_hex(ioread8(port_ptr + UART_IER));
>         pr_debug_hex(ioread8(port_ptr + UART_IIR));
>         pr_debug_hex(ioread8(port_ptr + UART_FCR));
>         pr_debug_hex(ioread8(port_ptr + UART_LCR));
>         pr_debug_hex(ioread8(port_ptr + UART_MCR));
>         pr_debug_hex(ioread8(port_ptr + UART_LSR));
>         pr_debug_hex(ioread8(port_ptr + UART_MSR));
>
> Without that macro, code above should be rewritten with pr_debug (or printk) as:
>
>         pr_debug("UART_IER=0x%02X\n", ioread8(port_ptr + UART_IER));
>         pr_debug("UART_IIR=0x%02X\n", ioread8(port_ptr + UART_IIR));
>         pr_debug("UART_FCR=0x%02X\n", ioread8(port_ptr + UART_FCR));
>         pr_debug("UART_LCR=0x%02X\n", ioread8(port_ptr + UART_LCR));
>         pr_debug("UART_MCR=0x%02X\n", ioread8(port_ptr + UART_MCR));
>         pr_debug("UART_LSR=0x%02X\n", ioread8(port_ptr + UART_LSR));
>         pr_debug("UART_MSR=0x%02X\n", ioread8(port_ptr + UART_MSR));
>
> That is less readable and less supportable.

What better is to not do foolish stuff like this at all

If you need tracing, use the in-kernel tracing framework, don't roll
your own.

> I prefer the fist case.

I prefer the flower case :)

> Actually I use a lot shorter macro:
> #define traceh(h)   printk("%s = 0x%lX\n", #h, (long int)h)
>
> What is you opinion? Which method is better?

Again, neither, don't clutter your code up with unneeded things like
this.

greg k-h