From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 From: Steven Haigh Subject: Re: HVMs terminating as (null) Date: Sun, 24 Nov 2013 06:56:03 +1100 Message-ID: <52910853.1090708@crc.id.au> References: <5290D480.1000804@crc.id.au> <20131123192746.GA21689@aepfle.de> <52910427.5020507@crc.id.au> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="===============7488528087119256630==" Return-path: In-Reply-To: <52910427.5020507@crc.id.au> List-Unsubscribe: , List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: , Sender: xen-devel-bounces@lists.xen.org Errors-To: xen-devel-bounces@lists.xen.org To: xen-devel@lists.xen.org List-Id: xen-devel@lists.xenproject.org This is an OpenPGP/MIME signed message (RFC 4880 and 3156) --===============7488528087119256630== Content-Type: multipart/signed; micalg=pgp-sha1; protocol="application/pgp-signature"; boundary="MEAPmvE1V5CC3abXev2j36isnBcqmsf1v" This is an OpenPGP/MIME signed message (RFC 4880 and 3156) --MEAPmvE1V5CC3abXev2j36isnBcqmsf1v Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="------------090205030503090908030203" This is a multi-part message in MIME format. --------------090205030503090908030203 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable On 24/11/13 06:38, Steven Haigh wrote: > On 24/11/13 06:27, Olaf Hering wrote: >> On Sun, Nov 24, Steven Haigh wrote: >> >>> Running Xen 4.2.3 with all the current XSA fixes. >> >> How exactly did you start the guests? >=20 > The DomUs were started with: xl create /etc/xen/ >=20 >> Does 'ps faxu' show qemu processes for the listed domain_ids? >> What is the 'xenstore-ls -f | sort' output? >=20 > I'll have to check this when I manage to reproduce it. So far, I have > been unable to get a reliable way to reproduce it. I managed to get a > system to do it every time a HVM DomU was shutdown OR restarted - but > after a reboot of the Dom0 I can't get it into that state again. >=20 > As soon as I can get a system in this state again, I'll leave it to see= > what information I can extract. Ha! As always, as soon as I send this, I notice its happened on a Dom0. # xl list Name ID Mem VCPUs State Time(s) Domain-0 0 1579 2 r----- 2731.3 planner.vm 1 1013 1 -b---- 189.3 (null) 2 0 1 --psrd 301.1 tracker.vm 3 1013 2 -b---- 834.4 Attached is the output of: # xl debug-keys q # xl dmesg > xen-dmesg.log # gzip xen-dmesg.log > Does 'ps faxu' show qemu processes for the listed domain_ids? I only see a qemu process for the running DomUs - no dead or extra ones. > What is the 'xenstore-ls -f | sort' output? Attached as xenstore-ls.log.gz --=20 Steven Haigh Email: netwiz@crc.id.au Web: https://www.crc.id.au Phone: (03) 9001 6090 - 0412 935 897 Fax: (03) 8338 0299 --------------090205030503090908030203 Content-Type: application/gzip; name="xen-dmesg.log.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="xen-dmesg.log.gz" H4sICCEGkVIAA3hlbi1kbWVzZy5sb2cA1Vttc+JGEv6eX9Gp+xA7ZbEzIwGCK6cOA7apGJsA 69tULkUNmpGtMkisJLx2kv3v16MXkLBsWK3qNkeqYjTqfrpnpvuZ7rF3Nvtr9td/ZrPZO/gO vurz3dGH/vUxfJAuPEo/cDwXjBqr6XC09KyH+dpZiH9ZvlVzRI2vj+HozrLg6KLbPUYxo9YE RigjOkX5sRRwycN4XNOPj2GyduHaewRKgLA2abYNE/qTqdLRE7tXPJRBCN177t7JiQzbsHb5 I3cWfL6QicyZ54ULjwvpt+Hi+j1cjN+fAam1msn7rrdcclfAwnFlG6zV2vblx9MnnJHwlmS2 5E+zRxwNThl84qF1L7y7RPPWEdIDx7U9f8lDnHs7eQG3Fx1wAgjlUwhLT0gwyROrn4DtuSGY T7SxETzrv+v1urCU4b0ngjbcsn9CvzfoQehzN7ClD6GzRL8oBNLyXBEkmj0nsApNn3trnAyB 4dkYAufO5eHal0H+LUMTvaw2BKG/trKSuKOaNBmBcWcIS77a4JOdD2jZoRa3cOhoHagNOC7Q iQVyOjyCOULb0n+UokhLvrBEyV4tuuufNTd0Qd7wbyOQ02nakU6nOxrA9e2kSCsWyWnZ4m3/ NiJZrTql+2wlIlmtBm3ss5WI5LWab69FIpDXMff5l4jktBjbagke8iK1WCavNt9rLBbJaRmt vYsRi+S0TGuvrVgkq2VGP19fQmHFAlsdkfx8wz9bCrpjCYfYPi2b7Nii6avXtbYiWy1mplr5 WamVacN40hsp0XNiUHKC35iB8AxgcD3tX+VlP0x6U+ieNRjpU1PJ1rsoS2NRgN5lvT7tqkOE kiZOrwXDyfk0fkaGz2Od4w+FRc97rQjrXNk1SmH1Er8wUJVfjVZXL/Yr/hD14gpPHYKpR5sv /JpEczR7RrQeBsm974wG3djv83gNut1ovcr4PUn9Pu9GWNTov+U3TbD0eF/zWMPu+UXkN038 0g/cG/y0dtbgctSP95n2473RzbexOsNBLfVyZ46dyfn3cczEcyQdFb56wYKlk5yeT4bq27nB DLKz0cPOOAY7i8HOXnEsxYo2On1KsSbPQSiX6hxsg2629OEZHOkts9HUGw9nqVDPW3LHhXvJ V3iuOqHDF04gRc4dnb1rGB/ikOFCYFIGsHSCpSoqUAlf4P5qoFjNlAZ5l6U5U6jwWgeOe4c4 CezI9ywE8Xz4B4FGux5HW1qHMfpSjB4mZhwmVn9DbHCjxn8jv7eBrxxr5mBNcrIR09nJZgnI ky1jnjyBi8kAiMbS8q7vIgOpKUc2VCHVxo1e8BDD5320Frhn726i12nhEo8H1r0U64Wq+SZD ZA5fCieESToKR1Y0stk+GUorxApUpy1WozrmzuUfsEqnWksnpXYW0Zdy6fnPENxzHx/Tt6Mu bvK1FybbFKUYVlhYuN0tJdZ9EavO1zhjoun2BjKUC7idagIcLETXqtBbr1aer7xZ8TuJRdwf EgtD4+Gs9poOKaHDvkhn4nreCktlN/S9Bbg4San2RooCWcwFonIPRjwIwnvfW9/d71H5ZS3X 6MfAfcS8EXFJ+raG+ur761UIY4nl6Uqt+NsaE9wttNEfTSFUMkGhPEbTo+OHa5W/sR+JRHp0 avH84mAcywV/2rzb+uRvfBJOkFXvx2A47McB178ZwCcnRALwojzh1sPMWwjw3O9TlevO2dXg +gJTSovyYDD+ZVPPaz8lAa90Ot2fk0YijUhMFVXjRz2ErzoSatR0aqrgVqyd0tNi4VlceYMd RuAtJPgRpA20AT87m3i4HX7AdNpEDReP3LXwiy3jJqO9XaPI0eFwcAPcUjm0s6g7gtPRWCWT 8D5tX/SfQukKRB+p4JzGO3aEu3e8lbmNQbUtJw0EZppjO8gzcHQ7GvReSsP1cLAdHE7GyWZo iadzJ8TN20q8d3Fqoe9E23Wxxu/Ju8vboTqwBr1gN4qiN7haO7ETDV9yX3zCSIROEDhBGE9Q LffRZWd0DCJhopxKZ7SboifAhmdpgxtlGNLOCgzojt6nwTFFVxUwznfTuYKmaUoGDwzvgT/X ou80851lvuvJ9wTvxx9/hKubTk/FYu9m2BlcI/HgYLpU6hIAHqTvykUbGoaGC3kCi2B+gmG1 XPFwc27FGbQrOer0E/GVOhrwXKBpcfqTerCtOj6kkX3562TQ7VzBsD+8Gf8KnfG4c33RH/av p+2cFa5iu9aGbc1L48OGaD9tSt5NodxiBKuFaLGxe/dgLmMAlRybSFKnQA18vsTcfmhvC+c6 a5p53KZt242Nz7eD8fT92y5fqXsKsVkaO/mYNHV5O5Jbjl2fdsUyioYwrK1PMLp/DrQhxwpE NfmQFRN5xbphtgTfKE5C7ofRHYJaXMiK8ReK3JgbG4sqkmMGbu8ozncV5zwzR3WRA0GIDLlr cf7C4nyeUZzeTDtX7U2dtxEjL1a1Ho+lirg1aqN6vXF/MsmuqmlYVKZiUZzdcyzm+JOzXC/x aL3NpOHE8tfzuUrEc1/KuI6sCc+VuaoCeWnhfUorC2TLj4BHpwzuFbEHMgSOBcSToaI0is5U eRKKGobN3UI+qojp+76H1Kfus5BkXLSauhExV0YSC5X7iHbGGNzawlk6GOOFAGngq/zGI8SX WJJ9XDtBpK5uupJTo5bhiYn01ZQcd7UOVf4iX2B6hc8rCT90p+Mrjf8QzU9GR1OUawEeg1Eh rFTwGc2lltXCCWBN9nAWVdfJMqUGQ5+vgprVZvUWawuSFuM8xLp9pRj232NF8yT3kQxs31vi om6GMC1MgzSV8cwoiUf/b4xhyr8wFn/0l8aU/Dcx9sPHH7C+xvMWcTE+xHoZl0uxTUUrcOR6 n07J01mj2e4Z2GCf6900IC6kK/0ovrZXmKrUTtTJhlDx40vbcsNTHcQzWjhV+bMO5Mzy1jhK MoKuP4tS69QghmHU4Um6qp9LBhtRuS9F8hin4fYJa4jweRbdE//JNP2zIoMUjrWMVqPJWvWM sXvMsIU8TddFK/hf+oHH5YxHxUIqLjJAm5OdgHxaYSUTqF6SGTv3xWN1Q448gvWNXHhuVHHg BhUtmKqBR1jiBQB/YjdGbSw2cEr4wzC0BnZpDaa18IkzDUMVR4mlWTae23hgaIof4XMWLS2K A0Sj2NshWlPDjv7zjslhTH3KpC3nNhpQfSHFBxE/SPWw89mgJNrxyb13ihja0TGE9ajiGg+U fCTsBKsFf86IIg1FopkYZoxYrTZY3D618uGNbW2Io00jP7ofziyEo4VwdD9cs1q4RmVwxJoT 26ps7bCaM2UZOHVA59hDHXgW1npzLC+CV7lEqZG2Ko4Z/IZH/un0d1h5iwUSwHql1GcrbFrg FNRlRjKy5MFDNJLniM/qV00zbtvqQHs+/RMTrZ5NiRxLJU/2gt8FOc669mCFR60nHCtu8nac pZGzeuzseVln9fLO0gOc3cPm9OvYHI+zumHssLluHE7nWS5nDWYQ8pLHW1bTbApmaaTZtDUD S2yNM5Nqc71Bud60GmYRj5PcEkaEFQuovrqN2KtovmpuAVLU3SxyK/7VILb2EhkfydXFpTuI 5emrLP8qYb9K0gfzLi3JuyOvh+0z9t3RfljYoUjV/ub2uIiumnxezM3l2A/hquTmJhd2tXCy Sm5m9Qq9o5LpFZ4cJpe6Xi0cqxaOVgtHKoVj1e1sBFdh3Ck4US1ccU1QGm5eLRyvFq46vovg quO7CK66WjSCq5ZRWL1aOKNauGr5jlXLd6xavmPV8h2tlu9otXxHq+U7Wi3f0Wr5jlbLd7Ra vqNl+O7w/pEW94/kK1uylx2Z/uUNWXHPcQI6RJfEQUb0sEaTfatZsQNmRQ+f1Z6OlBV0pDTp SFnOy6xf2450pxkl1fai0q6b0qZca5qG0AxZb2kmabY0g82FlGbTZrT1lb1o2Q6UfYsOlBV1 oFkOaDRkcvbkc5/sfPbD0C+E2dfkHk4zrJhmvvbm5wsSkr56SVU5zXyzWR1CM18wqz00o3/j iy+i0UP4hjQtxhvU1JpM6pphNwzNtE1L43Wd2halTcMW3/zuS/8WzKP/T+++iIl9b3HHUHwZ vq82QrjijqEknE4q9U4nFXrH9YaosgGRdbPKxtegvBiu3NohXHEfXRquuI8uDVfcR5eGqzLu EK7KrEC44j66NFxxGJeFe+W+ujRccR9dGq64jy4N9yW/SzwArriPLg1X3EeXhvuS32EfAFfc R5eGq5bvRLV8J6rlO1Et34lq+U5Uy3eiWr575dguBddijVfuDUvDVch3Cq5CvlNwZfju8KZU L25K6Ve2b/Tvefn1tVd65O8yrWsvdGzVZcJd9EejpE3gKPqTVCxe1R//g3Gi/hAX37zD/45f VaM7auqfDO7Xoy/MbdU0+pberr3D9FhJe6ykPb2kPf1Ae8k/dLF9rv6yloCmwYQ/Zka++y/2 w1KnAEAAAA== --------------090205030503090908030203 Content-Type: application/gzip; name="xenstore-ls.log.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="xenstore-ls.log.gz" H4sICMsHkVIAA3hlbnN0b3JlLWxzLmxvZwCtWtuOozoWfZ+vODrvNJCda0nzNjrPR5p5HKnk cEmsAkwbk66arx/jAAn4tp3qanV3Kl5rY7wveG0TV/T8Wf3xzz/+/PMfsfocp8vf4ryObgXv KGuGgZ9F3b9/Fs274CSnQn5LqhkMCyogqSwj8wyGz3HOakIbw1dxYvwyPpPso2hy52CcsaZj VYECPRbBA/PM6Bn4dFttRZqm4D9uNY5ZctYI+WVE1T2mYayBssSnEw5niDUVbYqAK7ecCZYx 5dWbSJMER+sEEdjLAG7dAesgWDhIRqgcxjkIdAdBGEt3EOAdBKEOgtccBEgH/cxp9+FecwXx pdgIind72OCR8ZkxQc4VapYTJy9uA/yaZ3gCzYpIfLXqOlnOmSNQFlR8Khtpply+zya+nXOF RVqsWa4mz5F4VIwtGC3hpO4GBqHsDUniRc1uoQ5Ex+VEmDynvvRxPKVmBKEDFV4IVAgNVHg9 UMEYqI6SZqSZalpgoEJgoEJwoMIrgQqvBCqEBioEBapcUnfoDWvuKbgKEh/2RyQMG8EPwhy+ BIl+jl3vAoy0siCi50V0JpzTgqMnN/HkdTLC1XI6noo6r6z67hplJLviF2Ti1uQzok1OeZGJ qCsuddEIFY+b3T7ETjtstjuZfgI/BfTzSOd4HkYSirFGm5KhV3sqBr8wYFQleMAfZWC4i/jf gnFyKeK/Knq5ir/vW3aUnetXRyUmuq/FYLDM3xwF1EDtZCQwHnX0f4q/TU6oQFgUJdSCdhmn rQqXuBBZLOXZ+FUXnyUZlXL3yaqV26anLSRb3KWX97hLHU+EJ9ZUQrcY9FQ95MK64Z6HvILg iiOEFkcIKo7wWnGEF4sjvFgc4RvFEX5TcYTXiyOYiqMnhcFTHCGoOEJIcYSQ4ghhxRH8xfE/ d7mMsmMsjp7Mh28WRwgujvAbiiOsi+MmOR3S3QZ36cDiCEHFEQKKIy09NY+W3q3lAPF1YkZQ fOY0v6h5nblrqUb4lN6XjkUia29bX0ivePwzylj7Fc4qK9r6ImnF6i6Bl+naioqouMmiFWXX YQdSdVgT+I3diuHa1kko4n7lTHN/mk1gJtqqv0RD7Pbq7jImbzQTRe4n1yQbGKfj22n3liRv yeEtOb4lJz8TV/9GsKMQSEh0D1mEGUx6jtgpOeXv75QVde+m+PYvAwSTgRCWgfBiBsJLGQgv ZSCEZiB8PwPDmsJrhmvv4M9ACMlA+E4GgjUDU8Rl0RkIvycDISADITADP7wNmA9EB0Zh4ggL ezqwwJwoPXhTcJNzF7WMypjzSoEHF/9c0TiuJ8sAjlDWXgvXmY4Luxk+R4xrA/aBUJAKg3Mu LJ2LOY168F50Lhic6ypZGsdVtFDOhe85F8KcCz7njhJ7EFWm4+kVwpbbS0wsBfSgQN7b0lKb V/h5grxvGtpcPARLDC4xgZMAxCQWbxEYhuZL9mObw+CdWsoz/mU2ch+ToVYU8mPUVdKTysxp YxR/I36YOM2GDoIq+ZvT9rQ/bE4GZ48EQfiluPcH9unhcDSsTUNqtRb/Ul9EGsIYB6nr7YN5 cArQMft002ugnnKPIH86WLfbqWhN77ebbI+7g7aSDyTrRdsraCs0tfiAtYwr0M4O4TKCIl6U 42W324O2W3+Ahfiaew7Ds16Lmyfo+LiWW4PxK61iPMC3Josq1Q1S09gcfiTyj8P6QJhv7pSY kYIzYxbMg7F8TouS8Tqau1t9JWjLWVZ03aD3+64dHWu/hG7ls3vnRVeI919EZNfCvEN98Ltr L3L2y/iKjUS1vXXALCHGoZjcCK3Imcots3LbvRqb0bY8GYbQhnIiiNnOo71kG4uf1tqHiRcC YGAcrBTLWZx2To8C+UuCheAqDc9H4X6DmDNknaUtmCHJ15xFZdjDETE5+4Gqjr1RLvpF59G7 AJaG/xoT5KUnvMtJ8xmG1xjiLEDjaO7xX2btHW1zqDHsYkuD6r5x3rm5J7lsU/kReLc9o51O uzdvPIa0xdfV8oqBa7FYSA2Lsq6vI1aWFSOoW31qsjRM0NLcnLGQLD2WFdrRoVghsT2+FY0X P/uiE8720pryGS2jfHNyBqGzobACCt224w4s/YS1XMZg8FG+xDvjfJLHXmPOAs1qSxNB6sBb PQTrXbs6huMzZWq7I59Kw0cX9FI0BSfDi8dyLSKS53LPpLjJZ5klSbnXz63TmNbkYtlHqKGF WIra+w1tNhtD4NgVTmpWLNZduS5Xkm0CR0MMjsgbzQvGSa1KfaoroHTWNfZOUjrvO823MI3G JGupxa0LzHsHOJit3HWCcYtv1NAsRwwLcwfoYsSw2jd1w/K/+JQdjod8k0XJ4VBG2222j8jm mEZn2KcEDtn+qL9Ka9Tk4BKEgBWEGhAjCEF/PgFaEAJOEIJfEEKIIASrIHTcC0IQQqggBJsg 1DIKXIIQfosgdFhBCUJACUKwCUKwC0IIEoRgF4QQJAjBKginVqRrzCUI1xiEIHx+3cNp0iUI NZC/JLwsCMEoCHWDGEGos/yCUOd4BaFOse83dCxOEK5f2/G6CSEIbXifIASTINSMIQShxvEL Qo3iFYQaw75Z1qAoQfh8Kup2i00QLhF4t4UIQuMDN1QQrhg4QWghYQShheoWhBaSRRCu0A5B uEJij5xXNIwgXFPWoi3VO78rCibGLYJQf59xcYLmjl+7IFxj8FEeKAjBIAg1Y84CPQlCQylx CkLAC0L4niAEuyAElyA8JYYdsF0QQpAgBLQgBKwghFkQ2k+fwSkIASEIAScINZit3FkFIfgE IeAFITwJwuSQbcg+PUaHTQHRVkZMdCyPWUR2kJZZmh625SA6BJt1wPBxeH1FXW7K6Vs9f4iT 8Scy/DP9hKGf4izdKXGFnPnTZRDoRWYEcWLWTZuVqwozLNsYo1gyF1ngZCUjFrQu5IOzu6dZ AFlmMhfvA105Ao67zWZ/OG1/KO2ItdL3Y9XGBR7WrFSzLem6X8r2fxPVxUD2Ox7LgEGvgwTP MQUJim3sbGHJiyDBMoxBgiKbggTk3x/bfYCVKUiQ7SqsWUOQ/B8cZHeNQEIAAA== --------------090205030503090908030203-- --MEAPmvE1V5CC3abXev2j36isnBcqmsf1v Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name="signature.asc" Content-Description: OpenPGP digital signature Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="signature.asc" -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.15 (GNU/Linux) Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/ iQIcBAEBAgAGBQJSkQhTAAoJEEGvNdV6fTHcmPgP/3k274612lMnLWwdo6IRraay 1CCA9LfVXxYAIwMQNpkD9Ls2wSM8exWHZq69mXSQqXMWD4wjciGeWVZ0bMBpNxKp oQ8Pqv2JOJjczjGoYL7yPfA+MwWDDHv1/Tfx9bfOr0pcw1lcwgeTzu47GueMOUSb jVDx+YvTdhZtloE8YztI72rJSdfHqRpn/8DlXn8DwqLkmESv0eG5z+BMRHFpCtki At432ID+LUwLY72mcK5iRsjyAOL85ksyVuu0OgbAn9khF7kn6xwwOyigXijyhTvQ sRu2vXb4LZZp8OVtdNbL9Wz1O1yYjOCjEJ4FgpeqJcvcvzOgA8/gxP5JV8TA9OFD QpJFaH1hTLHRFrpDZjm0wjsndJXaRXEEbeClhu/lNtZ0F022Ei0eGRZwCVkaWZc9 DrPv+8scaU3MlZwbxMtG6E0VlUIP63mNawFAZRyLjS9GTZG3f9C6eW+J7MUvT0vc UiJJsI9GIb1fci5rUhZU0ZKgZo2s7EcV6/uu8xjVyRcpQGgdZ/nieyF8lkPmpGRi 3owbzK/Ik6FoN0V1DjRFfZ7L6//zWmvhV4WFnZfZxqN5PZVBaAV412VdFoL2Zg1M fng+GXHCuq4pmF8zCcNlGI3xl5aqIXy+sN+rwMcdFyXq6Pq5K7KSLoNbRKOKT/qB kq6RxRDPIdgx8X/vBRXp =wY1T -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- --MEAPmvE1V5CC3abXev2j36isnBcqmsf1v-- --===============7488528087119256630== Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Content-Disposition: inline _______________________________________________ Xen-devel mailing list Xen-devel@lists.xen.org http://lists.xen.org/xen-devel --===============7488528087119256630==--