Re: PCIe Access - achieve bursts without DMA

[David Hawkins <dwh@ovro.caltech.edu>]

Hi Michael,

> On Fri, Jan 31, 2014 at 03:18:30PM -0800, David Hawkins wrote:
>> 1. Peripheral board DMA (board-to-board)
>> 2. Peripheral board DMA to host memory.
>> 3. Host (root complex) DMA.
>>
>> As far as "verification" of your custom peripheral board FPGA IP is
>> concerned, if I was a customer, and you had data for (1) and (2),
>> I'd be pretty happy (and could care less about (2), since its so
>> system dependent).
>
> Usually I would totally agree with you and try to implement the benchmark
> using DMA transfers Unfortunately, we have some boards and IP cores that
> do not support DMA transfers, or the target system must not do by a
> requirement, and as I have no influence on these, I had to investigate
> on how to improve my throughput.

Ah, I see, that does make your life difficult then.

> I've submitted a RFC Patch earlier today, which allowed me to perform
> PCIe read bursts on IO memory, achieving 18 MB/s instead of the 3 MB/s
> I got when using non-cached reads. However, I had to ioremap() my
> memory, like Gabriel said, using write-thru configuration.

That sounds like a reasonable compromise.

Cheers,
Dave