Re: [PATCH] fsl-eula-unpack: deploy Freescale EULA

[Ann Thornton <Ann.Thornton@freescale.com>]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 2144 bytes --]


I think you are misunderstanding what this says.  It is saying that the 
licenses in the software override this.  So the GPL licensed code is 
still GPL, etc.

Ann

On 6/8/2015 8:01 AM, Otavio Salvador wrote:
> Dear Lauren,
>
> On Thu, Jun 4, 2015 at 2:27 PM, Lauren Post <Lauren.Post@freescale.com> wrote:
> ...
>> All software is subject to agreement to, and compliance with, Freescale's
>> End User License Agreement.   To have the right to use these binaries in
>> your images, you must read and accept the following terms.  If there are
>> conflicting terms embedded in the software, the terms embedded in the
>> Software will control.
> ...
>
> I completely disagree with the change proposed by your lawyer. The
> statement seems completely wrong to me.
>
> When we use the "all" word this states that Freescale EULA overrides
> the license terms of:
>
> Linux kernel - GPL-2.0
> Qt5 - LGPL-3.0 / commercial
> …
>
> and Freescale has no right to do so. The proposed text put Freescale
> at risk of license agreement glitch as when it is said "If there are
> conflicting terms embedded in the software, the terms embedded in the
> Software will control." it opens the door for someone to make a GPL
> application and contaminate EULA covered binaries (i.e Vivante's
> ones), just by linking at them and stating their license "controls"
> the license terms.  It is clear that the lawyer is underestimating the
> complexity involved here.
>
> The text in use, nowadays, in the setup-environment:
>
> "Some BSPs depend on libraries and packages which are covered by Freescale's
> End User License Agreement (EULA). To have the right to use these binaries in
> your images, you need to read and accept the following..."
>
> Makes clear that it is user/customer duty to inspect the EULA and
> check if it is possible to agree with it, it makes clear libraries and
> packages might be under this license and its his/her duty to verify
> those.
>
> Regards,
>


-- 
Ann Thornton

/Microcontrollers Software and Applications
Freescale Semiconductors
email: Ann.Thornton@freescale.com/

[-- Attachment #2: Type: text/html, Size: 2894 bytes --]