Re: [RFC net-next] net: sch_clsact: add support for global per-netns classifier mode

[Daniel Borkmann <daniel@iogearbox.net>]

On 09/06/2017 12:01 AM, Roopa Prabhu wrote:
> On Tue, Sep 5, 2017 at 11:18 AM, Cong Wang <xiyou.wangcong@gmail.com> wrote:
>> On Tue, Sep 5, 2017 at 5:48 AM, Nikolay Aleksandrov
>> <nikolay@cumulusnetworks.com> wrote:
>>> Hi all,
>>> This RFC adds a new mode for clsact which designates a device's egress
>>> classifier as global per netns. The packets that are not classified for
>>> a particular device will be classified using the global classifier.
>>> We have needed a global classifier for some time now for various
>>> purposes and setting the single bridge or loopback/vrf device as the

Can you elaborate a bit more on the ... "we have needed a global
classifier for some time now for various purposes".

>>> global classifier device is acceptable for us. Doing it this way avoids
>>> the act/cls device and queue dependencies.
>>>
>>> This is strictly an RFC patch just to show the intent, if we agree on
>>> the details the proposed patch will have support for both ingress and
>>> egress, and will be using a static key to avoid the fast path test when no
>>> global classifier has been configured.
>>>
>>> Example (need a modified tc that adds TCA_OPTIONS when using q_clsact):
>>> $ tc qdisc add dev lo clsact global
>>> $ tc filter add dev lo egress protocol ip u32 match ip dst 4.3.2.1/32 action drop
>>>
>>> the last filter will be global for all devices that don't have a
>>> specific egress_cl_list (i.e. have clsact configured).
>>
>> Sorry this is too ugly.

+1

>> netdevice is still implied in your command line even if you treat it
>> as global. It is essentially hard to bypass netdevice layer since
>> netdevice is the core of L2 and also where everything begins.
>>
>> Maybe the best we can do here is make tc filters standalone
>> as tc actions so that filters can exist before qdisc's and netdevices.
>> But this probably requires significant works to make it working
>> with both existing non-standalone and bindings standalones
>> with qdisc's.
>
> yes, like Nikolay says we have been discussing this as well. Nikolay's
> patch is a cleaver and most importantly non-invasive
> way today given the anchor point for tc rules is a netdev. we have
> also considered a separate implicit tc anchor device.

Seems ugly just as well. :( Hmm, why not just having the two list
pointers (ingress, egress list) in the netns struct and when
something configures them to be effectively non-zero, then devices
in that netns could automatically get a clsact and inherit the
lists from there such that sch_handle_ingress() and sch_handle_egress()
require exactly zero changes in fast-path. You could then go and
say that either you would make changes to clsact for individual
devices immutable when they use the 'shared' list pointers, or then
duplicate the configs when being altered from the global one. Would
push the complexity to control path only at least. Just a brief
thought.