Re: How do I manage this setup with git-svn and/or git remotes?

[Junio C Hamano <gitster@pobox.com>]

Linus Torvalds <torvalds@linux-foundation.org> writes:

> On Fri, 17 Aug 2007, David Kastrup wrote:
>> 
>> But it isn't an independent git project: the superproject has its
>> _own_ copy of dsp, with its _own_ specific commits and fixes that are
>> not supposed to ever end up in the dsp "mothership". 
>
> Sure. And that's different from any git "branch" exactly how?
>
> So you'd have different branches in the superproject - the way you always 
> have when you have two copies of a git project. And then you merge between 
> the two at will.

My reading of the project David is talking about is that its dsp
project which is a "subproject" part gets non generic commits
within the context of the superproject --- which means (1) you
would have branches in the subproject not superproject, and (2)
once you did that, the subproject is not really a subproject
anymore, as you cannot merge that back to the standalone dsp
project without dragging the non-generic bits along with it.

> There's a special "subtree" merge that does exactly that: it basically is 
> the normal recursive merge, except it merges into a subtree. I think 
> that's how Junio does the "git-gui" merges. Junio?

Yes.  It has exactly the same semantics and limitations with the
gitk merge, but just merges into a sub directory.  Shawn cannot
easily pull the changes done inside git.git repository back to
git-gui.git proper.