Re: [RFC] Disk shock protection (revisited)

[Elias Oltmanns <eo@nebensachen.de>]

Jeff Garzik <jeff@garzik.org> wrote:
> Elias Oltmanns wrote:
>> The general idea: A daemon running in user space monitors input data
>> from an accelerometer. When the daemon detects a critical condition,
>> i.e., a sudden acceleration (for instance, laptop slides off the desk),
>> it signals the kernel so the hard disk may be put into a (more) safe
>> state. To this end, the kernel has to issue an idle immediate command
>> with unload feature and stop the block layer queue afterwards. Once the
>> daemon tells us that the imminent danger is over, the most important
>> task for the kernel is to restart the block layer queue. See below for
>> more details.
>
> Speaking specifically to that problem, it seems to me that you either
> want an mlock'd daemon, or just simply to keep everything in the
> kernel, for this specific solution.

Yes, the daemon is mlock'd.

>
> You don't want, for example, to swap out other apps, swap in the
> daemon, in order to handle a sudden acceleration.

Quite. But with mlock this particular problem can be handled in user
space just fine. The only reason I can see right now for putting this
logic into the kernel as well is to keep the functionality around even
after task freeze during suspend / resume. On the other hand, I don't
know whether this is really worth the effort even though the time when
the suspend operation is in progress can arguably be one of the most
accident-prone moments (think of users packing their things in a hurry).

Regards,

Elias