Re: Switching SCM to git and commit/review policy

[Otavio Salvador <otavio@debian.org>]

Rolf Leggewie <no2spam@nospam.arcornews.de> writes:

> Otavio Salvador wrote:
>>  - the tree will be a moving target, without stable revision numbers
>>    and difficult to merge, base work in and like
>
> OE is always a moving target.  I don't see how the policy would change that.

The revisions will be a moving target. To tag a commit as "not-ok"
you'd need to amend it and  them change it rev number.

>>  - most of the pros can be done using the oe-next tree. Doing a full
>>    compilation of changed modules before and after each merge gives a
>>    nice feedback for trivial problems
>
> Modules?  Are you talking kernel?  Or are you using modules as a synonym
> for recipe?

recipe, sorry.

>>  - Being available on unstable doesn't mean it'll be tested
>
> Neither does any of the other proposals ensure that.  "tested" sounds
> like 0 or 1, but in fact it is a continuum.  I can at least think of the
> following
>
> - compiles fine
> - compiles fine from scratch
> - compiles fine from scratch for MACHINE/DISTRO X and Y
> - tested to run on MACHINE X
> - tested to run on all supported MACHINEs
> - does not interfere with another package
>
> What do you mean by "tested"?  How will other processes and policies
> ensure that?

We can't ensure that also because most of tests need to be done by an
human. I think that a sort of compile tests are enough to kill most of
problems.

We can also think about make a specific distro that is need to be
booted, using qemu or whatever, that ensures that basic stuff isn't
break due the change.

>>  - 2 days is a too short testing window
>
> well, that is of course just a proposal and thus easy to fix if necessary.
>
> PS: This is not a rebuttal or a claim that the proposed policy is even a
> desirable one.  But I feel there is more need for clarification.

Sure. I also believe this all need more discussion and
clarification. Mostly because I'm a begginer at OE world and then I
can miss understand a lot of things, sure.

-- 
        O T A V I O    S A L V A D O R
---------------------------------------------
 E-mail: otavio@debian.org      UIN: 5906116
 GNU/Linux User: 239058     GPG ID: 49A5F855
 Home Page: http://otavio.ossystems.com.br
---------------------------------------------
"Microsoft sells you Windows ... Linux gives
 you the whole house."