Re: [RFC PATCH v3 00/13] lib, sched: Introduce sparsebitmap (sbm)

[Chen Yu <chen.yu@linux.dev>]

Hello Prateek!

Thanks for bringing this interesting topic,

On Thu, Oct 01, 2026 at 07:28:36PM +0000, K Prateek Nayak wrote:
> 
> Problem
> =======
> 
>                                             %cycles vs global mask operation
> 
> global mask                                     : 100.0000%  (var: 3.28%)
> per-NUMA mask                                   :  32.9209%  (var: 7.77%)
> per-LLC mask                                    :   1.2977%  (var: 4.85%)
> per-LLC mask (u8 operation; no LOCK prefix)     :   0.4930%  (var: 0.83%)
> 

This shows a significant latency improvement, especially in the per-LLC (u64, u8) case.
May I know if schbench / sched-messaging were used?

> 
> Future work
> ===========
> 
> o Interoperability with cpumaks since sbm lose the crucial optimizations
>   that come naturally from for_each_cpu_and() iterations.
>
> o Different data representation - using the u8 variant for updates and
>   then perform a "gather" operation to build a dense mask.
> 
> o Extending sbm work to help in wakeup (and possibly resurrect Mel's
>   optimization from [4] in some form). The current sbm is still far away
>   from being used for wakeups since  updates  to sbm leaf, even on a
>   16CPUs per LLC system is visible in benchmark performance (~8-10%).
> 

If we leverage sbm for the wakeup path, it is a per-LLC mask, there seems to be
no much difference from Mel Gorman's proposal of allocating per sd_share
unsigned long idle_cpus_span[]? The frequent update to this mask might still cause
c2c latency within 1 LLC. A wild guess is that maybe the u8 version is more suitable,
because it has only max-to-8 CPUs touching the mask at the same time?

My understanding is that the major case that sbm could fit is turning the global bitmask
into a per-LLC bitmask, because it mainly avoids CPUs on different LLC/node writing the
same cache line frequently (nohz.idle_cpus_mask set via nohz_balance_enter_idle() on
many CPUs, etc), which might cause a costly cache RFO event storm. Meanwhile, with sbm,
at the reader side, _nohz_idle_balance() could start scanning from the current CPU to find
an idle CPU, so as to avoid the costly HITM event - the reader is on LLC1, while the writer
is on LLC0 - so maybe:

for_each_cpu_wrap(balance_cpu, nohz.idle_cpus_mask, this_cpu+1)

could start from this_cpu's LLC sibling first, rather than this_cpu + 1, because this_cpu+1
might not always be the LLC sibling of this_cpu.

I found that in the current code, there are also other global mask:
rd->rto_mask(mentioned by Pan Deng when running ffmpeg[1])
rd->dlo_mask
tick_broadcast_**mask
maybe they can also be converted into sbm.

[1] https://lore.kernel.org/lkml/a3207ebf537bbe5605ff5454f63b5604d83a04a0.1753076363.git.pan.deng@intel.com/

thanks,
Chenyu