| Bug ID | 107694 |
|---|---|
| Summary | [wine] RAGE: texture problems |
| Product | Mesa |
| Version | 18.2 |
| Hardware | Other |
| OS | All |
| Status | NEW |
| Severity | normal |
| Priority | medium |
| Component | Drivers/Gallium/radeonsi |
| Assignee | dri-devel@lists.freedesktop.org |
| Reporter | sa@whiz.se |
| QA Contact | dri-devel@lists.freedesktop.org |
Created attachment 141= 292 [details] screenshot of bug in RAGE The game RAGE starts and runs, but have some quite severe texture problems.= See attached screenshot. The problem is especially bad when loading new areas. Settings these options in default.cfg minimizes but doesn't get rid of the = bug fully: jobs_numThreads 1 vt_maxPPF 128 as suggested in https= ://store.steampowered.com/news/6464/ This bug looks quite a lot like one that plagued the Windows drivers (ATI Performance) back when the game was released: https://www.youtu= be.com/watch?v=3Dz-yl6pDFgtw I have seen video of RAGE rendering fine with radeonsi (https://www.yout= ube.com/watch?v=3DOgqgNrN16KM) so I tried jumping back quite a few Mesa releases* to see if there was a regression somewhere, but AFAICT i= t is still there as far back as 11.2.2.=20 I'm guessing the bug happened as a change from radeon to amdgpu on the kern= el side? * Using a hack for Wine to skip the check for a compat profile. System environment: -- system architecture: 64-bit -- Linux distribution: Debian unstable -- GPU: TONGA -- Model: Asus Strix R9 285 2GB -- Display connector: DVI -- xf86-video-amdgpu: 18.0.1 -- xserver: 1.20.1 -- mesa: 18.2.0~rc4 -- drm: 2.4.93 -- kernel: 4.17
| What | Removed | Added |
|---|---|---|
| Resolution | --- | NOTOURBUG |
| Status | NEW | RESOLVED |
As far as I can tell this is a game bug that was never actuall= y fixed. It seems they did some transcoding on Nvidia via CUDA which helped reduce the problem there but never bothered to fix it for AMD cards. There are other config settings suggested I'm afraid you will just have to experiment.
Created attachment 141=
396 [details]
rendering on i965/skylake
Can't say that I agree. Attached is a screenshot from the same place in the
game, with the same settings on i965/Skylake, no texture bug. Software
rendering with llvmpipe is likewise fine.
Maybe you're thinking of the notorious texture pop-ins? This is quite a
different problem.=20
The second video clip I linked to was recorded on a Tahiti GPU in 2016 and =
was
presumably using radeon and not amdgpu. Probably why my regression testing =
lead
nowhere.
FYI, This bug does not occur on the 64-bit version of the game only the 32-bit. = The 32-bit is very unstable for me also, it crashes quite often. Unfortunately, the 64-bit version's in-game audio is broken on Proton currently. I have spent hours testing different settings on and off for over a year, n= ever managed to find a setting that cured the issue. The game works fine on proprietary drivers. System info: -- Arch 64-bit -- GPU: RX Vega 56 -- Mesa 18.3.0-devel (git-e345247092) -- Kernel 4.18.5
| What | Removed | Added |
|---|---|---|
| Resolution | NOTOURBUG | --- |
| Status | RESOLVED | REOPENED |
(In reply to Sven Arvidsson from comment #2) > Created = attachment 141396 [details] > rendering on i965/skylake >=20 > Can't say that I agree. Attached is a screenshot from the same place i= n the > game, with the same settings on i965/Skylake, no texture bug. Software > rendering with llvmpipe is likewise fine. >=20 > Maybe you're thinking of the notorious texture pop-ins? This is quite a > different problem.=20 >=20 > The second video clip I linked to was recorded on a Tahiti GPU in 2016= and > was presumably using radeon and not amdgpu. Probably why my regression > testing lead nowhere. Well I'll reopen the bug in case someone else takes a look. However unlike comment #3 I have see the bug o= n 64-bit also and the issues in not present when replaying an apitrace both of these things lead me to believe this is a game bug.
Hi, The youtube video linked in the first comment has very likely been taken wi= th gallium nine (gearsongallium mentionned in the video was a website of a gal= lium nine tester with a lot of performance comparisons and tests, plus a distro = with gallium nine). Then maybe the 64 bit version of the game was used, since comment 3 mentions t his version works better. I haven't tested the game myself.
(In reply to Axel Davy from comment #5) > Hi, >=20 > The youtube video linked in the first comment has very likely been tak= en > with gallium nine (gearsongallium mentionned in the video was a websit= e of a > gallium nine tester with a lot of performance comparisons and tests, p= lus a > distro with gallium nine). >=20 > Then maybe the 64 bit version of the game was used, since comment 3 mentions > t his version works better. I haven't tested the game myself. The game uses OpenGL, so gallium nine wouldn't make a difference. Could very well be 64bit though. I was quite convinced that it was something specific to AMD given that the 11.11a catalyst driver is specifically mentioned as fix for a very similar problem, and the release notes mention fixes specific to the 32bit version. I'm not so sure anymore though, if it is reproducible on 64bit too.=20 There's also this an entry about a similar problem on the PC Gaming Wiki, suggestions include turning off anisotropic filter, antialiasing or Catalyst A.I. (whatever that is?): https://pcgamingwiki.com/wiki/RAGE#Corrupted.2C_black.2= C_jagged_or_dotted_textures Even if it is a game bug, it would be nice to find a workaround.
For all my searching it seemed AMD released multiple "fix= es" for this game but people were still reporting issues many years after the release [1]. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/pcgaming/com= ments/3ic13g/4_years_later_and_rage_is_still_a_glitchy_mess_on/
All tests performed with same settings. - Rage 32-bit on Windows 10: Works perfect out of the box no performance issues, no issue with the virtual textures, no texture pop-in bug. I noticed the player shadow wasn't rendered correctly, but everything else is fine. Rage.exe RAM usage ~1,370MB on the Wasteland map. - Rage 32-bit on Ubuntu w/ 18.20 Pro drivers: I experience good performance= out of the box but the virtual textures bug is present although very minor. Ca= n be totally cured by setting "jobs_numThreads 1", texture pop in bug = still persists. Rage.exe RAM usage ~780MB on the Wasteland map.=20=20 - Rage 32-bit on Arch w/ latest mesa-git: Massive issue with virtual textu= res unless you set "jobs_numThreads 1" which reduces but doesn't fix = the issue, frame rate dips to 30-40fps in certain areas of the wasteland and the "= ;texture pop" is there regardless even if you enabled the texture cache, set th= e maxPPF etc. Rage.exe RAM usage ~730MB on the Wasteland map. http= ://renderingpipeline.com/2012/03/megatextures-in-rage/ Adding "+com_allowconsole 1" to the launch options using "to= ggle vt_showPageNumbers; vt_restart" you can see the wrong mipmap level and= texture numbers are being loaded for some of the tiles. I'm wondering if somebody at AMD would have access to the changelogs for the proprietary drivers back when the Rage patches were first introduced, it wo= uld atleast point you in the right direction. Heres a video I made comparing 32/64-bit versions on my system: https://www.youtu= be.com/watch?v=3DEUwq4dbnFkA
(In reply to Sven Arvidsson from comment #6) > There's also this an entry about a similar probl= em on the PC Gaming Wiki The Wiki as well as many other guides recommend to set fc_maxcachememoryMB = to a higher value. I noticed that on Proton, the highest value I can set is 96 (which is the default). Can this actually be set to values of 1024 and high= er on Windows?
(In reply to James B from comment #8) > Heres a video I made comparing 32/64-bit version= s on my system: > https://www.= youtube.com/watch?v=3DEUwq4dbnFkA Same results on my system (RX 580) running Ubuntu and Padoka PPA. It would be nice to be able to play the 32 bit version as it supports achievements, which the 64 bit version does not.
Seems like in Windows the problem is solved with AMD Catalyst = Control Center by turning on 'Surface Format Optimization' option. https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3D313663882 Maybe this can give some hints on how to solve this in Linux.
| What | Removed | Added |
|---|---|---|
| Resolution | --- | MOVED |
| Status | REOPENED | RESOLVED |
-- GitLab Migration Automatic Message -- This bug has been migrated to freedesktop.org's GitLab instance and has been closed from further activity. You can subscribe and participate further through the new bug through this = link to our GitLab instance: https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mesa/mesa/issues/1326.