Re: Regressions: MSI vs HDA-Intel

[Torsten Kaiser <just.for.lkml@googlemail.com>]

On Fri, Mar 26, 2010 at 6:31 PM, Takashi Iwai <tiwai@suse.de> wrote:
> At Fri, 26 Mar 2010 18:25:22 +0100,
> Torsten Kaiser wrote:
>>
>> I have two systems that use the alsa hda-intel driver, both show
>> regressions in relation to MSI.
>>
>> System 1: Athlon(tm) X2 BE-2400 with an AMD RS690/SB600 chipset
>> 00:14.2 Audio device [0403]: ATI Technologies Inc SBx00 Azalia (Intel
>> HDA) [1002:4383]
>> (Mainboard is a MSI MS-7368)
>>
>> After upgrading from 2.6.31 to 2.6.33 I get a delay during bootup:
>> [    1.155925] HDA Intel 0000:00:14.2: PCI INT A -> GSI 16 (level,
>> low) -> IRQ 16
>> [    1.159143] input: AT Translated Set 2 keyboard as
>> /devices/platform/i8042/serio0/input/input2
>> [    1.232595] firewire_core: created device fw0: GUID 00dc10000129c48f, S400
>> [    1.252677] hda_codec: ALC888: BIOS auto-probing.
>> [    1.259226] HDA Intel 0000:01:05.2: PCI INT B -> GSI 19 (level,
>> low) -> IRQ 19
>> [    1.260293] HDA Intel 0000:01:05.2: irq 27 for MSI/MSI-X
>> [    1.314712] input: GenPS/2 Genius Mouse as
>> /devices/platform/i8042/serio1/input/input3
>> [    4.322508] hda-intel: azx_get_response timeout, switching to
>> polling mode: last cmd=0x000f0000
>> [    5.332508] hda-intel: No response from codec, disabling MSI: last
>> cmd=0x000f0000
>> [    6.342508] hda-intel: Codec #0 probe error; disabling it...
>> [    7.392508] hda_intel: azx_get_response timeout, switching to
>> single_cmd mode: last cmd=0x000f0000
>> [    7.430464] ALSA device list:
>> [    7.431549]   #0: HDA ATI SB at 0xfe7f4000 irq 16
>> [    7.432656]   #1: HDA ATI HDMI at 0xfe9e8000 irq 27
>>
>> 2.6.34-rc2 does not boot on this system, something related to the new
>> bootmem allocator, so I can't say if this might already be fixed for
>> 2.6.34.
>>
>> Should the system be blacklisted like the two Asus Athlon X2 boards,
>> or is this some other bug?
>
> If it happens on 2.6.33 and enable_msi=0 solves the issue, then yes,
> we should put them on the blacklist.

Surprisingly this did not fix the delay. After all the trouble I had
with MSI on the other system, I was sure it was related to the fact,
that 2.6.33 tried to use MSI.
2.6.33 with snd_hda_intel.enable_msi=0:
[    1.155712] HDA Intel 0000:00:14.2: PCI INT A -> GSI 16 (level,
low) -> IRQ 16
[    1.158852] input: AT Translated Set 2 keyboard as
/devices/platform/i8042/serio0/in
put/input2
[    1.232597] firewire_core: created device fw0: GUID 00dc10000129c48f, S400
[    1.252679] hda_codec: ALC888: BIOS auto-probing.
[    1.259206] HDA Intel 0000:01:05.2: PCI INT B -> GSI 19 (level,
low) -> IRQ 19
[    1.314745] input: GenPS/2 Genius Mouse as
/devices/platform/i8042/serio1/input/input3
[    4.322508] hda-intel: azx_get_response timeout, switching to
polling mode: last cmd=0x000f0000
[    5.332508] hda-intel: Codec #0 probe error; disabling it...
[    6.382508] hda_intel: azx_get_response timeout, switching to
single_cmd mode: last cmd=0x000f0000
[    6.420470] ALSA device list:
[    6.421545]   #0: HDA ATI SB at 0xfe7f4000 irq 16
[    6.422628]   #1: HDA ATI HDMI at 0xfe9e8000 irq 19

... if I had read these messages, instead of just copy&pasting them, I
could have noted, that the delay is from codec *0*, but MSI gets
enabled for codec *1*.
Info about the HDMI output:
01:05.2 Audio device [0403]: ATI Technologies Inc Radeon X1200 Series
Audio Controller [1002:7919]

But that is a clear bug in the alsa code: After codec 0 (the
integrated audio from the SB600) does not responds, it disables the
MSI support for codec 1 (part of the intregrated graphic chipset).
(I don't know if the HDMI audio support is working or not, as I do not
have an HDMI display I could attach there.)

2.6.31 was working without the delay:
[    0.930754] HDA Intel 0000:00:14.2: PCI INT A -> GSI 16 (level,
low) -> IRQ 16
[    0.946676] input: AT Translated Set 2 keyboard as
/devices/platform/i8042/serio0/input/input2
[    1.031402] hda_codec: Unknown model for ALC888, trying auto-probe
from BIOS...
[    1.035263] HDA Intel 0000:01:05.2: PCI INT B -> GSI 19 (level,
low) -> IRQ 19
[    1.090754] input: GenPS/2 Genius Mouse as
/devices/platform/i8042/serio1/input/input3
[    1.102573] firewire_core: created device fw0: GUID 00dc10000129c48f, S400
[    1.112916] ALSA device list:
[    1.112974]   #0: HDA ATI SB at 0xfe7f4000 irq 16
[    1.113033]   #1: HDA ATI HDMI at 0xfe9e8000 irq 19


>> System 2: Opteron(tm) 2218 with an nVidia MCP55 chipset
>> 00:06.1 Audio device [0403]: nVidia Corporation MCP55 High Definition
>> Audio [10de:0371] (rev a2)
>> (Mainboard is an ASUS KFN5-D SLI)
>>
>> Commit 80c43ed724797627d8f86855248c497a6161a214 disabled MSI for this
>> system, but the MSI mode was working fine for all 2.6.33 versions I
>> used.
>>
>> Should the generic blacklist disable MSI for all Athlon X2 instead of
>> all nNvidia chipsets?
>
> Well, it's not clear yet.  I don't bet that non-athlon would have
> any problem.  So I keep it still disabled for Nvidia controllers.
> You can put it in the whitelist instead.

OK, just wanted to let you know, that there are MCP55 out there that
do work with MSI. :-)

Thanks, Torsten