Re: [B.A.T.M.A.N.] two-radio nodes and alternative next hop

Jan Hetges
2008-04-24T03:55:53Z

[-- Attachment #1.1: Type: text/plain, Size: 378 bytes --]

On Wed, Apr 23, 2008 at 09:54:37AM +0200, Axel Neumann wrote:
[..snip..]
> > i'll make some more logs when .3.137 is back up
> ok.
there you go (to make the confusion complete, i named them
like before ;-) .
and something completely different: i think, .4.1 should choose the
direkt link to .4.162 instead of going through .4.160 (and vice versa)

cheers

--Jan

[-- Attachment #1.2: 3.1.log --]
[-- Type: text/plain, Size: 4073 bytes --]

WARNING: You are using BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972 (compatibility version 10) !
BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972, IF wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1, LinkWindowSize 50, PathWindSize 100, OGI 1000ms, currSeqno 4887, UT 13:10:24:11, CPU 43/1000
Neighbor outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld rid sid ) [ viaIF RTQ RQ TQ]..
172.19.3.160 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.160 94 ( 98 13:10:24:10 26708 0 5 6 ) [ wlan0:bmx 74 94 78]
172.19.3.130 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.130 88 ( 100 1:11:50:46 525 0 3 5 ) [ wlan0:bmx 78 80 96]
172.19.3.128 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.128 92 ( 98 1:11:50:48 17407 0 4 8 ) [ wlan0:bmx 72 80 90]
172.19.3.131 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.131 91 ( 100 0:21:34:38 33336 0 1 3 ) [ wlan0:bmx 80 94 84]
172.19.3.136 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.131 87 ( 100 0:15:02:33 58460 0 3 2 ) [ wlan0:bmx 50 50 100]
172.19.3.133 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.133 96 ( 96 0:12:30:01 65198 0 1 9 ) [ wlan0:bmx 76 78 96]
172.19.3.135 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.131 86 ( 100 0:07:15:27 14037 0 2 4 ) [ wlan0:bmx 40 36 100]
172.19.3.137 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.160 83 ( 91 0:01:03:44 3969 0 1 1 ) [ wlan0:bmx 0 4 0]

Originator outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld pws ogi cpu hop change ) alternativeNextHops brc ...
172.19.3.131 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.131 91 ( 100 0:21:34:38 33336 0 100 1004 8 1 7 ) 172.19.3.136 60 172.19.3.135 46 172.19.3.137 1
172.19.3.134 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.131 74 ( 88 0:06:44:35 47266 0 100 1013 0 2 1 ) 172.19.3.135 46 172.19.3.136 51 172.19.3.137 0
172.19.3.130 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.130 88 ( 100 1:11:50:46 525 0 100 1021 14 1 3107 ) 172.19.3.136 50 172.19.3.135 43 172.19.3.128 77 172.19.3.137 1
172.19.3.133 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.133 96 ( 96 0:12:30:01 65198 0 100 995 5 1 1 ) 172.19.3.135 38 172.19.3.136 52 172.19.3.137 0
172.19.4.161 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.160 86 ( 93 0:15:03:22 31126 0 100 1003 0 2 1 ) 172.19.3.135 40 172.19.3.137 2 172.19.3.136 45 172.19.3.130 5
172.19.3.160 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.160 94 ( 98 13:10:24:10 26708 0 100 992 19 1 15 ) 172.19.3.136 52 172.19.3.135 47 172.19.3.137 0
172.19.4.160 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.160 91 ( 94 0:15:03:21 23 0 100 1000 25 2 1 ) 172.19.3.136 50 172.19.3.135 38 172.19.3.137 2
172.19.3.141 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.128 87 ( 92 0:15:02:35 17669 0 100 1043 14 2 99 ) 172.19.3.136 47 172.19.3.130 73 172.19.3.135 42 172.19.3.137 0
172.19.3.137 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.160 83 ( 91 0:01:03:44 3969 0 100 998 1 2 5 ) 172.19.3.136 42 172.19.3.135 34 172.19.3.137 1 172.19.3.128 12
172.19.4.162 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.160 86 ( 90 0:15:03:32 17134 0 100 978 10 3 1 ) 172.19.3.136 46 172.19.3.135 34 172.19.3.137 0
172.19.3.128 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.128 92 ( 98 1:11:50:48 17407 0 100 991 26 1 185 ) 172.19.3.136 38 172.19.3.130 65 172.19.3.135 29 172.19.3.137 2
172.19.4.165 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.160 90 ( 96 0:15:03:48 62168 0 100 982 19 2 1 ) 172.19.3.136 50 172.19.3.135 42 172.19.3.137 1
172.19.3.136 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.131 87 ( 100 0:15:02:33 58460 0 100 1003 24 2 422 ) 172.19.3.136 63 172.19.3.135 55 172.19.3.137 0
172.19.3.135 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.131 86 ( 100 0:07:15:27 14037 0 100 1014 33 3 252 ) 172.19.3.135 68 172.19.3.136 64 172.19.3.137 0 172.19.3.130 2 172.19.3.128 1
14 known Originator(s), averages: 87 ( 95 0 100 1003 14 1 292 )

Originator Announced networks HNAs: moved to debug level 9...

Originator Announced services ip:port:seqno ... see debug level 7

[-- Attachment #1.3: 3.128.log --]
[-- Type: text/plain, Size: 3198 bytes --]

WARNING: You are using BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972 (compatibility version 10) !
BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972, IF eth1:bmx 172.19.3.128, LinkWindowSize 50, PathWindSize 100, OGI 1000ms, currSeqno 17406, UT 6:08:28:30, CPU 26/1000
Neighbor outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld rid sid ) [ viaIF RTQ RQ TQ]..
172.19.3.130 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.130 88 ( 100 1:11:50:49 522 0 1 1 ) [ eth1:bmx 82 84 96]
172.19.3.1 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.130 71 ( 100 1:11:50:50 4882 0 8 4 ) [ eth1:bmx 78 94 82]
172.19.3.141 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.141 92 ( 99 0:15:02:35 17666 0 1 2 ) [ eth1:bmx 88 92 94]
172.19.3.137 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.1 60 ( 95 0:01:03:42 3966 0 2 3 ) [ eth1:bmx 24 44 54]

Originator outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld pws ogi cpu hop change ) alternativeNextHops brc ...
172.19.3.131 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.1 72 ( 91 0:21:34:38 33333 0 100 994 10 2 117 ) 172.19.3.130 64 172.19.3.137 35
172.19.3.134 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.1 60 ( 75 0:06:44:34 47263 0 100 971 0 3 60 ) 172.19.3.137 30 172.19.3.130 51
172.19.3.130 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.130 88 ( 100 1:11:50:49 522 0 100 1031 14 1 1443 ) 172.19.3.1 66 172.19.3.137 34
172.19.3.133 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.1 76 ( 96 0:12:30:00 65195 1 100 1011 5 2 51 ) 172.19.3.130 64 172.19.3.137 29
172.19.4.161 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.1 69 ( 95 0:15:03:22 31123 0 100 1036 1 3 43 ) 172.19.3.130 49 172.19.3.137 41
172.19.3.160 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.1 80 ( 99 1:11:50:50 26705 0 100 979 19 2 79 ) 172.19.3.130 68 172.19.3.137 34
172.19.4.160 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.1 71 ( 95 0:15:03:21 20 0 100 1005 25 3 75 ) 172.19.3.130 66 172.19.3.137 41
172.19.3.141 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.141 92 ( 99 0:15:02:35 17666 0 100 1002 14 1 1 ) 172.19.3.137 29 172.19.3.130 0
172.19.3.137 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.1 60 ( 95 0:01:03:42 3966 0 100 999 0 3 63 ) 172.19.3.137 55 172.19.3.130 46
172.19.4.162 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.1 65 ( 92 0:15:03:32 17131 0 100 1009 10 4 43 ) 172.19.3.130 64 172.19.3.137 41
172.19.3.1 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.130 71 ( 100 1:11:50:50 4882 0 100 1022 43 2 98 ) 172.19.3.1 69 172.19.3.137 31
172.19.4.165 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.1 60 ( 99 0:15:03:48 62164 0 100 980 19 3 84 ) 172.19.3.130 56 172.19.3.137 44
172.19.3.136 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.1 66 ( 88 0:15:02:33 58457 0 100 1002 17 3 77 ) 172.19.3.130 63 172.19.3.137 30
172.19.3.135 eth1:bmx 172.19.3.130 65 ( 87 0:07:15:25 14034 0 100 1010 35 5 50 ) 172.19.3.1 64 172.19.3.137 32
14 known Originator(s), averages: 71 ( 93 0 100 1003 15 2 163 )

Originator Announced networks HNAs: moved to debug level 9...

Originator Announced services ip:port:seqno ... see debug level 7

[-- Attachment #1.4: 3.137.log --]
[-- Type: text/plain, Size: 3322 bytes --]

WARNING: You are using BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972 (compatibility version 10) !
BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972, IF ath0:bmx 172.19.3.137, LinkWindowSize 50, PathWindSize 100, OGI 1000ms, currSeqno 3970, UT 0:01:03:45, CPU 1/1000
Neighbor outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld rid sid ) [ viaIF RTQ RQ TQ]..
172.19.3.1 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 66 ( 94 0:01:03:43 4884 0 1 1 ) [ ath0:bmx 0 22 0]
172.19.3.128 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 68 ( 93 0:01:03:44 17405 1 3 2 ) [ ath0:bmx 28 54 50]
172.19.3.160 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 81 ( 100 0:01:03:43 26707 0 6 3 ) [ ath0:bmx 82 100 82]

Originator outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld pws ogi cpu hop change ) alternativeNextHops brc ...
172.19.3.131 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 76 ( 90 0:01:03:42 33335 0 100 1024 8 3 1 ) 172.19.3.128 24 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.131 0
172.19.3.134 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 55 ( 71 0:01:03:43 47263 2 100 991 0 4 2 ) 172.19.3.128 18 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.131 0
172.19.3.130 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 68 ( 94 0:01:03:43 522 1 100 1022 14 3 1 ) 172.19.3.128 36 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.131 0
172.19.3.133 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 70 ( 95 0:01:03:43 65198 0 100 1006 5 3 2 ) 172.19.3.128 29 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.131 0
172.19.4.161 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 84 ( 97 0:01:03:42 31124 1 100 1033 0 2 2 ) 172.19.3.128 20 172.19.3.1 0
172.19.4.160 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 78 ( 96 0:01:03:43 22 0 100 1007 25 2 1 ) 172.19.3.128 15 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.131 0
172.19.3.160 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 81 ( 100 0:01:03:43 26707 0 100 988 19 1 1 ) 172.19.3.128 22 172.19.3.1 0
172.19.3.141 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 66 ( 89 0:01:03:42 17668 0 100 980 14 4 3 ) 172.19.3.128 33 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.131 0
172.19.4.162 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 84 ( 94 0:01:03:43 17132 1 100 1017 10 3 2 ) 172.19.3.128 26 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.131 0
172.19.3.128 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 68 ( 93 0:01:03:44 17405 1 100 998 26 3 4 ) 172.19.3.128 35 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.131 0
172.19.3.1 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 66 ( 94 0:01:03:43 4884 0 100 1013 43 2 2 ) 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.128 27 172.19.3.131 0
172.19.4.165 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 85 ( 100 0:01:03:43 62166 0 100 1024 19 2 1 ) 172.19.3.128 29 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.131 0
172.19.3.136 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 70 ( 86 0:01:03:43 58458 1 100 1014 17 4 2 ) 172.19.3.128 31 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.131 0
172.19.3.135 ath0:bmx 172.19.3.160 64 ( 82 0:01:03:42 14034 1 100 1012 35 5 1 ) 172.19.3.128 20 172.19.3.1 0 172.19.3.131 0
14 known Originator(s), averages: 72 ( 91 0 100 1009 16 2 1 )

Originator Announced networks HNAs: moved to debug level 9...

Originator Announced services ip:port:seqno ... see debug level 7

[-- Attachment #1.5: 4.1.log --]
[-- Type: text/plain, Size: 3148 bytes --]

WARNING: You are using BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972 (compatibility version 10) !
BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972, IF wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.160, LinkWindowSize 50, PathWindSize 100, OGI 1000ms, currSeqno 26711, UT 20:01:15:43, CPU 24/1000
Neighbor outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld rid sid ) [ viaIF RTQ RQ TQ]..
172.19.3.1 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 85 ( 100 13:10:25:39 4886 0 6 5 ) [ wlan0:bmx 96 98 96]
172.19.4.165 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.165 100 ( 100 0:15:03:51 62169 0 1 1 ) [ wlan1:bmx 96 98 96]
172.19.4.162 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.160 98 ( 100 0:15:03:35 17136 0 1 2 ) [ wlan1:bmx 80 76 100]
172.19.4.161 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.161 97 ( 100 0:15:03:25 31128 0 1 3 ) [ wlan1:bmx 92 96 94]
172.19.4.160 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.160 97 ( 100 0:15:03:24 25 0 2 4 ) [ wlan1:bmx 96 96 100]
172.19.3.137 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.137 91 ( 97 0:01:03:46 3971 0 3 6 ) [ wlan0:bmx 86 86 100]

Originator outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld pws ogi cpu hop change ) alternativeNextHops brc ...
172.19.3.131 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 85 ( 91 0:21:34:41 33338 0 100 1005 8 2 1 ) 172.19.4.162 74
172.19.3.134 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 61 ( 74 0:06:44:38 47267 0 100 1019 0 3 1 ) 172.19.4.162 27
172.19.3.130 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 78 ( 88 1:11:50:50 525 0 100 1023 14 2 17 ) 172.19.4.162 71
172.19.3.133 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 85 ( 95 0:12:30:04 65200 0 100 995 9 2 1 ) 172.19.4.162 79
172.19.4.161 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.161 97 ( 100 0:15:03:25 31128 0 100 1023 0 1 1 ) 172.19.4.162 83
172.19.4.160 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.160 97 ( 100 0:15:03:24 25 0 100 998 14 1 166 ) 172.19.4.162 91
172.19.3.141 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 83 ( 89 0:15:02:38 17667 3 100 1007 14 3 1 ) 172.19.4.162 69
172.19.3.137 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.137 91 ( 97 0:01:03:46 3971 0 100 1010 1 1 1 ) 172.19.4.162 41
172.19.4.162 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.160 98 ( 100 0:15:03:35 17136 0 100 1002 30 2 1254 ) 172.19.4.162 90
172.19.3.128 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 79 ( 92 1:11:50:51 17408 0 100 999 18 2 13 ) 172.19.4.162 64
172.19.3.1 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 85 ( 100 13:10:25:39 4886 0 100 1028 43 1 37 ) 172.19.4.162 70
172.19.4.165 wlan1:bmx 172.19.4.165 100 ( 100 0:15:03:51 62169 0 100 1007 19 1 3 ) 172.19.4.162 86
172.19.3.136 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 76 ( 87 0:15:02:36 58461 0 100 1013 24 3 1 ) 172.19.4.162 65
172.19.3.135 wlan0:bmx 172.19.3.1 75 ( 86 0:07:15:30 14037 1 100 1032 33 4 1 ) 172.19.4.162 61
14 known Originator(s), averages: 85 ( 92 0 100 1012 16 2 107 )

Originator Announced networks HNAs: moved to debug level 9...

Originator Announced services ip:port:seqno ... see debug level 7

[-- Attachment #1.6: 4.162.log --]
[-- Type: text/plain, Size: 3084 bytes --]

WARNING: You are using BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972 (compatibility version 10) !
BatMan-eXp 0.3-alpha rv972, IF eth1:bmx 172.19.4.162, LinkWindowSize 50, PathWindSize 100, OGI 1000ms, currSeqno 17132, UT 0:15:03:31, CPU 10/1000
Neighbor outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld rid sid ) [ viaIF RTQ RQ TQ]..
172.19.4.1 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.1 88 ( 100 0:15:03:27 26702 1 2 1 ) [ eth1:bmx 76 98 76]
172.19.4.160 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 100 ( 100 0:15:03:18 19 0 1 2 ) [ eth1:bmx 96 100 96]
172.19.4.165 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 97 ( 100 0:15:03:22 62163 0 2 3 ) [ eth1:bmx 10 76 12]

Originator outgoingIF bestNextHop brc (rcvd knownSince lseq lvld pws ogi cpu hop change ) alternativeNextHops brc ...
172.19.3.131 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 81 ( 85 0:15:03:25 33332 0 100 995 10 4 588 ) 172.19.4.1 75 172.19.4.165 4
172.19.3.134 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 58 ( 63 0:06:44:31 47261 0 100 1014 3 5 282 ) 172.19.4.1 57 172.19.4.165 4
172.19.3.130 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 76 ( 78 0:15:03:26 519 1 100 1008 8 4 634 ) 172.19.4.1 70 172.19.4.165 5
172.19.3.133 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 84 ( 86 0:12:29:57 65194 0 100 1029 1 4 536 ) 172.19.4.1 73 172.19.4.165 9
172.19.4.161 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 93 ( 97 0:15:03:19 31122 0 100 993 1 3 662 ) 172.19.4.1 88 172.19.4.165 8
172.19.3.160 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 96 ( 100 0:15:03:25 26703 0 100 991 14 2 580 ) 172.19.4.1 81 172.19.4.165 6
172.19.4.160 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 100 ( 100 0:15:03:18 19 0 100 1009 25 1 47 ) 172.19.4.165 7 172.19.4.1 61
172.19.3.141 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 81 ( 83 0:15:02:31 17664 1 100 1003 14 5 618 ) 172.19.4.1 74 172.19.4.165 9
172.19.3.137 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 85 ( 91 0:01:03:40 3965 0 100 1036 0 3 48 ) 172.19.4.1 76 172.19.4.165 7
172.19.3.128 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 77 ( 80 0:15:03:26 17402 0 100 994 17 4 568 ) 172.19.4.1 67 172.19.4.165 3
172.19.3.1 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 79 ( 85 0:15:03:25 4881 0 100 997 44 3 542 ) 172.19.4.1 74 172.19.4.165 5
172.19.4.165 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 97 ( 100 0:15:03:22 62163 0 100 977 19 3 584 ) 172.19.4.1 81 172.19.4.165 9
172.19.3.136 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 74 ( 77 0:15:02:30 58455 0 100 1057 17 5 530 ) 172.19.4.1 66 172.19.4.165 3
172.19.3.135 eth1:bmx 172.19.4.160 73 ( 75 0:07:15:22 14032 0 100 1025 35 6 264 ) 172.19.4.1 64 172.19.4.165 5
14 known Originator(s), averages: 82 ( 85 0 100 1009 14 3 463 )

Originator Announced networks HNAs: moved to debug level 9...

Originator Announced services ip:port:seqno ... see debug level 7