Re: [PATCH 0/7] cxl: Consolidate cxlmd->endpoint accessing

[Dan Williams <dan.j.williams@intel.com>]

Li Ming wrote:
> Currently, CXL subsystem implementation has some functions that may
> access CXL memdev's endpoint before the endpoint initialization
> completed or without checking the CXL memdev endpoint validity. 
> This patchset fixes three scenarios as above description.
> 
> 1. cxl_dpa_to_region() is possible to access an invalid CXL memdev
>    endpoint.
>    there are two scenarios that can trigger this issue:
>    a. memdev poison injection/clearing debugfs interfaces:
>       devm_cxl_add_endpoint() is used to register CXL memdev endpoint
>       and update cxlmd->endpoint from -ENXIO to the endpoint structure.
>       memdev poison injection/clearing debugfs interfaces are registered
>       before devm_cxl_add_endpoint() is invoked in cxl_mem_probe().
>       There is a small window where user can use the debugfs interfaces
>       to access an invalid endpoint.

This is the justification I wanted to see in the changelog of the
patches themselves. That is a reasonable theoretical window.

>    b. cxl_event_config() in the end of cxl_pci_probe():
>       cxl_event_config() invokes cxl_mem_get_event_record() to get
>       remain event logs from CXL device during cxl_pci_probe(). If CXL
>       memdev probing failed before that, it is also possible to access
>       an invalid endpoint.

Makes sense, please put this in the changelog.

>    To fix these two cases, cxl_dpa_to_region() requires callers holding
>    CXL memdev lock to access it and check if CXL memdev driver bingding
>    status. Holding CXL memdev lock ensures that CXL memdev probing has
>    completed, and if CXL memdev driver is bound, it will mean
>    cxlmd->endpoint is valid. (PATCH #1-#5)
> 
> 2. cxl_reset_done() callback in cxl_pci module.
>    cxl_reset_done() callback also accesses cxlmd->endpoint without any
>    checking. If CXL memdev probing fails, then cxl_reset_done() is
>    called by PCI subsystem, it will access an invalid endpoint. The
>    solution is adding a CXL memdev driver binding status inside
>    cxl_reset_done(). (PATCH #6)

Makes sense. I jumped into the patches first since I was familiar with
the problem space, but happy to see you did this analysis. Just
cover-letter analysis can typically get lost in teh shuffle.