Re: Mercurial's only true "plugin" extension: inotify... and can it be done in Git?

["Shawn O. Pearce" <spearce@spearce.org>]

Geert Bosch <bosch@adacore.com> wrote:
> On Mar 9, 2008, at 09:59, Jakub Narebski wrote:
> 
> >This extension[3][4] optimises "hg status" command by asking file
> >notification daemon about changed files instead of doing stat. I'm not
> >sure how useful this extension is: inotify is Linux specific, and  
> >Linux
> >has fast stat... nevertheless this is one example where extension
> >(plug-in) framework shows that it can do more than good scriptability.
> 
> FWIW, OS X 10.5 has a similar functionality, called "fsevents",
> as well as a much slower stat.

Windows NT on NTFS has a file monitor system that works somewhat
like an inotify, but different enough that you gotta write totally
different code for it.  It also has a much slower stat.

I have wanted to put something like this into git-gui, so that a
running git-gui session can see changes made to your working dir
"live".  But I haven't gotten around to writing it.  I did do some
early experiments on Windows NT + NTFS with a small C daemon that
watches the working directory, but it ran into issues about also
need to know what is inside .gitignore to properly avoid sending
events that git-gui doesn't want to know about.  Like say build
object files.  :-)

I think the reason Git has never had such an "extension" is we are
just that freaking fast when it comes to comparing the working tree
to the index.  hg wasn't in the early days and that may have been
what gave rise to the plugin.

-- 
Shawn.