bug in git-send-mail (the 'next' branch)

bug in git-send-mail (the 'next' branch)

[Yakov Lerner]

There is a bug in git-send-mail in the 'next' branch. If first
paragraph of the file in all indented by 1 space, and 1st line of the
paragraph is at the first line of the file, then the whole
paragraph disappears silently. If it's intentional, there should be a warning
or something. And If it's *not* indented (as if it expects message
header lines at this place), then it appears in the message body, so
there is some inconsistency here.

Yakov

Re: bug in git-send-mail (the 'next' branch)

[Jakub Narebski]

"Yakov Lerner" <iler.ml@gmail.com> writes:

> There is a bug in git-send-mail in the 'next' branch. If first
> paragraph of the file in all indented by 1 space, and 1st line of the
> paragraph is at the first line of the file, then the whole
> paragraph disappears silently. If it's intentional, there should be a warning
> or something. And If it's *not* indented (as if it expects message
> header lines at this place), then it appears in the message body, so
> there is some inconsistency here.

I guess that this bug is in "header flowing" code; headers in email
message can span multiple lines by some use of indenting. That is
where one can search for the source of this bug...

-- 
Jakub Narebski
Poland
ShadeHawk on #git

Re: bug in git-send-mail (the 'next' branch)

[Frank Lichtenheld]

On Tue, Mar 18, 2008 at 03:52:58PM +0200, Yakov Lerner wrote:
> There is a bug in git-send-mail in the 'next' branch. If first
> paragraph of the file in all indented by 1 space, and 1st line of the
> paragraph is at the first line of the file, then the whole
> paragraph disappears silently. If it's intentional, there should be a warning
> or something. And If it's *not* indented (as if it expects message
> header lines at this place), then it appears in the message body, so
> there is some inconsistency here.

If the first line of the file doesn't match either /^From / or
/^[-A-Za-z]+:\s/ send-email assumes the file is using the legacy format
from the original send_lots_of_email.pl script which is apparently
"first line of the message is who to CC, and second line is the subject of the
message." (comment from source code). The code doesn't use only the
first two lines but eats everything up the first whitespace line.
Which explains the behaviour you have seen.

There are a few things that could be fixed here:
1) Document the file formats this script expects in the man page. It
   doesn't talk about this at all atm.
2) Fix the legacy format support to only use the first two lines and
   warn/die if there is no whitespace line after that
3) Warn if the first line looks neither like a email header nor a
   email address
4) Perhaps in the future at some point deprecate the legacy support
   (1.6.0?)

Gruesse,
-- 
Frank Lichtenheld <frank@lichtenheld.de>
www: http://www.djpig.de/