Re: gitk "find commit adding/removing string"/possible pickaxe bug?

[Jeff King <peff@peff.net>]

On Tue, Jan 18, 2011 at 05:44:17PM +0100, Thomas Rast wrote:

> In particular, in a history where
> 
>   $ git show HEAD:foo
>   quux
>   $ git show HEAD^:foo
>   bar
>   $ git show HEAD^2:foo
>   baz

I created a similar repo with:

commit() {
  echo $1 >file && git add file && git commit -m $1
}
mkdir repo && cd repo && git init
commit base
commit master
git checkout -b other HEAD^
commit other
git merge master
commit resolved

which should be identical. But I get different results (see near the
end):

> the behaviour is:
> 
>   git log -Squux                  # empty
>   git log -Squux -p               # empty

All of which make sense to me. Pickaxe operates on diff filepairs, and
git by default doesn't seem to do merge diffing at all (but see below).
So those filepairs don't exist to consider.

>   git log -Squux --pickaxe-all    # empty

This doesn't help. It just loosens the actual diff shown from "just the
things that matched -S" to "everything in that commit". It doesn't
add to the filepairs that make it to pickaxe.

>   git log -Squux -c      	  # shows merge, but no diff

This "-c" does what you want, because we start looking at merge
filepairs. Although one thing leaves me confused. If I do:

  git log -p

I get no diff for the merge commit. But in git-diff(1), it says:

  COMBINED DIFF FORMAT
    "git-diff-tree", "git-diff-files" and "git-diff" can take -c or --cc
    option to produce combined diff. For showing a merge commit with
    "git log -p", this is the default format; you can force showing full
    diff with the -m option.

which implies to me that "-c" should be on by default if we selected
"-p" (or presumably -S).

I didn't bisect, but I wonder if the doc is wrong, or if we accidentally
lost this default at some point.

>   git log -Squux --cc    	  # shows merge, but no diff

Makes sense again, since you didn't ask for a patch, no patch.

>   git log -Squux -c -p   	  # shows merge, but no diff

Weird.  Here I get a nice combined diff, which is what I expect.

>   git log -Squux -c --pickaxe-all # shows merge, but no diff

Yep, no "-p" again.

>   git log -Squux --pickaxe-all -c -p  # shows merge & combined diff

The pickaxe-all shouldn't impact anything, at least not in my test repo,
as there is only one file. But of course I do get the diff, as I did
above. Can you show the steps to create your repo? I'm wondering what is
different.

-Peff