Finding leaf nodes.

Finding leaf nodes.

[Jason Pyeron]

I am trying to find all the unmerged commits [5].

I can find, as a human, all the commits by git log --oneline --graph --all [1] but I am looking for a scripted way.

But git show-branch  -a --independent misses some [2]

find .git/refs/ -type f -exec cat '{}' ';' | sort -u; finds too much [3].

The closest I get is with refs=`git show-ref -s`; git log --format=%H $refs --not $(echo "$refs" | sed 's/$/^/') but it too [4] gives me extra, but I am really not sure why. 

* | a54a4fb 
* | a0d2e63 
* | dd4400d 
| | *   68ea2c8
| | |\
| |/ /
|/| |
| | * c74d3c5 ??? Why is this the only extra commit listed ???
| |/
|/|
* | 9c87570 
* | 717e33d 
* | 159799f 


What should I do to automate this?



1:
0748f668b7fe0cba7a0edf1684ae84ddf87104ee
13916782bebe690149bfd1c3fb31d6d08942585b
383f3ae77393c2e303b3c32ef7dee122f0b623be
473093c214ba578cd7aecb6e2e5caaad70d173e4
4d0579c438e9d750f158124284bd740a5a0e0e26
68ea2c83978a7c023d76ebe438dd7d98fb1fd074
6900b076d790593a909bc84a1d062217e4a32941
9802bc44da0a35e4c7a917cd23468c387897cccd
982243cfde0dc6dfb1733d8e95748b7e687f57b8
c197b7f71cd6d601b99adbe0a5cf5bf6bc749b6e
c4bc3c4eb0015c73b50ea280a4a380e3cffc5160
c5234422373d0425fa9cd610cb0848b7c33fe436
d6af1c103b0cdeb7e7d45ffce2a838fa7a287aea
eb50b82c6f3f55b66693482a913a5c1cfc19a03d
f9c41c1a17df4358558a23a7c45bc2c60bf97e27
Fb962761aa2ce6fbf77e4769c9e418bbe6f9f47f

2:
4d0579c438e9d750f158124284bd740a5a0e0e26
68ea2c83978a7c023d76ebe438dd7d98fb1fd074
982243cfde0dc6dfb1733d8e95748b7e687f57b8
C4bc3c4eb0015c73b50ea280a4a380e3cffc5160

3:
00ea00e8e6a23a4243316f860aa07ed59203ab97
144eb9f673f14010c600766762b99cba1a64cc6e
2250af4ad29b92b07365320c5ccb7a22c17f588e
26bdfdfe71f7ceb4e0954bc5ab6c198481a280ae
283be0f77477fcd8c8bc878c602538f8a3451403
2f47330df8fb0357ef4e4d605d5c402150892a18
3ec60ab0dbdc63760429187605ede4549d7b2bad
43813b0fc44f7c41d2cdd4573145dbeb1aae1aee
4d5b52d440d3a64953a6d7ef3cbb81c8d289e392
556a5c2d759b51080e3bfe07a89b67e927749328
6fe0b6db2718625e5eeb3cbadeb58aa858ab4f1b
717e33d67ad3297a15cb432d3f70f7c12d353fa3
7587a45658aa689cc774d7253007be3feb2eec23
ad9b5fa90c8f52b3ca31dd433c2c4b408e5f2a8f
b3d7623b74dd75cc4f965d6b37dc461d2786f912
c19fc45c87de85122952d63d28a0c7d3a18b79d5
e8529e95d89d3f519a31ef7de5bd7f0d0d318e8c
f2e86371e7fe3391023adccd61856d088db773dd
fceca0050ceee8c4996a5740f7122e96c4948dd8

4:
c74d3c5cda60d8be7f38f1ec89c554a1346d57f8

5: My remotes:
https://github.com/CipherShed/CipherShed.git
https://github.com/pdinc-oss/CipherShed.git
https://github.com/discnl/CipherShed.git
https://github.com/eaglgenes101/CipherShed.git
https://github.com/erkinalp/CipherShed.git
https://github.com/GigabyteProductions/CipherShed.git
https://github.com/jeffallen/CipherShed.git
https://github.com/kaydiechii/CipherShed.git
https://github.com/srguglielmo/CipherShed.git

--
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
-                                                               -
- Jason Pyeron                      PD Inc. http://www.pdinc.us -
- Principal Consultant              10 West 24th Street #100    -
- +1 (443) 269-1555 x333            Baltimore, Maryland 21218   -
-                                                               -
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
This message is copyright PD Inc, subject to license 20080407P00.

Re: Finding leaf nodes.

[Michael J Gruber]

Jason Pyeron venit, vidit, dixit 12.04.2015 06:04:
> I am trying to find all the unmerged commits [5].

"Unmerged" to which branch?

It's not clear to me which commits you are looking for. By "leaf node" I
would describe a commit without child commits. "unmerged" can only be
understood relative to a specific branch.

Maybe you are looking for commits from remote refs which are not on any
local branch?

> I can find, as a human, all the commits by git log --oneline --graph --all [1] but I am looking for a scripted way.
> 
> But git show-branch  -a --independent misses some [2]

This finds refs which are not "contained in" (can be reached from) any
of the other refs. If a remote ref is contained in another remore ref it
is not listed.

> find .git/refs/ -type f -exec cat '{}' ';' | sort -u; finds too much [3].

This finds all refs.

> The closest I get is with refs=`git show-ref -s`; git log --format=%H $refs --not $(echo "$refs" | sed 's/$/^/') but it too [4] gives me extra, but I am really not sure why. 

This finds all commits which are on some ref (branch/tag/..), excluding
those which are next to the tip or higher up from those refs.

> 
> * | a54a4fb 
> * | a0d2e63 
> * | dd4400d 
> | | *   68ea2c8
> | | |\
> | |/ /
> |/| |
> | | * c74d3c5 ??? Why is this the only extra commit listed ???

Because it is not "next to the tip", more specifically: not a first
parent (foo^) of a referenced commit, and neither a predecessor of one.

> | |/
> |/|
> * | 9c87570 
> * | 717e33d 
> * | 159799f 
> 
> 
> What should I do to automate this?
> 

Please try and restate what you mean by "unmerged commits". Maybe remote
commits not on any local branch, or remote commits not on master?

> 
> 
> 1:
> 0748f668b7fe0cba7a0edf1684ae84ddf87104ee
> 13916782bebe690149bfd1c3fb31d6d08942585b
> 383f3ae77393c2e303b3c32ef7dee122f0b623be
> 473093c214ba578cd7aecb6e2e5caaad70d173e4
> 4d0579c438e9d750f158124284bd740a5a0e0e26
> 68ea2c83978a7c023d76ebe438dd7d98fb1fd074
> 6900b076d790593a909bc84a1d062217e4a32941
> 9802bc44da0a35e4c7a917cd23468c387897cccd
> 982243cfde0dc6dfb1733d8e95748b7e687f57b8
> c197b7f71cd6d601b99adbe0a5cf5bf6bc749b6e
> c4bc3c4eb0015c73b50ea280a4a380e3cffc5160
> c5234422373d0425fa9cd610cb0848b7c33fe436
> d6af1c103b0cdeb7e7d45ffce2a838fa7a287aea
> eb50b82c6f3f55b66693482a913a5c1cfc19a03d
> f9c41c1a17df4358558a23a7c45bc2c60bf97e27
> Fb962761aa2ce6fbf77e4769c9e418bbe6f9f47f
> 
> 2:
> 4d0579c438e9d750f158124284bd740a5a0e0e26
> 68ea2c83978a7c023d76ebe438dd7d98fb1fd074
> 982243cfde0dc6dfb1733d8e95748b7e687f57b8
> C4bc3c4eb0015c73b50ea280a4a380e3cffc5160
> 
> 3:
> 00ea00e8e6a23a4243316f860aa07ed59203ab97
> 144eb9f673f14010c600766762b99cba1a64cc6e
> 2250af4ad29b92b07365320c5ccb7a22c17f588e
> 26bdfdfe71f7ceb4e0954bc5ab6c198481a280ae
> 283be0f77477fcd8c8bc878c602538f8a3451403
> 2f47330df8fb0357ef4e4d605d5c402150892a18
> 3ec60ab0dbdc63760429187605ede4549d7b2bad
> 43813b0fc44f7c41d2cdd4573145dbeb1aae1aee
> 4d5b52d440d3a64953a6d7ef3cbb81c8d289e392
> 556a5c2d759b51080e3bfe07a89b67e927749328
> 6fe0b6db2718625e5eeb3cbadeb58aa858ab4f1b
> 717e33d67ad3297a15cb432d3f70f7c12d353fa3
> 7587a45658aa689cc774d7253007be3feb2eec23
> ad9b5fa90c8f52b3ca31dd433c2c4b408e5f2a8f
> b3d7623b74dd75cc4f965d6b37dc461d2786f912
> c19fc45c87de85122952d63d28a0c7d3a18b79d5
> e8529e95d89d3f519a31ef7de5bd7f0d0d318e8c
> f2e86371e7fe3391023adccd61856d088db773dd
> fceca0050ceee8c4996a5740f7122e96c4948dd8
> 
> 4:
> c74d3c5cda60d8be7f38f1ec89c554a1346d57f8
> 
> 5: My remotes:
> https://github.com/CipherShed/CipherShed.git
> https://github.com/pdinc-oss/CipherShed.git
> https://github.com/discnl/CipherShed.git
> https://github.com/eaglgenes101/CipherShed.git
> https://github.com/erkinalp/CipherShed.git
> https://github.com/GigabyteProductions/CipherShed.git
> https://github.com/jeffallen/CipherShed.git
> https://github.com/kaydiechii/CipherShed.git
> https://github.com/srguglielmo/CipherShed.git
> 
> --
> -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
> -                                                               -
> - Jason Pyeron                      PD Inc. http://www.pdinc.us -
> - Principal Consultant              10 West 24th Street #100    -
> - +1 (443) 269-1555 x333            Baltimore, Maryland 21218   -
> -                                                               -
> -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
> This message is copyright PD Inc, subject to license 20080407P00.
> 

RE: Finding leaf nodes.

[Jason Pyeron]

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Michael J Gruber 
> Sent: Monday, April 13, 2015 10:23
> 
> Jason Pyeron venit, vidit, dixit 12.04.2015 06:04:
> > I am trying to find all the unmerged commits [5].
> 
> "Unmerged" to which branch?

All. I was atempting to describe a leaf node.

> 
> It's not clear to me which commits you are looking for. By 
> "leaf node" I
> would describe a commit without child commits. "unmerged" can only be

That is exactly what I meant.

> understood relative to a specific branch.
> 
> Maybe you are looking for commits from remote refs which are 
> not on any
> local branch?

Anywhere, that I know about. If the commit does not have a child, then that commit needs to be in the list, I do not care about the branches.

> 
> > I can find, as a human, all the commits by git log 
> --oneline --graph --all [1] but I am looking for a scripted way.
> > 
> > But git show-branch  -a --independent misses some [2]
> 
> This finds refs which are not "contained in" (can be reached from) any
> of the other refs. If a remote ref is contained in another 
> remore ref it
> is not listed.

Your description is logical, but how can a commit be included in "another remote ref"?

> 
> > find .git/refs/ -type f -exec cat '{}' ';' | sort -u; finds 
> too much [3].
> 
> This finds all refs.

I know, the issue is I do not know how to filter it.

> 
> > The closest I get is with refs=`git show-ref -s`; git log 
> --format=%H $refs --not $(echo "$refs" | sed 's/$/^/') but it 
> too [4] gives me extra, but I am really not sure why. 
> 
> This finds all commits which are on some ref (branch/tag/..), 
> excluding
> those which are next to the tip or higher up from those refs.
> 
> > 
> > * | a54a4fb 
> > * | a0d2e63 
> > * | dd4400d 
> > | | *   68ea2c8
> > | | |\
> > | |/ /
> > |/| |
> > | | * c74d3c5 ??? Why is this the only extra commit listed ???
> 
> Because it is not "next to the tip", more specifically: not a first
> parent (foo^) of a referenced commit, and neither a 
> predecessor of one.

I need to think on what you just said for this one.

> 
> > | |/
> > |/|
> > * | 9c87570 
> > * | 717e33d 
> > * | 159799f 
> > 
> > 
> > What should I do to automate this?
> > 
> 
> Please try and restate what you mean by "unmerged commits". 
> Maybe remote
> commits not on any local branch, or remote commits not on master?

Regardless of branch references, I need to list all commits which do not have any child commits.

> 
> > 
> > 
> > 1:

See: yellow lines at http://client.pdinc.us/git-leaf-nodes-334e98c075877ce78b1ef959cb1155f7.html

> > 
> > 2:
> > 4d0579c438e9d750f158124284bd740a5a0e0e26
> > 68ea2c83978a7c023d76ebe438dd7d98fb1fd074
> > 982243cfde0dc6dfb1733d8e95748b7e687f57b8
> > C4bc3c4eb0015c73b50ea280a4a380e3cffc5160
> > 
> > 3:
> > 00ea00e8e6a23a4243316f860aa07ed59203ab97
> > 144eb9f673f14010c600766762b99cba1a64cc6e
> > 2250af4ad29b92b07365320c5ccb7a22c17f588e
> > 26bdfdfe71f7ceb4e0954bc5ab6c198481a280ae
> > 283be0f77477fcd8c8bc878c602538f8a3451403
> > 2f47330df8fb0357ef4e4d605d5c402150892a18
> > 3ec60ab0dbdc63760429187605ede4549d7b2bad
> > 43813b0fc44f7c41d2cdd4573145dbeb1aae1aee
> > 4d5b52d440d3a64953a6d7ef3cbb81c8d289e392
> > 556a5c2d759b51080e3bfe07a89b67e927749328
> > 6fe0b6db2718625e5eeb3cbadeb58aa858ab4f1b
> > 717e33d67ad3297a15cb432d3f70f7c12d353fa3
> > 7587a45658aa689cc774d7253007be3feb2eec23
> > ad9b5fa90c8f52b3ca31dd433c2c4b408e5f2a8f
> > b3d7623b74dd75cc4f965d6b37dc461d2786f912
> > c19fc45c87de85122952d63d28a0c7d3a18b79d5
> > e8529e95d89d3f519a31ef7de5bd7f0d0d318e8c
> > f2e86371e7fe3391023adccd61856d088db773dd
> > fceca0050ceee8c4996a5740f7122e96c4948dd8
> > 
> > 4:
> > c74d3c5cda60d8be7f38f1ec89c554a1346d57f8
> > 
> > 5: My remotes:
> > https://github.com/CipherShed/CipherShed.git
> > https://github.com/pdinc-oss/CipherShed.git
> > https://github.com/discnl/CipherShed.git
> > https://github.com/eaglgenes101/CipherShed.git
> > https://github.com/erkinalp/CipherShed.git
> > https://github.com/GigabyteProductions/CipherShed.git
> > https://github.com/jeffallen/CipherShed.git
> > https://github.com/kaydiechii/CipherShed.git
> > https://github.com/srguglielmo/CipherShed.git

--
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
-                                                               -
- Jason Pyeron                      PD Inc. http://www.pdinc.us -
- Principal Consultant              10 West 24th Street #100    -
- +1 (443) 269-1555 x333            Baltimore, Maryland 21218   -
-                                                               -
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
This message is copyright PD Inc, subject to license 20080407P00.