From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from mout.gmx.net (mout.gmx.net [212.227.17.22]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 2F74C338F4D for ; Wed, 27 Aug 2025 08:19:24 +0000 (UTC) Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.17.22 ARC-Seal:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1756282767; cv=none; b=LU/0dwnGuPSeKpoyPsMsaRDf2sTNwE+ms79weFHoiJVQ5VO1nUm9NSqaeZa92qVBGKm9x+pLwq3NvG3gbW46bxAzTFFo9I4empfMtF6kNtx47YkSvHjhW2qu5Ems6hrV/BNvsxTBM9L6LFQnuhM66YNKuqfnZug/CX8EnAQOp6A= ARC-Message-Signature:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1756282767; c=relaxed/simple; bh=eYX8IGmnRAURiqA0f+fjZ9CyTkfAJEU5WKPDf2/uV1E=; h=Date:From:To:Cc:Subject:Message-ID:References:MIME-Version: Content-Type:Content-Disposition:In-Reply-To; b=GT4thBluVr5YHeKNQgDCh1vCkXaZUVyAa9j0ciFrZkDLKIQ6TH8aEBP6MGoaJvEnBMkBY4DLjnl+pNmIZoQhCJdqsemibESc3TO/n88uLl0uSsOX7ZPq8mqeLPMpCdYiD6P0QTQ5qv/TrTUA6v9HwVv8Lx0xr1q+6edcZ0L5spQ= ARC-Authentication-Results:i=1; smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=gmx.de; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.de; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmx.de header.i=oswald.buddenhagen@gmx.de header.b=JIo7H7hM; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.17.22 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=gmx.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmx.de header.i=oswald.buddenhagen@gmx.de header.b="JIo7H7hM" DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmx.de; s=s31663417; t=1756282763; x=1756887563; i=oswald.buddenhagen@gmx.de; bh=eYX8IGmnRAURiqA0f+fjZ9CyTkfAJEU5WKPDf2/uV1E=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Date:From:To:Cc:Subject:Message-ID:References: MIME-Version:Content-Type:In-Reply-To:Content-Transfer-Encoding: cc:content-transfer-encoding:content-type:date:from:message-id: mime-version:reply-to:subject:to; b=JIo7H7hMnPgQLr39IUqdx6zNqNjkbQ/qAAP+JdaSc3tIGcQAfTGwYSX++8jHa8qm zJHye2i5KJn87ViMjJOb5i0H3P4dWuLv+L/p+3gyMj9SdU8irQ2cbljw27c81jCMY /No8yDqcqIDRWesJkqob9ygTrsk9p6bbe6NkQOvdhfpxFXI2OhNNz1ZukoiFpoUPv spz6yyvFOPQITNHny/AvpEnedmbpK04CgJttzW+j4ekmCF50dBJeII0t+5+VF8pu1 PG7rq7xLQPmZ8GrvhjEq2BFBTaQ2+GUt8XJkQsfNJZ2RCN5NoxLw0gkRFOM0Tp+jD ZeJqy1tDS+eoRIxhyA== X-UI-Sender-Class: 724b4f7f-cbec-4199-ad4e-598c01a50d3a Received: from ugly.fritz.box ([89.247.162.120]) by mail.gmx.net (mrgmx104 [212.227.17.168]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1N3KPq-1uQ82z0m8o-00tFoe; Wed, 27 Aug 2025 10:19:23 +0200 Received: by ugly.fritz.box (MasqMail 1.0.0, from userid 1000) id 1urBNK-TLV-00; Wed, 27 Aug 2025 10:19:22 +0200 Date: Wed, 27 Aug 2025 10:19:22 +0200 From: Oswald Buddenhagen To: phillip.wood@dunelm.org.uk Cc: git@vger.kernel.org, Ayush Chandekar , Taylor Blau , Kristoffer Haugsbakk Subject: Re: [PATCH v2 3/3] commit: print advice when core.commentString=auto Message-ID: References: <0e7c08b15e5923ae03f5630a8286c7dcebdbcfb9.1753975294.git.phillip.wood@dunelm.org.uk> Precedence: bulk X-Mailing-List: git@vger.kernel.org List-Id: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii; format=flowed Content-Disposition: inline In-Reply-To: X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:qZk05UiXqpLvn7WW51oqJcsDfJmqwTO8T3N+05EwXj8GdgIw7uW c8XVho+c+SBzbrNOG6x0DhcEkZ49EUM+HpEsYc6oDtL9Jq5HISb3RGX13GlHY96IE4BLlCd xOiR4Pg7dABlLiyOeBFlPM7kvR97SM7W6irptZrYz9zG5TnK7HepONoH1b4PJkRua1Lznjh PuOwT+wvzKqNCcDM3Jryw== X-Spam-Flag: NO UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:QZhJQ1YEyV4=;M7sK6PB9xV8MyhWq8JID0mxNFs+ xItYv72rJDIKqf0SyWPFMtts2dOfpvAcHf2l/OsjxE/vrvhXaeTeQvbK+aKlawgiYhZYs3AWn m/DWIE3lXr8rugZeAKcauHeHf0Pru0jJNiJXVfp0QLpHdXBnz6WTOWgCKMJWLFr83sThtQpnK ZVF11TDv6ky4+w23AW1Li39pQsXYebSo6G5gyCqonuFdp1q7lNpJ+JMxiWK+tj7MQcMJw16Bj r7TltQc161KxtKQgbSw7aXxusPGacCjHhHyZhXywjhNRBdCHToYNlKEWstkX3lFiqGN6q3g47 T8Voil+YFEcbKEdGogzmeWyQW9fb/BUAG4zNNcHsHe/Nz+REqLd6j+2lwgIBbmKl+MDsCTXId mhyDtIJ+lmWRe0UI0sdk2Li99XrdnZkFskrwr58wHiOK3ka8PC7TuW5bu55YkLWO/3R0PBg0V r7aW/EwDNgJziINvHSOyO8Roz24kQbAAlkDGNAOelja983m6CFTenVfV/P9j8xj+Tw0TGpaMw xMzA2096MOrc/9QLm+rwYpYtwvBsYRnBLG0SJtqpokjTgedWhaVoaOeX8pVG0S5kiBlxXJ/dV I9jmggR7+p53gWdnbVbcUVAzu/0gnUKK8ePBx6dTAaFiE9Ym/yyoI1FsML6m7JYZ4pOSiZ+h+ s7MDf0VjkUl0/zFN+h+KLcf7+rlqajuq8DNDrbGVcDopNlICjDU6Gaw+6NbbUFfcX++zkR7i6 IIM2ph6JVBEksIgmq4t8oVmqMutszalt0Dboda709s2kBIqOWZkOvsV74hpqBugRevvNHXerN MyU3uTJ6wgFackRSulbaA9XuH51At1Twy9g3uUWVm+N5D1Eb+znfKp3WYsNy5jGINHiVlzw2d 84DqLw3RxYzFx8dEVsKT1QGZxsl4VoFhmVQUtd3FSuVLGfA1MDzMrT8uD5qKg+mO/v5igJ59A s+rUPLyyNzB/WutZd072bE9IO8X+xO1QV3JQc2+mtI+sCpP50W3XRO9gU4Q/F1JFi5bu/IoFh I5vMo9F0Btw/MDiYOmQ1Hsc3oQviZnFy0A3VQXqcENlBVP64nQu/ndV3Mgw1vXAjsF4r4uLnF t76mJNZM3nnW6Onk/pExg9874FnHzVHi2ZAobTpdcekBboG2EgP1mI4su4KRnYncuPN/Y9d3R uydxygI2jZlKsXMEqnOBuCtUt7fPpcELP3deYPTrbYBOM+NOI3L++R7CEbfFVQYVIG9TxLr9g 07iseRra0ttCQkUTfMduoB8PsY0Pgf414OqyI9DCnki1EbRpzwdjmfXIumxbdrn23PnUVF/hY LDdXzPl+tnYD+cHHt1RoxHI9aLv5IEw5/T307wqyr1txeMOcMNpxLhs7cJhcUfYNYPjugcHr1 zPZyDVsW2wprsmGr/2HtzfR5nFbt1dzyCSnHZlDiL9u1SeQXkd5mlwgsmtkepIWghIdL/KUhO oexV5isHasejXeim+y6JxgnwFLhivNHzrFboPxqqur9FXPsqhIXRN8NO9WLIK0z47KngLAsaE Elxbh8NSQ2pvCKqyLl5Eof3UbD74f+bG3XGtaBVTM/5qJRHbNElRpcdKpM05lTIwR2wRIV3Jf LyEuPFOQt7AGzpT9LOdW5m5SMslrzzm5S4W1C5hV2IIKLBS79OSx9kdzukTBvp/sNhtaK92NK FABQg3cMcLr/MPCLMHthnJpsNwmlaEzxlH4QThtWUiAKSGJyeATBmEwSP+xIseEN1bqxaE5G3 gC2yTrt6TADrtjr5h38BvxJM0zktytuD9q2gx54JpTMSLQ/1lThu5E3Ggm+rW3mpe5mcav/P8 iJv3X3fyPf4qMQ3IeFaCFaVIgBh7Sg/PahLqhbsct4WyitTdWxMpcW7ge6siCMeLIiiQDT/fc 0vT/npytU32H9dk+/chy6rA0bV4NFZgEszEoQeqPJIJxmHfRKRSAR+KjgmlzsUHcXd7usNK5r 9efNljmaeISG77KRNmpq/CG8B+sV6z0NM2hvfzJva4Ta1DQvHpyzBBuq/K8pIS76ocDi0VzLT ao3O84NSBxb4DA4B66vb3CwWvUWkpZ80usgDBsdYT6U9lH4hUA7RxgaG7DwgvR/+ExhMlfPe6 agUm/6v6DBYHWxuIL78zu6oitPK1EhJS6iVXjj88rKnqV2SQWF7O2h4mr4D3JynpMpfF2r6a9 nMjHlhzWxjhBN1SXTMgK72pBpqDBm3SGjt385aItOcr33szXsKqls+eAf8FDnn1+bspfd5A3f JtP4yIUikQNS69LDmy2vebgM853FoPbPEWwzIQZFcckMid08hnDsac7TGCbCsDqGTQJppvXrQ fyZmjID7/D+1sx1KIMtkCBZ8lNhp3d0WO6EfMEuwLW1vMXX82JpkS8JxJs9OJiJsuspiOlWQt MNOveDGIxPXpX9JPYaTnvHExl3PZCHNL4g9XTskbqJ0tJI6c34db8vc6bqzga1BZVT2TFujPN qxsCyB0AfWFkKfun7HbhTpjMhKmyUXnOtFWXPe/e74eU4TH8WkUlQTRvjOnI/1Q5LtN6hwK4G FIbMfj/kOelym1FA+pnED+3UX0o21TB8Qv9eiJHHcQKnXEOWb7YRayTJfg3NqYuPpnxsn7agG cHJggMY86II+8utpJLBPanGPCLq+2WzWWYTYgSoVhN/suurlIKJDs/WvPyv1Yd0m3vBLmVh8t U/KBtmVwW/qJmU6Lhe/sCd9VAd5V4eixupldZHMXm4WlBSXkPJUVdcltJZBzl6r8B0JU97sxX ipx8QmnHy4K0pYybmFmhSq3e6qNEO7HqwtVFz2v+WxC0WmTlvtqjK7C16WrJcyzxVO0aopeF1 fwcRQCEGnBHm3448D2Ak2AbilX+0F+wA1mC55UTRAJM2XrZLqxSAOlGevT4ehsCfBVQY2tQaW dkCahF9nYECl/1/i53fTJXNXzHTtCvvwRVsmy251kpDRmiA8ZYndtBP6E/00LGKCw0LtgS09Y elg6B4RianMupWvPj9PNlC2avYafU13olOi5UQA1q+E6HKNqM6PzpLCldHcSr30x0gkbc0dw3 FihteVER747eFqLzA+gaHAqUs8vYWXZyJiY4fhZLxutdQ8BoltAcMM6+cKbGdWMkm0YQRvTQA Lv72hIJTeWnXlICy2/n3YF9anrskyOH+To+vsavpuWVatnB0SECeKTD+4axjjG2gPtWZSAjBo eqisp50Wtkk9jj0wM+xUkyCk1rlGKGtrNQmNeREPFQa0+C5Y4Mpcu5h6khelyB/Dd7dSIZynS KUNF4P3ZYTdiA0RO3SupqkqKBvKEnk3Lw2zBObuSPjYtWI1FzMOeIFEj/hBjz/KL3Y/4iuCMn XTgGb7TGTdA0n2O1680NSXisFqa13eausf4hhO+vZb+RGygMxle4+10WAgTEWzOuj0Xv/Oni0 Uk1Pmx8qlMhI4BTEA4h1kA4gY76fpdd4DdPi4pjK6Z+qtEsQEKg3bS/19Tq5xWInfXiFNBX2l WWctE+OO5xaFtbR1GjRXIDrHPwsc7x9lss0IfNBbE+Qt3Dxf1IHMcgUc6G6sht08C7srkOKM0 zp48P85gFlp+eOtvhIVp69zMWlF6HBeHwL4iCh13Eps1gOcyChKSihQDNsLqOdQCvJXcUjY5z DZqvNKpQ3uF43UX56Yt8r3T+BJL5Tw3tN2bWIUcnGTHvaNjvZw0S4mPnmeI2KkpShKUICdT8e wP4HGVMF9eWadW/cSz0y461KldX3Dp7vTn0TUvGbPTBCPfie+pyAj4N9/hR/661mH0di381Hk UXH3A2jsaLYEKNztgDzShg3yAo5f/IBQkq5x/6v9fshLQwSMp7cW83+k6GrA3aaQKEzaopx1X PVEATUQ2heUsJucqyn5zihrKnwU3TwGp5CwtxgtRRxCfXQJUI9O91Mh+/4r7mj+DvPipReK9/ lUTJuwR1vn8lDCX8KxMFLrNXBJxSiRBK03xdnqJXoWtQAqIsHPnmLJv25BjacoHUxR0w3vIA0 yzPIw5BZZCj0qe2nQfLXc1BbHedTv2CbDr08v+m4Kx/JlDCnI5lJ8GyeSqSC0YSIy+JRDiWv3 cPN4SgszQzrJHui5BOEQZl/qlSTgIxbJd11pep2Am+9/zvrol6wLsemz+ebGK9UwDzzrln7hT OclHmOtLBykpeRygMC5onwkx+MdQ9uKKxkwdsj4gv8EUMcrum7HYUfkngc9l4hACLtwGtd52t qhOlAucw/ZbCDuBdnbaNJHZqlc+sLNZU5YInjKYWuzi2NYB22vhPbueDKsaqpRTDBDCG4m0U+ zCZnhvIWHFjfCc3fo5NGkFeS/0U0BpwL3ebW651Qud7Rbe9glZEV700MYZDHAr4HXjksLblC4 0mabvkH9gOsZaBnF9pua5CYY8ekEl8S4UOZEbkOFrpMgGeOYwGgXxAgSq2LHFG8e3zJS/g+lN G5Hgh0LjUub8+iKHLsCRVgJQmiQ6J3UEqLdWBB5SObjWxriukPpYFFlFmqLE7aKkc54Sa0R73 SeXJ5eSbsiMA2ordK2WwcKr1hLc9hwfbZlWbKAlDejaAk1eey57+JJfeccsjJWckHZwOMNFzS Bejnios+LMyNh6qNwS4ZjZ+ccRLNjLhHYjEGeBn0JC7OMINbDBuLBjfltDy17bBOc1HqiqfVW 3Q78vE872v5GUidqbz20syoAofgOa0w/NE+dLGdNUml9TDS16Y7LYQXSJPJUMlhjuOHXDn1sF qhElDXz/bRFIWntySsCyxmldi/5Q Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable On Tue, Aug 26, 2025 at 02:33:10PM +0100, Phillip Wood wrote: >Some of git's reputation for being hard to use is well earned and I=20 >don't want to add to that. > i would find that reasoning compelling if we weren't talking about a=20 case that is likely to affect only very few, and probably rather=20 advanced users (who somehow managed to make the feature actually useful=20 for them - others would have quickly reverted the setting, because it=20 would have gotten into their way).