From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from mout.gmx.net (mout.gmx.net [212.227.15.15]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id B1285414A32 for ; Mon, 20 Jul 2026 12:15:36 +0000 (UTC) Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.15 ARC-Seal:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1784549758; cv=none; b=XUwjy8uoml8t1+DEYbqITg7GIBpNhCA/Q5OFnOCx/uHjStZ+LWoi0ZDCTKqL91tfm+lLGUZUjpqzXCK+wUiNdyZ96d4bVRz3R8oF1rzPs/p5mEDNrn+v9iS4MFaZuVqad8ZPIWhOW8S16yP3p/JihznpUzf85qsnAkM55Ll8bTs= ARC-Message-Signature:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1784549758; c=relaxed/simple; bh=K7QIEbPjTj1cFB5DYwYUWTNpJyf8j++kdE/mS0NVae4=; h=Date:From:To:Cc:Subject:Message-ID:References:MIME-Version: Content-Type:Content-Disposition:In-Reply-To; b=biEyxe0sHxaWuM2C8+GOrntaTiMyRInFv9NpiWu3FCdkzAI4ABoVccClxLj4niJzh9JhCGuv3JuEkoUulUfhEREyS7ti7/rXlbEzIbkU+/CRxcwO02/U1WoGSWd4nHjnfiNW5tbYMmHxoLu56VhREpR64yO9WQnTyB9KjQ4HZlg= ARC-Authentication-Results:i=1; smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=gmx.de; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.de; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmx.de header.i=oswald.buddenhagen@gmx.de header.b=ACBv2vh4; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.15 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=gmx.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmx.de header.i=oswald.buddenhagen@gmx.de header.b="ACBv2vh4" DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmx.de; s=s31663417; t=1784549731; x=1785154531; i=oswald.buddenhagen@gmx.de; bh=wr0t0rRIIKQUgDdv8IJuTCz3b8np6qeFbceOKzAsUBY=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Date:From:To:Cc:Subject:Message-ID:References: MIME-Version:Content-Type:In-Reply-To:Content-Transfer-Encoding: cc:content-transfer-encoding:content-type:date:from:message-id: mime-version:reply-to:subject:to; b=ACBv2vh464HR/AlAAnY4uzlbfSa9rJ7J7F5j1uq7l9r2FFxhCmFrczgNdeD/BSSY B4aiYAKSqP5z/RKiuAEIl1lpYhqKlTKZqzPxEOZLsbReRHio7LKaKgVgHUfqa+F+O UkH2KKxWFYpTO3NG+jRc4m+LIEE//7ZXBTHBcLTYqwZ0v/g165rNXkuF3K875ulGA f59Sek4fR0CbZ9VYZ2Eq3epdqcgutFvObcfAVfX1RlR8lUxOPNx0KBP1t4jWACMSk B38VdNGM4LJZE+sFW05f+KgJDRlDMTlg48jKrcDTECThr2Ngh4TLhZLWGmEvoj36I 4tacx23y1K+nmOxLHw== X-UI-Sender-Class: 724b4f7f-cbec-4199-ad4e-598c01a50d3a Received: from client.hidden.invalid by mail.gmx.net (mrgmx004 [212.227.17.190]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1My36T-1wvcE801Fv-012Zew; Mon, 20 Jul 2026 14:15:31 +0200 Received: by ugly.fritz.box (MasqMail 1.0.0, from userid 1000) id 1wlmuA-t99-00; Mon, 20 Jul 2026 14:15:30 +0200 Date: Mon, 20 Jul 2026 14:15:30 +0200 From: Oswald Buddenhagen To: Junio C Hamano Cc: git@vger.kernel.org Subject: Re: [PATCH v3 0/9] sequencer: do not record dropped commits as rewritten Message-ID: References: Precedence: bulk X-Mailing-List: git@vger.kernel.org List-Id: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii; format=flowed Content-Disposition: inline In-Reply-To: X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:IvX+suT66g/uH0pTRBNREUAdMJkra6xf8peXpddxPw6aQ+SjB3H iN1N3WL1nFXr1zU0xsIUpOM0jBHkXFjzubX6cCPlVEs9N+kfn/qjTVVLAwg3/CPJjUIVGh5 uJls5pg+go/S3BGOhtslpdFBfehAC0pN+UkJ2kWuKUOjQcwjeX8Rd450h5AfdQhUv39GlFx PNv7+uifT8DDT6mLtA4NQ== X-Spam-Flag: NO UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:XVFfuqMN0Nw=;65uhemgcXbwmBhriAFdBTbwId3k PTMf68LxtgkX+ywAL0ggxOs0e4QVSMNpkXl5ncuvRVWku9+i7fwgPf984Y2VYGjjrabevxdES /pxULsWaltvrzP9DOUDUIr+bN/WhO7YCI/H50wIrBKabfU97LY6lFXTlwpVYTyTKn79eNetoZ PPlYGz/4ey4tjzum3Yapxb0v/KJ6lNHsfB7SGuwUW75r2eLrIUzjhIcxLk2Cbj9AHwFFRGW54 EeKE9XlfgL7d03MQkxJqaJ8bD9iSwomzKAq6UU9HYydK1g2V2a5oHhlNPxY/wXoSh2RIfLDHk l+0iQKrDBMeFi+YeYS6nzHtYRxNUR7li3pCUgP+/12UuQVF3YntSI8Ask7lpM9X5Ubr95xHBK j0oOWtCLE8q+DwKGIey0pwPWlHA0SWQ5liherWLbpe26ff50A27IdtrOnecCbZz01SDRsEYud F8CfHnVeyXCt1XIYg2F1bxKHbbuU8GSN/2EkoUWAwN+MNgOPryK6CWEb4OjfcN9WU86R+IIuw 8zZ+6VQzn7j4KPjYfk/quKcqD4k6rxm/l9ingDS9+Bz1C4DaWWD+jMLRvpyjuVB+8/+PNdZKt y3SQ9ITSWtYqfwgUcB1KXY8jyhNxMQ2MRgDojhc0NDrwC3D9aqjUNtEhSSIkebcokcuvmYZFe iPVvdg5dGa38Q8yA62ZS7JeZraspf/Hb9VpGYxcBL4+YELec2YhWkYkJ98pDzblpphQkFZ3JT 7WFJsBBln6hMSXQrlz4APCWKeGk09PZotfa/GZpzuowPaufzgwq4MhBfz+GXHlgJ20IQR9W2j wmDnfrASNIe+Ys2fl3EgerpoTNPqU2OLVg/yxSODHr6lwPtozt+DGcStvSnXgkPvF5bfhClzB c0jNdgI75wbTQ0RXCM8YLkppYMxJLx02kib3xymMrz7ifRhL9Brhz2oOlwzTiY3SSBHnUPUO6 aRQp5trjSOiPog0VVaQzaT3JMDfw+zHwWrLV4yeYT+V/qpSuIery42Rk8xHC29hb9dnCA0KQc 7FYBQmWkeA5rTfrpPeBHC8rlnce11HxJVVXZ6PZ6M1OYyzh3kwiQN0TLk17eIBNhe+dDJmbv/ m6sW530vbHdoFbdC+6YiH34rt/GFxIcI2KqZi3Wj/uk7x5h6bFckRc+a71oXPzxee5JwxaRlA +RjqepRH4VSWCY+a9QDwBF014D5x303faKbJc9ad31chPGi0mBBdD8fq59hcCKHjuMEuaLzO/ XpKxGJD2fBcI9vSXsflIuNz7Wc8ec+E+6g+1YwqPLV4Y6cIXZz2VqmvD3SnhOtjGydrwnzBhZ tiqWaY5R1cFLn/PPFGZ2LxMTLdOjDaowrAfC+BkVUfWh8lzxgvHDjLbIjyGtPdyB5SSkPCjO8 fOFkefxu0usgHb3m5b4+JbsPZMr3NU+k7j29PlVl6ovqbI8SWqehBbw+a3FgmZj8sueySk/LO 3JW+vuzTId9mOgJa0v9R43rb+EyrzrAiE8ATRnFTZDWZ7c/ZYekNHeOBr17JR7Vs+xxOdQT86 F2LWYX1qhH4ZdNOd8FEbkAY7+xisL6Ae1gcHtB8kRTbA+zIgtc2EaCEkkHZbeisuDUMZ+Sgbt UC70Wo9Z4iZ24I3wqTYI2f+ytTJfynWEGo/U585bfRfGaZ73Ak95bFg0SPn3o8DFTMvmHcAj3 nhrOOM7pE9439OFDXFdzpk8ocA/TwJ48KymY2EoG+4dXLFPOwaEIzhm1Z17Je+1hXCM/sQx7v U5BgZ66c7oc1Tb7HUP+nLAUuKT1uAMjR8oYGESORg3gXz9G5Itv72AJOka+mx3d7tgWzguQq2 K9EDGIjYyWAWTGUsARPMvNNPtIPuQRAghOq0Qdfp0CqOD5vN4qjjNuFAPDoH5+AiWI/6/1lL6 pqYDMJNJA2EcSoUbHa3d2e2o3AQd5faCShSpAfPLlfvlzywdj+tc8DZjUBI+CfEasuxYY/s2I ULTHool1nfUDfrZCwhMwIhlD7adkSK194aI+DmB6jCXn2AXtk+ikz95Gp/e13X7f8lGYiNGgZ StUK5ou0jHnRyJDUrw9foP7pJsPxLcCojZ5LCFdsPy7rto9vSFWzYI0cWHXz2fLwRC1clH+7X zJXAjRTWXdmyen8f/LMJWzS9frU6DQeyq1/pAf7h74CzplXgl0QTtp3m9XWiWSkx+WO/6Wz0X /xdoph4+z9Kl58Q5EAMqMpwRKjO2JLkthXJc5T6aQR0iDjlClJeL5ADKQv3aAWpkAHFkMkLLX lLK0QTeGQLcaf9BzCkGTTgVz7iEttvHEf4UmUlhROo8+i6mE61Bxr7rF70ausPjpQMJx5S2PA /tlpiB5V4VQKrMXyy5llklk/KtJkvGwWGY1Kte8ic6yb0ZN8WinHQud/AKfUAW74NAyLDLmzz YG5kdVgI3TQ8acMb2VfeNw24cM3gcUIB1Tbh41rfoh93Et5XY8PSriVXxGxqgpmAqgrE8nd5V +Qr45gUQvqUtgNC8j2dh2QrOT0cqKZw4cGuFQkWfFCIGIGb+EYXJZ/29Bs9lxht1W0xCGaJef a7NJPJe54qbmw+UMa5/Ac/8Lv7EHeF4C6i3ca3rsTQpysvDZyhhlMm3NCyyU4FOz/DfVK6VA3 dQz9OTZTx1GeovX4BOO9HUbeU2yKNb3cDTWuqhkF6dP0GJ39yheMCfUlNSRtdMSsAFA8uW2yr ZkrfousW1/Eb0QY/c87TtleSZ6oarDuofTIdLpA9rlSR17reyxBZ4gk+I3vjprFL+ubKp6gTm ANPYBba9k4c7N4QZg2KhraM9xhAIas7t35jCYUxkoEKX7xiGshiuiOJ67D6za+JftTRIb1BEs iQnc6/WHyfq3lz11BjPdDPmP5jxf9aZjlf6uYfXxR+S9ZzCcWFyMn0UQgo16n0Jtv6ExCMbm2 xLaT5u1vY2OS2frsur4S8OIdFLRWjOGPvHp+UUsESkeynhnvOyZ+Z80VxTLEiRya+iOu8s9UU /8fJsSG9ZJE64NTkuAe1yU/1h4MHlsD1FoaQhpdXVXqRL+EU6gbEeKZK5qN57c9DuC709TCU2 xN40GF/5OiAdKF06nMMNReDqVN9YrQ/5VESQF6Dfn2VG88Cp3eQQ1++Vryeu94fjC7d7u3XQO PxKY59jEBiZ2JkPwYaJzsSyzR86cP+/sP+M6PViJVYOfjj3zT3Dwj3N95Hix5/ApHflcuC/+/ Xd9dVDt+GZZsE1RqTlWVAIC+ynolsEt2j+5tBioHWarlwzOZkgfhpXhPyD09EgydhpLSYTFGt 8oT9NmwmiFWCWKZDdDIcS1MPC2H+lKNRE5WfbhOq3x8s9NRzOc21a3IS2H8ot6335qwSq7z7P rlxnCX+aNPLxny9MXSmbzRp3IQtqt3xbFYSrIJod1Gb61u88ref4+z+xT7Sq6XBk0olIf/Kmp V9Auo62288CFCt8/MZRErjXs1Ts6MX0mZZmtxQiSwaHck8RlDe181AHGe+XXBHAFVkapa0tob dERXoESM+n8QQjM7fDvXRyKK1ebsk9KFkUOGJGTdr1GRur63YqRmY4/5dKsC7AIGQYlM0MdBB d/31puwMgahvoTB5UdK9Be09h8INLXWZph3W+96yOMzwuzR2j6+KUvi/PFd6OsO7FnxAR387W RqgZRxbK8Xyafh0+WRyqiTQhUtB0WctKmCfFwFgFwqmgfv5squiDvYLFGP6zF+tXO4V7BFmkv 6e8gUkoZx6YnCSpkZRFGqlHyzYUoORdvqu+2HIYEByZaxEwh/fKaizaO7FIvosltXyTQ0PZ0j uvZqdwx+oGy6YzAsX8J/KezeWl9swh1DZDY3Zh9eSVvarh+91mr3k1pYya+sybNs2ua41zMCt MjJ/QPG/lQ4F8YsIbAVHbLiphMZ6f4drN4HWs6DPeigioJsHYp+VGLVCQg79oL3JJJOQ3K2Wv df7Orn9DKPg7D2vS7fNBa1iY44+viuUxBfOq+it1F2WAVtVmE10o4eccmpaLSfmjxYGC/Ggtp DseIopSatTGMCTTGOmwqr8VmwuMca7qSADQ+hRFvzJJSF6UMEsMF4eywx1mrU1qBWqI/dDXfC 9oXuVkuhdG1fFX/8cTdLIi2g2OSzRo1sdGqlAZQ6TgXp48jFyJoNrxR9gWX6cWWcD41dot3O8 n0iz/enHOaVl8NwPKqMeeAdJQ+6FySYNG6Redpqd/1cbMAWjEvICXSsqmi5jY6PQK3QB4WFxd hEhjAajHTPxwA4t6SoyvbgbX5BkNiSz26NYpm0p4iYYcjTLugmeMS1BmLogL7IvtsoHwS5k0F M77RTUQihd8eaTHLb1myZ5GLVRtXQABbSqQMltJ+NSUD0b3aB1p5Rp92vwh//XA0iyDEokQbp PkRQA2yuopWkDPbFKFaLhlnOJpwcsLs+qfbCq5M9m9HqXens3r3nPzJobyTgb0tQLUw5Z8kFX /QCzGZl0pkXLoQ9olT3w5Aog51matJDVm12gOOpWNiZEEBGavqOLHLA0D9u5ufL02c9yguKLt I1V6uEaUUCd8vSkVDHaqLCngmcT+aedy5EJUBKy6ukE0qqwmx/yRleOFxp0Hyj7GetASS26LD ryK7F0JuvZ/qSGwam5TXOB+eQYyfGwMNWu+3tYTL5fPOT01ys5tx6F/LRo67SL2B1sAsyqu6y CYPj98/LreKG3n9tFtJHIa9PIwF5AZ/4atMrrWuhzuw7qHriCGMu/dBrfaUOt4LSAANYRybh+ dncDAad2mKpAO+NN+IG7JYbwe8CSaVZSTIkS3H/eEd3EQzzP8c4ikjYYfNX/20PwfEzzgVEwN 7hsHq/FyFr7YqMq/ReGdooIuPpjBFdLHINOExqctdCg1c81D+wtwMsLThPCBBD/p/7P+PUG++ EcR28pvcVeKqm7pVjqB4iHlTT+ypL8CkogWjqUTCUmsXmLtp9EnJYd2TyrXfRllNKstpViIGV vvhObGPL5ykkF2Eb2HjKEyHtsmI026urNhsKabeJ3fAwz6V8nJcYtkqkBeoKudLqwRf6fKTiS TFDvcXHNZtp45kfnLRiuPZ+CZ+0mvqINSKL7I9mAUfmiia5a84Rn/2i8+wIlWgO9HDOEHlRyG SYuw/CJ/Hru5H21cmMD9quuYjjVVvN9oJ827PTT+LvURmk8sqB97rn07zE0WPpsLbX4jJZjf/ E1K6VQaaFTEN3lluPFAJss1mbV4Cw4q5CLkAi5hIc/i3+tUc8vHNpzQNaB13CtRu1A2xTpq7c +ophVJmz+cr0cr2/d+pi4rdGwGMrpWIw1y9GQey+0R4lBsCcjWS26uhZwHaogO9rJRx3SfWYk aPa/az+FAW8gLztwJ1DtaG7ZTA8z5KVodzVu9ZCezQMMREvJDMVWoZenbcu/Ez0eONmO8wrRj FnV2Ft1SCdXySvuAknPVLO7im0XRZVXGAnddoqlOHO5hkM0L+jf1426woGVcaX5SfvcUMhPrU vTOUizC3dBX6WZhX+4/E3bhWBx7oYeP5B2HR+k23iJQZWwMKJEIbsg5NXVKF+7hqbGnNZtSRH ufMuYxEq6oe0y6ZJSt1/v+H8M8DZXPL7LBDDgbZF7QRedDUUzrWdorIGiyTGKLVTiBcHnHRQm ufoJqPgAR0GnOtbKyUeE3+Kw6CfwwLYKxwwQDxpVYH0nFySZ4y89a+VXQEzV2tXdG3jPGQ== Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable On Sun, Jul 19, 2026 at 12:29:31PM -0700, Junio C Hamano wrote: >It looks like this is now ready to go? Any further comments? > you can add whatever footer is appropriate for "i read it, it seems to=20 make sense, but i didn't double-check" for me. (same for phillip's new 2-patch series.) (it feels silly to "spam" the list with such low-value verdicts. i=20 really miss gerrit code review here, where i'd leave a +1 in passing.)