Re: More questions and patches for 835GM/ns2501 DVO

[Thomas Richter <thor@math.tu-berlin.de>]

Hi Daniel,
>> I also tried a lot with the two-monitor case and again went deeply into the
>> DPLL setup logic.
>> The differences I observed before are simply due to the initial resolution
>> (800x600), in the final
>> resolution, the DPLL settings are actually correct. What I get there is:
> I suspect that due to the pipe A quirk logic we actually get the setup
> sequence for the DPLLs completely wrong. This will require a bit more
> magic to make it work correctly ... But I have some ideas.
> -Daniel
Well,  maybe. The register contents that are listed in my mail are read 
out from the hardware exactly when the
DVO gets stuck, actually right before it. From what I can see from there 
is that the PLL setup and DVO setup
look actually ok (from what I can tell). What is also remarkable is that 
the DVO-reenable logic does succeed by
writing the same value to the DPLL_A and DPLL_B registers, which is the 
proper value for a 1024x768 screen. However,
the DPLL_B register value is correct, whereas the DPLL_A register 
contains values that are likely useful for the VGA
output.

Now, here is the miracle: The DVOC register indicates that the DVO gets 
its input from pipe B. However, writing the
correct value into DPLL_A (!) (remember, DPLL_B is already set 
correctly) revives the DVO.

Thus, I wonder how this can be. The only explanation I have is that the 
DVO is still fed by pipe A, and not by pipe B.
Maybe there is something else that needs to be done to switch the DVO to 
pipe B.

Anyhow, happy to take your ideas. Unfortunately, I will again not have 
this specific laptop available for some while. I do have an R31 for 
testing, though its display is connected via LVDS and not via a DVO. The 
chipset seems to be similar otherwise, though.

Greetings,
     Thomas