Re: [kvm-devel] [PATCH 00/11] KVM updates for Linux 2.6.24-rc review

Laurent Vivier
2007-10-21T12:38:21Z

Avi Kivity a écrit :
> Laurent Vivier wrote:
>> Avi Kivity a écrit :
>>> Avi Kivity wrote:
>>>> The following patches fix fallout from the main 2.6.24 KVM merge. An
>>>> exception is the movnti emulation patch, which adds support for Linux
>>>> 2.6.16 guests.
>>>>
>>>> The patches can be found in kvm.git in the branch kvm-updates-2.6.24.
>>>> There is also a branch kvm-updates-2.6.25 which will form the basis of
>>>> the next merge window submission.
>>>>
>>>> Please review the patches and let me know if something is wrong or if
>>>> a patch is missing.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>
>>> Laurent, I believe the following patch (in kvm-updates-2.6.25) needs
>>> to go into 2.6.24 as well. Can you comment on this?
>> What kind of comment do you want ?
>
> Well, whether it needs to go into .24.
>
>> What are the requirements to go in 2.6.24 instead of 2.6.25 ?
>>
>> Is a bug correction enough ? :-P
>>
>
> It has to fix something real-life, in a real guest.
>
>> This patch correct a bad behavior of x86_emulate_insn() in case of
>> error with a REP prefix.
>>
>> This patch is needed because, without it, when REP prefix is used with
>> an instruction failing for some reasons (like IO or page fault) we
>> don't restore all modified registers (like RSI and RDI), but only ECX
>> and EIP, so when we re-enter in x86_emulate_insn() we modify again an
>> already modified value. Moreover, this patch manages correctly the
>> case where the instruction fails in writeback().
>>
>
> Okay, I guess it is needed. Can you backport it to the branch? It's
> very different from kvm-updates-2.6.24...
>

Well, in fact it is not needed in 2.6.24, because this patch correct a bad
behavior introduced by commit 57f4e446ebca4aad5c11364baf8477c8cfcb16a4 (which is
not in kvm-update-2.6.24):

KVM: Call x86_decode_insn() only when needed

Move emulate_ctxt to kvm_vcpu to keep emulate context when we exit from kvm
module. Call x86_decode_insn() only when needed. Modify x86_emulate_insn() to
not modify the context if it must be re-entered.

So, in fact, the answer is (after correctly understanding the question): no,
this patch is not needed in kvm-update-2.6.24.

Regards,
Laurent
--
---------------- Laurent.Vivier@bull.net -----------------
"Given enough eyeballs, all bugs are shallow" E. S. Raymond