Re: RFC: ioapic polarity vs. qemu os-x guest

["Michael S. Tsirkin" <mst@redhat.com>]

On Tue, Feb 11, 2014 at 01:23:31PM -0500, Gabriel L. Somlo wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> I'm trying to get OS X to work as a QEMU guest, and one of the few
> remaining "mysteries" I need to solve is that the OS X guest hangs
> during boot, waiting for its boot disk to be available, unless the
> following KVM patch is applied:
> 
> 
> diff --git a/virt/kvm/ioapic.c b/virt/kvm/ioapic.c
> index ce9ed99..1539d37 100644
> --- a/virt/kvm/ioapic.c
> +++ b/virt/kvm/ioapic.c
> @@ -328,7 +328,6 @@ int kvm_ioapic_set_irq(struct kvm_ioapic *ioapic, int irq, int irq_source_id,
>  	irq_level = __kvm_irq_line_state(&ioapic->irq_states[irq],
>  					 irq_source_id, level);
>  	entry = ioapic->redirtbl[irq];
> -	irq_level ^= entry.fields.polarity;
>  	if (!irq_level) {
>  		ioapic->irr &= ~mask;
>  		ret = 1;
> --
> 
> 
> After digging around the KVM source for a bit, and printk-ing things
> from Windows 7, Fedora 20, and OS X (10.9), I figured out the following:
> 
> 
> 1. Edge-triggered interrupts are invariably unaffected by the xor line
> being removed by the patch. On all three guest types, edge-triggered
> interrupts have polarity set to 0, so the xor is essentially a no-op,
> and we can forget about it altogether.
> 
> 
> 2. Windows and Linux always configure all level-triggered interrupts
> with polarity 0 (active-high, consistent with QEMU's ACPI/DSDT, in
> particular q35-acpi-dsdt.dsl, which is what I'm using with -M q35).
> As such, on Windows and Linux, the xor line in question is still a
> no-op.
> 
> 
> 3. OS X (all versions I tried, at least since 10.5/Leopard) always
> configures all level-triggered interrupts with polarity 1 (active-low),
> regardless of what the QEMU DSDT says. As such, the xor line acts as
> a negation of "irq_level", which at first glance sounds reasonable.
> 
> However: when KVM negates "irq_level" due to "polarity == 1", the OS X
> guest hangs during boot.
> 
> OS X works fine when "polarity == 1" is ignored (with the xor line
> commented out).
> 
> This may be another instance (similar to how OS X didn't use to check
> with CPUID regarding monitor/mwait instruction availability) where
> apple devs know that any of their supported hardware advertises
> active-low in the DSDT, so no need to check, just hardcode that
> assumption... :)
> 
> 
> 4. With s/ActiveHigh/ActiveLow/ in QEMU's q35-acpi-dsdt.dsl, Linux
> actually switches to "polarity == 1" (active-low), and works fine
> *with the xor line removed* !!!. With the xor line left intact (i.e.
> without the above patch), the active-low fedora guest worked extremely
> poorly, and printed out multiple error messages during boot:
> 
> 	irq XX: nobody cared (try booting with the "irqpoll" option)
> 	...
> 	Disabling IRQ #XX
> 
> for XX in [16, 18, 19, ...].
> 
> 
> So, right now, I'm wondering about the following:
> 
> 
> 1. Regarding KVM and the polarity xor line in the patch above: Does
> anyone have experience with any *other* guests which insist on setting
> level-triggered interrupt polarity to 1/active-low ? Is that xor line
> actually doing anything useful in practice, for any other guest, on
> either QEMU or any other platform ?
> 
> 
> 2. Is there anything in QEMU (besides the ACPI DSDT .dsl files) which
> has a hardcoded assumption re. "polarity == 0", or active-high, for
> level-triggered interrupts? I tried to dig through hw/i386/kvm/ioapic.c
> and a bunch of other files, but couldn't isolate anything that I could
> "flip" to fix things in userspace.
> 
> 
> Any ideas or suggestions about the appropriate way to move forward would
> be much appreciated !!!
> 
> 
> Thanks much,
> --Gabriel

I think changing ACPI is the right thing to
do really. But we'll need to fix some things
first of course.

I think it's PC Q35 that has this assumption.
hw/i386/pc_q35.c

        gsi = qemu_allocate_irqs(kvm_pc_gsi_handler, gsi_state,
                                 GSI_NUM_PINS);

kvm_pc_gsi_handler simply forwards interrupts to kvm.

and

hw/isa/lpc_ich9.c
static void ich9_lpc_update_pic(ICH9LPCState *lpc, int pic_irq)
{
    int i, pic_level;

    /* The pic level is the logical OR of all the PCI irqs mapped to it */
    /* The pic level is the logical OR of all the PCI irqs mapped to it
 * */
    pic_level = 0;
    for (i = 0; i < ICH9_LPC_NB_PIRQS; i++) {
        int tmp_irq;
        int tmp_dis;
        ich9_lpc_pic_irq(lpc, i, &tmp_irq, &tmp_dis);
        if (!tmp_dis && pic_irq == tmp_irq) {
            pic_level |= pci_bus_get_irq_level(lpc->d.bus, i);
        }
    }

so somewhere we need to flip it, I am guessing in ich9
along the lines of:

-    pic_level = 0;
-            pic_level |= pci_bus_get_irq_level(lpc->d.bus, i);
+    pic_level = 1;
+            pic_level &= !pci_bus_get_irq_level(lpc->d.bus, i);




-- 
MST