RE: 2.6.16-rc5: known regressions [TP 600X S3, vanilla DSDT]

Yu, Luming
2006-03-15T06:49:01Z

>> If you remove the real THM0._TMP, and fake a dummy THM0._TMP in
>> DSDT, and don't change anything in kernel, then if S3 works well, I
>> will be convinced that THM0._TMP was causing trouble.
>
>I'll try it, to test my theory above! But one clarification first: Do
>you mean that I use a vanilla thermal.c, or should I keep using the
>modified thermal.c with zone_to_keep=0 as the module parameter? I
>don't think I revert to the vanilla thermal.c. Suppose that there are
>two bugs, which I think is likely (see previous email). Commenting
>out only THM0._TMP but preserving everything else in the DSDT & kernel
>might eliminate any bug caused by THM0._TMP. But if it still hangs --
>and I'm pretty sure it will -- it means there's a another bug
>somewhere else.

Ok, I'm fine whatever way you choose to start, But I think you need to
verify
the findings with the UN-modified kernek ,UN-modified Thermal.c and
others
that can reproduce S3 hang with UN-modified DSDT.