Resume problems on Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G

Resume problems on Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G

[Michael Schierl]

Hi,

My new notebook, a Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G, does not resume after
suspend (echo mem >/sys/power/state).

Since my old notebook worked with APM, ACPI stuff is quite new for me; I
 tried several things but with no success.

What happens:

- I boot a minimal kernel (vanilla 2.6.15.2), with init=/bin/bash to
  minimize userspace problems (root fs = ext3, mounted read only)
- I mount /sys and echo mem >/sys/power/state
- my notebook seems to suspend properly, everything powers down, power
  LED is flashing. (I cannot eject CD now)
- when pressing the power button (the notebook cannot be waken up by
  pressing keys on the keyboard, but that is the same on Windows, so
  most likely by design), the power LED changes to light (without
  flashing), and the CDROM spins up. (Now I can eject CD). Screen is
  dark and remains so until I power it down hard (by pressing power
  button for 5 seconds).
- when compiling in network support and netconsole support (and enabling
  netconsole to maybe get error messages), the
  behaviour changes: the CDROM still spins up but the power LED remains
  flashing. (you can find the .config at
  http://home.arcor.de/mschierlm/test/acpi/_config ) No reaction on the
  net console after suspend.
- The notebook does not have any serial ports.

Next I patched the kernel with acpi-release-20050902-2.6.15.diff.bz2, no
changes. Patching it with acpi-test-20051216-2.6.15.diff.bz2 (after
unapplying the old patch), no changes either. The reaction with a
"non-minimal" kernel is like the one with the minimal one.

Next I downloaded acpica-unix-20060217.tar.gz and decompiled my DSDT.
Result is in same place as _config. Recompiling it only creates one
warning about no return value in _WAK. There are lots of tutorials
around, some say it does not matter, others say I should add a return
value. So I added a return value, but did not notice any changes in
behaviour.

The next issue was to check if the dsdt uses any _OS checks. The only
match for _OS in the file is in line

If (CondRefOf (_OSI, Local0))

which is quite unrelated I guess (I don't understand that ACPI
"programming language", but it seems that _OSI is something else than
_OS). So if I understood the tutorial correctly, there is no need to try
different ACPI os names.

I'm out of ideas now.

Any suggestions what to do to make my new notebook suspend on Linux? It
suspends fine on Windows and the latest BIOS update is installed.

Please CC me since I am not on the list. Thank you,

Michael

Re: Resume problems on Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G

[Shaohua Li]

On Fri, 2006-03-03 at 05:45 +0800, Michael Schierl wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> My new notebook, a Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G, does not resume
> after 
> suspend (echo mem >/sys/power/state).
> 
> Since my old notebook worked with APM, ACPI stuff is quite new for me;
> I 
>  tried several things but with no success.
> 
> What happens:
> 
> - I boot a minimal kernel (vanilla 2.6.15.2), with init=/bin/bash to 
>   minimize userspace problems (root fs = ext3, mounted read only) 
> - I mount /sys and echo mem >/sys/power/state 
> - my notebook seems to suspend properly, everything powers down,
> power 
>   LED is flashing. (I cannot eject CD now) 
> - when pressing the power button (the notebook cannot be waken up by 
>   pressing keys on the keyboard, but that is the same on Windows, so 
>   most likely by design), the power LED changes to light (without 
>   flashing), and the CDROM spins up. (Now I can eject CD). Screen is 
>   dark and remains so until I power it down hard (by pressing power 
>   button for 5 seconds). 
> - when compiling in network support and netconsole support (and
> enabling 
>   netconsole to maybe get error messages), the 
>   behaviour changes: the CDROM still spins up but the power LED
> remains 
>   flashing. (you can find the .config at 
>   http://home.arcor.de/mschierlm/test/acpi/_config ) No reaction on
> the 
>   net console after suspend. 
> - The notebook does not have any serial ports.
If the video is dark, please try the boot options listed in
documentation/power/video.txt.
Did the keyboard response after resume?

Thanks,
Shaohua

Re: Resume problems on Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G

[Michael Schierl]

Hi Shaohua,

Shaohua Li schrieb:
> On Fri, 2006-03-03 at 05:45 +0800, Michael Schierl wrote:

> If the video is dark, please try the boot options listed in
> documentation/power/video.txt.

I tried them (all three variations of acpi_sleep=), no change.

Since I do not have a Radeon graphics "card" (it's an Intel 91x), I did
not try those radeon specific tweaks.

> Did the keyboard response after resume?

The Num and Caps Lock LEDs do work (the notebook does not have a Scroll
Lock LED). Typing "reboot" has no effect, though.

I tried the same setup without SATA support, but from an initial ramdisk
instead. Same results, so it is most probably not the SATA driver.

Michael

Re: Resume problems on Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G

[Michael Schierl]

Shaohua Li schrieb:

> Did the keyboard response after resume?

it works even better. If I compile in sysrq support, I can reboot the
box after "resume" by pressing alt+sysrq+b.

when I do

mount /sys
setleds +caps
echo mem >/sys/power/state
setleds +num

the num lock LED switches on after "resume". When adding a while loop

while true; do
setleds +num
setleds -num
done

the num lock LED flashes as expected, so the notebook is still running,
yet quite disconnected from the outside world.

however, when I do not do setleds before suspend, or when I do any other
action that accesses my hard disk before turning on the led, it does not
work. So I guess the hard disk has some problems with suspend as well.

anything else to try?

Michael

Re: Resume problems on Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G -- SATA

[Michael Schierl]

[added linux-ide to CC]

Shaohua Li schrieb:

> If the video is dark, please try the boot options listed in
> documentation/power/video.txt.

Okay, I got video working on vanilla 2.6.16 by using "vbetool post" and
"vbetool vbestate restore" directly after "echo mem >/sys/power/state".

I copy all stuff need into tmpfs to ensure that it can restore the video
without hard disk access.

when accessing hard disks first time after resume, I get (wrote it by
hand so maybe this is not 100% correct)

ata1: handling error / timeout
ata1: port reset  p_ is 400000 is 0 pis 400000 cmd 8007
                          tf 80 ss 113 se 405000
ata1: status = 0x50 {DriveReady SeekComplete}
sda: current: senseKey 0x0 ASC  0x0 ASCQ 0x0

Sometimes there is "cmd 6" instead of "cmd 8007".

What to do, what to test?

I don't have any way of getting information out of my machine after
resume except on display (hard disks do not work after resume, the
notebook does not have a serial port and network does not work after
resume either) and by flashing keyboard LEDs, so transcribing huge dmesg
output would be a pain...

Please CC me since I am not on the list(s). Thank you.

Michael

Re: Resume problems on Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G -- SATA

[Mark Lord]

Michael Schierl wrote:
..
> Okay, I got video working on vanilla 2.6.16 by using "vbetool post" and
> "vbetool vbestate restore" directly after "echo mem >/sys/power/state".
> 
> I copy all stuff need into tmpfs to ensure that it can restore the video
> without hard disk access.

OOhh.. clever, wish I'd thought of that,
as all of my (now solved) suspend/resume issues
were *all* libata related.

> when accessing hard disks first time after resume, I get (wrote it by
> hand so maybe this is not 100% correct)
> 
> ata1: handling error / timeout
> ata1: port reset  p_ is 400000 is 0 pis 400000 cmd 8007
>                           tf 80 ss 113 se 405000
> ata1: status = 0x50 {DriveReady SeekComplete}
> sda: current: senseKey 0x0 ASC  0x0 ASCQ 0x0
> 
> Sometimes there is "cmd 6" instead of "cmd 8007".
> 
> What to do, what to test?

Randy Dunlop's libata-acpi patch might work for you.
http://www.xenotime.net/linux/SATA/

Cheers

Re: Resume problems on Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G -- SATA

[Michael Schierl]

Mark Lord wrote:

>> I copy all stuff need into tmpfs to ensure that it can restore the video
>> without hard disk access.
>
> OOhh.. clever, wish I'd thought of that,

One should not forget to disable swap first :)

> as all of my (now solved) suspend/resume issues
> were *all* libata related.

So I guess it is a good idea to get SATA working first, isn't it?

>> What to do, what to test?
>
> Randy Dunlop's libata-acpi patch might work for you.
> http://www.xenotime.net/linux/SATA/

I tried the 2.6.16-rc4 patches on 2.6.16 (one hunk did not apply in
libata.h, but I think I was able to fix it manually). Before suspend it
works well, after suspend it does not work. Seems that the timeout is
longer with the patch, though. I tried it several times; once it seemed
to have worked, but it was not reproducible (and it did not work any
longer after the next suspend), so I guess it could be just that I only
tried files already in cache. (Or alternatively, the patch has a success
rate of maybe 5%...)

"Just for fun" i tried the 2.6.15 patches on 2.6.15, but it did not even
boot.

BTW: It is an Intel AHCI controller.

Any other ideas/patches?

Michael

Re: Resume problems on Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G -- SATA

[martin schneebacher]

hi!

> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "Michael Schierl" <schierlm@gmx.de>
> To: "Mark Lord" <liml@rtr.ca>
> Subject: Re: Resume problems on Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G -- SATA
> Date: 	Tue, 21 Mar 2006 16:37:03 +0100
> > Randy Dunlop's libata-acpi patch might work for you.
> > http://www.xenotime.net/linux/SATA/
> 
> I tried the 2.6.16-rc4 patches on 2.6.16 (one hunk did not apply in
> libata.h, but I think I was able to fix it manually). Before suspend it
> works well, after suspend it does not work. Seems that the timeout is
> longer with the patch, though. I tried it several times; once it seemed
> to have worked, but it was not reproducible (and it did not work any
> longer after the next suspend), so I guess it could be just that I only
> tried files already in cache. (Or alternatively, the patch has a success
> rate of maybe 5%...)
> 
> "Just for fun" i tried the 2.6.15 patches on 2.6.15, but it did not even
> boot.
> 
> BTW: It is an Intel AHCI controller.
> 
> Any other ideas/patches?

have you ever tried the sata_pm patch from http://tpctl.sourceforge.net/tmp/sata_pm.2.6.15-rc6.patch ?
i have a intel SATA ICH6M interface and it works fine with this patch.

bye...masc.



-- 
_______________________________________________
Surf the Web in a faster, safer and easier way:
Download Opera 8 at http://www.opera.com

Powered by Outblaze

Re: Resume problems on Fujitsu-Siemens AMILO M7440G -- SATA

[Michael Schierl]

martin schneebacher schrieb:

> have you ever tried the sata_pm patch from http://tpctl.sourceforge.net/tmp/sata_pm.2.6.15-rc6.patch ?
> i have a intel SATA ICH6M interface and it works fine with this patch.

Tried it against vanilla 2.6.15 - no change.

Michael