BenQ S73U - no ACPI

BenQ S73U - no ACPI

[Jan Willies]

Hello,

I got a BenQ S73U and it doesn't support ACPI very well. I got 23 
warnings when compiling /proc/acpi/dsdt with the iasl-compiler, but no 
errors. This is confusing, it should work well cause they are only 
warnings, not errors!
Anyway, Sebastian Lammermann managed to turn all warnings down by 
rewriting the DSDT, but one. Unfortunately the behavior didn't change, 
shutdown is still not working.

The last unsolved warning:

dsdt.dsl  1164:             Method (_OSC, 5, NotSerialized)
Warning  1075 -                        ^ Reserved method has too many 
arguments (_OSC requires 4)

If anyone please have a look at the DSDT, it would be very kind! I'm 
really desperate to get this thing working under Linux.

original: http://openwrt.loswillios.de/dsdt.dsl
modified: http://www.hft-leipzig.de/~s03114/dsdt.dsl


I mailed BenQ about this problem, they even replied which surprised me a 
bit. They promised to pass the mail to their developers, but I don't 
think it will change something... I reckon I'm not the first one who 
mailed them about that.



regards
Jan Willies

PS. If you want a nice office-laptop, apart from the ACPI-stuff, the 
S73U is a good deal for 599€ ;-)
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-acpi" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html

Re: BenQ S73U - no ACPI

[Luming Yu]

On 5/9/07, Jan Willies <jan@willies.info> wrote:
> Hello,
>
> I got a BenQ S73U and it doesn't support ACPI very well. I got 23

please describe the problem in detail.

> warnings when compiling /proc/acpi/dsdt with the iasl-compiler, but no
> errors. This is confusing, it should work well cause they are only
> warnings, not errors!

compile-time working doesn't mean run-time working.

> Anyway, Sebastian Lammermann managed to turn all warnings down by
> rewriting the DSDT, but one. Unfortunately the behavior didn't change,
> shutdown is still not working.
>
> The last unsolved warning:
>
> dsdt.dsl  1164:             Method (_OSC, 5, NotSerialized)
> Warning  1075 -                        ^ Reserved method has too many
> arguments (_OSC requires 4)
>
> If anyone please have a look at the DSDT, it would be very kind! I'm
> really desperate to get this thing working under Linux.
>
> original: http://openwrt.loswillios.de/dsdt.dsl
> modified: http://www.hft-leipzig.de/~s03114/dsdt.dsl

please in details...

>
>
> I mailed BenQ about this problem, they even replied which surprised me a
> bit. They promised to pass the mail to their developers, but I don't
> think it will change something... I reckon I'm not the first one who
> mailed them about that.

That's interesting.. BenQ begins to care about linux?

Re: BenQ S73U - no ACPI

[Jan Willies]

Luming Yu wrote:
> On 5/9/07, Jan Willies <jan@willies.info> wrote:
>> I got a BenQ S73U and it doesn't support ACPI very well. I got 23
> please describe the problem in detail.
What information are useful? I have put some log-files here:

    http://web746.webbox240.server-home.org/acpi/acpid
    http://web746.webbox240.server-home.org/acpi/acpi.log

There simply is no S{1,2,3,4,5} with this laptop. It won't even 
power-off itself after halt.
>> errors. This is confusing, it should work well cause they are only
>> warnings, not errors!
> warnings when compiling /proc/acpi/dsdt with the iasl-compiler, but no
>
> compile-time working doesn't mean run-time working.
I discovered that, sadly.


- jcw

Re: BenQ S73U - no ACPI

[Luming Yu]

please enter a bug on bugzilla.kernel.org in ACPI category

On 5/11/07, Jan Willies <jan@willies.info> wrote:
> Luming Yu wrote:
> > On 5/9/07, Jan Willies <jan@willies.info> wrote:
> >> I got a BenQ S73U and it doesn't support ACPI very well. I got 23
> > please describe the problem in detail.
> What information are useful? I have put some log-files here:
>
>     http://web746.webbox240.server-home.org/acpi/acpid
>     http://web746.webbox240.server-home.org/acpi/acpi.log
>
> There simply is no S{1,2,3,4,5} with this laptop. It won't even
> power-off itself after halt.
> >> errors. This is confusing, it should work well cause they are only
> >> warnings, not errors!
> > warnings when compiling /proc/acpi/dsdt with the iasl-compiler, but no
> >
> > compile-time working doesn't mean run-time working.
> I discovered that, sadly.
>
>
> - jcw
>
>