From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 From: Luca Capello Subject: Re: Oops removing thinkpad_acpi and video on git:linux-acpi-2.6 Date: Sun, 21 Oct 2007 19:45:52 +0200 Message-ID: <87myuccqen.fsf@gismo.pca.it> References: <87lka1ffwc.fsf@gismo.pca.it> <20071018012106.GA24821@khazad-dum.debian.net> <87tzoo2q3x.fsf@gismo.pca.it> <20071018230334.GD4483@khazad-dum.debian.net> <871wbr2u1r.fsf@gismo.pca.it> <20071020002720.GA21173@khazad-dum.debian.net> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="Boundary_(ID_gjCpAhmOb1X+jgGTG8FDIg)" Return-path: Received: from mbox.unige.ch ([129.194.9.209]:49954 "EHLO mbox.unige.ch" rhost-flags-OK-OK-OK-OK) by vger.kernel.org with ESMTP id S1751534AbXJURp6 (ORCPT ); Sun, 21 Oct 2007 13:45:58 -0400 Received: from gismo.pca.it (233-71.203-62.cust.bluewin.ch [62.203.71.233]) by mbox.unige.ch (Sun Java(tm) System Messaging Server 6.3-1.04 (built May 9 2007; 32bit)) with ESMTPSA id <0JQ900G9DW0J2D00@mbox.unige.ch> for linux-acpi@vger.kernel.org; Sun, 21 Oct 2007 19:45:56 +0200 (CEST) In-reply-to: <20071020002720.GA21173@khazad-dum.debian.net> Sender: linux-acpi-owner@vger.kernel.org List-Id: linux-acpi@vger.kernel.org To: ML Linux-ACPI --Boundary_(ID_gjCpAhmOb1X+jgGTG8FDIg) Content-type: TEXT/PLAIN; CHARSET=us-ascii Content-transfer-encoding: 7BIT Hi Henrique! On Sat, 20 Oct 2007 02:27:20 +0200, Henrique de Moraes Holschuh wrote: > On Fri, 19 Oct 2007, Luca Capello wrote: >> On Fri, 19 Oct 2007 01:03:34 +0200, Henrique de Moraes Holschuh wrote: >>> Hmm, I will see if I can reproduce it. >> >> Thank you. > > Unfortunately, I can't reproduce it. [...] > Please compile thinkpad-acpi and ACPI with the debug modes enabled, > and load thinkpad-acpi with the debug=0xffff parameter. Then > reproduce the oops, and send me the entire kernel output since > driver load until the oops. Done (and dmesg attached). Disabling CONFIG_THINKPAD_ACPI_HOTKEY_POLL doesn't change anything (and the dmesg attached is with that option enabled). BTW, I needed to play a bit with module loading/unloading, since the first time I removed the thinkpad_acpi module the oops wasn't triggered. Please let me know if you want my .config as well. > You could also try turning on some of the ACPI debug bits, one of > them (sorry, I don't know which) will tell you exactly which > device's notify handler it is calling. Well, I think I've all the ACPI debug options already on, since CONFIG_ACPI_DEBUG=y and CONFIG_ACPI_DEBUG_FUNC_TRACE=y, as well as CONFIG_PM_DEBUG=y (and CONFIG_THINKPAD_ACPI_DEBUG=y, obviously). Thx, bye, Gismo / Luca --Boundary_(ID_gjCpAhmOb1X+jgGTG8FDIg) Content-type: application/octet-stream; NAME=dmesg-2.6.23.1_thinkpad-acpi-0.18-oops_gismo-20071021.log.gz Content-transfer-encoding: base64 Content-disposition: attachment; filename=dmesg-2.6.23.1_thinkpad-acpi-0.18-oops_gismo-20071021.log.gz Content-description: 2.6.23.1 kernel and thinkpad_acpi-0.18 oops H4sICP4wGkcAA2RtZXNnLmxvZwDtWm1v2zgS/u5fQeC+dHGJI8mv8S0WaJx0N9i0azjtbg+9QqBJ OtZZErUkZSf362+Gki1bkh07cW9R4ALEL8NnhjPD4XA48uj9gLzlPIgfSBBPJZlKRT5IcpXqAWVJ 4C8CLqTTGO2GBXGSmn7Dvg3I74hHOqGaXLCQan1hhy5y3B5JYiFi0228HY5uV4KuxSJggnz5/fb6 K3kTpaEJzmeC8gF5EpoQJaMBiSUhidQGP/2wT35hkPusQZcHGnT5rEG9XQa5B1pkZkE8Tyj3Uf8B 4WphP/kzGvNQ+EEcANCoJ9TASBJKRo0gOCnJIFYlwQ4T9E6mMd/i/pd/f9UcDW+d5t1o2LwZHiXu AL0UP0xUHSc4yMAXUPlk6izVS9VZqg116sIiCamB92iwNcGB0NkyknFZtWAS5eokSk5QAjJzFSxE xYyP+HVE88W9eTQKInrhNN3+uec4PddxW2WWmTHJ4OICZjlHQlNPm7EwFzslX93+dk96Vzcfr50/ /iBvvKbrkh/OCMRM7+qXj20gnrvN6jR3IpYLWYj53HV2G5oZB57ShoahqCx8vUtm0szFU8U+S83h +BrQMPgP8mQjRKeTeme+MLxmNUocug9/+fXmnzuFbFmSfYGMpQRYkCRSmaqfajhIRPX8BWxapgqS GnIT59HJ/84gh4WhXQAl/iRuZU0V5YEkehkYNst2zT8yWqYCDzSd1CzwlgapxgnyAOJiSiGhIoJk 5iR7mUUME+SrbRmsp4GwlysUD5Q9rXmUQEehFIlxCUHHpjoTXdVdiYdAG6F8k9glX8dXMbQRfbA/ aZzFQH0UamHSJAseyDzB9MmSrDJpkjFm9D17oNgv+axH7qxJmAojpZmV4euBuv21Hvx+tljZnsKE QBf75YyA9wyUC7AROrs9uMF8nLtt/VKGWmKdm+3AyV0MUl9fTEAFdJywQ9TyXnZ2I+fuUmLTu5lD txc8klyQyqFWLF/Oc9w6h8HDzJShlli3znbg5OsMyk5e5lDkPHltFtZ45EB10DunVodFUr94G3wa vr/fKWVzmbOV3Qy43fGTY48LtDoFkFYXZkgnTEYRWKFPHm7fzqEb9mybsLfUKfxlmY7dwFUgkOq8 endz/S227ktdieo8awCC6r34fD4EKUcXGUJUSjmk1ZYWQD+5P+sUONShVzc3o0OssIofttMz6HE+ NDOhIhqWwTm5zpP50G5nbvOu4DWnY3u3imuuIyNCYbKLha5s9mKkNjrWo7vNAkViTlW+ihPK5qvM CvX5lMJVhy5oEGKFf2aPlVBSe32PqQF5RMai2WweWM/JMI3EnuLBjh/rnSmttAqAVOcPIJ98s4DM AxN5HefJD+qHGm8cpg5ynlwd/WJ19F51igVGWHUTauKdkUqBvM3FZGyUDMlUwB1GAcvqEk4mTySh ikbCVMOkiEE78zpUn2uyus6qy7pu/di2FCCMkfGOlqu7tx1te679xoyG/JxyLmPbufrSaju9r3g7 fshaBNQQp/RHVJBYoke58NrTdq8jJkTpjNibTqf9rtfu8I5DhFIwYyWppfE8lsuY3N1enysRwuLz 7EpplRrAlbDjVNsg/+f6q7gwbsUjxq0SkVzk6XA3CgZzqPCxz+ODbFXpE+COyvCMxkxkLTAaw/4R MV+l3CU1bMYl5Alsue2ZEvaVnoE1h2m4Ru0+VjJgNn6ANftUeW6SNXBH6VEgc8Ar9Xl2mjWyrhIr YDj6SlX2T7CG7TjQMxQMvlKLveLXqLobUwHD0VeqsX+CQtu6lseGO3D4tQ7ZP0UR2XVdto3dg8MH qJJ1jlaytZG2uwuvD0EMJW/WGKKpkXkTHI/pozbgfjWLaNzVo92I+RXktYH//FRr7O6GdAbMxgfE Vka5Vlk/O6+TaiuRbd4jjNmabpJqP43X/fr6+jh/LrBzgYsHEXp+jBOfc8waWK9WASweLrxiSXfd /Ta++hC5KdStJRHriwXBASggzQwvRli+jVfSdxRwezGbdWAVtOvZ6aFoNGj//PECKuF9VWgG+ADV J5yRcCmEAj4CYepp9fhy4Ta9/9Ez4nVt/T0+933hM8IT3eCfvcC4L7rA7P35SR7/310x/U25TpQx 3L84Y3yyT4WxN5Df6udCxSIkHz7d3ZFE2ugkXCgxhf8Yo7Tmmjq+HQ1Ig3z5sTzy01fiw2H1aP7u PPamfNoD2oXz6NLG6Odr0rvs0bbT7ZHRJ/jSoy63X95fE4c0fpMJFHkOuJp8cb+S+/cj0hiOPhGX NN7bzK6hdIrntnG7fqB16XYgnUVETbETTEKP0WTjwSaXbG4bCjSI8QcbyaKbHa0sSe0vAvJ3HzBa qEW281ZEGXOB3eU1IZFLoTTdgKTApRPczCsKPnrV9ucGvrGengKGpHbx4VRSYgn/vp4kHmx4mZCE RSygJAmCR6JjWHVOfVyEkDwI0DlgBCwF/SDTTKiBxXkigTLmydeBsgwgwJfYSoTPUfAIhQJ+W88k Zywovlk5lBFg9rlYkCcIW+prcJMwRGnFoLjB3omBeTPNMhbNUQyD8cCkPiSxZNm6bHdWCpAoYhlQ pgYNpSB1pT9iTBCB/yc2JZHg4/A3f8lBigfy+o4LFnFKAiFE3/Egb68/+Uw9JRnOSkcFGAuMIQL0 8WeMo2nRkqJpmOMIrEcgfUWXRLgYqaiI9W2iI2lXYsUIatlcHPr0IcHfj8Q8MxVNog/Cp2EoGTEa /SQW9vXRtMi/J5xEE0bZDLAz6nUgpCA22YRB4M1ZkMxwA0W56vAhCmyrBj7pmCYaCzKkSlCB27dV +xlLI6F11oMkFD0eBrDolGimbX3TGAVwH+s4Z/bBx4DMbTDnv6/4AIIx0DF/ec1u02udu+c04t02 +ZvbsFsWd9egdtcetZfH95ms/mCKLSlwdI/3qSv6fUJu3t29/fkeh2Eur+81xm8/QzlW4Dod7kEG udqgdt12j3cFUIeb2MvWxHH6TmN8/XlQk4Pub8vUPlCvbwsJjut6lwxy9/hqlFHtiNPyOi0KWKdf J9e53NbX6bf7jTE4rox1ydh1t7CQ0VogwfW2qP0uZyihVeiw+gNse1OzDkCnKKFT1azxDtxaob7B lx8IuHzD6g5j7dXIPA5hsCJsmAmDbHt9ny0muVl9GI43jO07TsdxWpPGcOzVuGs4bhXUHu91Wxm1 XcLC8jaux1Unwvxjt5ZaMxtIaNViuwUV3QAvSO2VsG2QMMo22fbWeZOs9pWZKYFlGB6dG+uK3Ge2 UVYKDfBw495AcQfe3AwwxiAYNyOZQqFbCkHWKkeJ09iAeO325ZRVIJXIKhF4f1tIp926rLqsbMUW S9/ttxpDyH/ko4KzbYAnfdk4yA7Wg2Kxug9DIZxgSxHSRacHiQIq6RIfmrzikxpuaoKlZnWfBjav BWwe22bL3ABsKo39pVTzP1ORCsxJHLORU4GjwQBHKP7KzS4owIUL8KlTRqOtqFMKF+fshrqkc+FP 05iZQMbAiEnPE5VZWp1+zSxO/SROhwN4voa10UG9bgnnMMZRKJsFIfdVkACSopFeCejBC65A/mvD WpUrGsNB291SwtmhAxMlHZxMh0ZjKLmAQL+CSwacJ2RBodJq4tFy3PkBuXtEftzcX3h2/FSfYRr/ BZNrNsggMAAA --Boundary_(ID_gjCpAhmOb1X+jgGTG8FDIg)--