[PATCH v3 3/6] dmaengine: pxa: add pxa dmaengine driver

[robert.jarzmik@free.fr (Robert Jarzmik)]

Vinod Koul <vinod.koul@intel.com> writes:

>> +#define DCSR_RUN	BIT(31)	/* Run Bit (read / write) */
>> +#define DCSR_NODESC	BIT(30)	/* No-Descriptor Fetch (read / write) */
>> +#define DCSR_STOPIRQEN	BIT(29)	/* Stop Interrupt Enable (read / write) */
>> +#define DCSR_REQPEND	BIT(8)	/* Request Pending (read-only) */
>> +#define DCSR_STOPSTATE	BIT(3)	/* Stop State (read-only) */
>> +#define DCSR_ENDINTR	BIT(2)	/* End Interrupt (read / write) */
>> +#define DCSR_STARTINTR	BIT(1)	/* Start Interrupt (read / write) */
>> +#define DCSR_BUSERR	BIT(0)	/* Bus Error Interrupt (read / write) */
>> +
>> +#define DCSR_EORIRQEN	BIT(28)	/* End of Receive Interrupt Enable (R/W) */
>> +#define DCSR_EORJMPEN	BIT(27)	/* Jump to next descriptor on EOR */
>> +#define DCSR_EORSTOPEN	BIT(26)	/* STOP on an EOR */
>> +#define DCSR_SETCMPST	BIT(25)	/* Set Descriptor Compare Status */
>> +#define DCSR_CLRCMPST	BIT(24)	/* Clear Descriptor Compare Status */
>> +#define DCSR_CMPST	BIT(10)	/* The Descriptor Compare Status */
>> +#define DCSR_EORINTR	BIT(9)	/* The end of Receive */
> would help if these are PXA_xxx
OK, for v4.

>> +
>> +/*
>> + * Requestor lines are mapped as :
>> + *  - lines 0 to 63   : DRCMR(line) = 0x100 + line * 4
>> + *  - lines 64 to +oo : DRCMR(line) = 0x1000 + line * 4
>> + */
>> +#define DRCMR(n)	((((n) < 64) ? 0x0100 : 0x1100) + (((n) & 0x3f) << 2))
> This is hard to read, why not make this a function?
Yes, why not. For v4.

>> +static int pxad_alloc_chan_resources(struct dma_chan *dchan)
>> +{
>> +	struct pxad_chan *chan = to_pxad_chan(dchan);
>> +	struct pxad_device *pdev = to_pxad_dev(chan->vc.chan.device);
>> +
>> +	if (chan->desc_pool)
>> +		return 1;
>> +
>> +	chan->desc_pool = dma_pool_create(dma_chan_name(dchan),
>> +					  pdev->slave.dev,
>> +					  sizeof(struct pxad_desc_hw),
>> +					  __alignof__(struct pxad_desc_hw),
> why __alignof__ and why not simple say sizeof(struct pxad_desc_hw) to align
> the pool for this struct.
Because it's not the size of the struct which makes its alignement requirement,
but it's declared alignement (see pxad_desc_hw declaration, especially the
__aligned((16)) part). Would the requirement have been of 32 bytes for the same
structure size (because of a IP hardware designer whim), I would only need to
modify the pxad_desc_hw structure declaration.

> Also you have given the descriptor size here for pool size, which sounds odd
> and ideally you would like to request a large pool for channel for allocating
> multiple desc
Euh how so ? dma_pool_create() takes as its third argument the size of one
unitary block, ie. one pxad_desc_hw, which is of sizeof(struct pxad_desc_hw) bytes.
You probably know that dma_pool_create() allocates per pages, ie. multiple
pxad_desc_hw will be allocated at once.

>> +static struct pxad_desc_sw *
>> +pxad_alloc_desc(struct pxad_chan *chan, unsigned int nb_hw_desc)
>> +{
>> +	struct pxad_desc_sw *sw_desc;
>> +	dma_addr_t dma;
>> +	int i;
>> +
>> +	sw_desc = kzalloc(sizeof(*sw_desc) +
>> +			  nb_hw_desc * sizeof(struct pxad_desc_hw *),
>> +			  GFP_ATOMIC);
> GFP_NOWAIT
Ok.

>> +	if (!sw_desc)
>> +		return NULL;
>> +	sw_desc->desc_pool = chan->desc_pool;
>> +
>> +	for (i = 0; i < nb_hw_desc; i++) {
>> +		sw_desc->hw_desc[i] = dma_pool_alloc(sw_desc->desc_pool,
>> +						     GFP_ATOMIC, &dma);
> GFP_NOWAIT
Ok.

-- 
Robert