know mount location with in FS

know mount location with in FS

[Anand Jain]

Hello,

I wonder if there is any known way to get the mount point directory name 
with in the btrfs-kernel ?

Thanks, Anand

Re: know mount location with in FS

[Eric Sandeen]

On 2/16/14, 9:02 AM, Anand Jain wrote:
> 
> Hello,
> 
> I wonder if there is any known way to get the mount point directory name with in the btrfs-kernel ?

For what reason?

Remember that a single block device can be mounted in multiple places (or bind-mounted, etc), so there is not even necessarily a single answer to that question.

-Eric

Re: know mount location with in FS

[Anand Jain]

> For what reason?
>
> Remember that a single block device can be mounted in multiple places
 > (or bind-mounted, etc), so there is not even necessarily a single
 > answer to that question.
>
> -Eric

  Yes indeed. (the attempt is should we be able to maintain all
  the mount points as a list saved/updated under per fs_devices. ?)

  some of the exported symbols at fs/namei.c looks closely
  related to the purpose here, but it didn't help unless
  I missed something.

  any comment is helpful..

  The reason:
     First of all btrfs-progs has used "scan-all-disks" very
     liberally which isn't a scalable design (imagine a data
     center with 1000's of LUN).
     Even a simple check_mounted() does scan-all-disks (when
     total_disk >1), that isn't necessary if the kernel could
     let it know.
     Scan for btrfs has expensive steps of reading each super-block,
     and the effect is, in general most of the btrfs-progs commands
     are very very slow when things like scrub is running.
     check_mounted() fails when seeding is used (since
     /proc/self/mounts would show disk with lowest devid and in
     most common scenario it will be a seed disk. (which has
     different FSID from the actual disk in question). and
     Further most severe problem is some btrfs-progs threads has been
     scan-all-disks more than once during the thread's life time.
     So a total revamp of this design has become an immediate need.

     What I am planning is
        - btrfs-progs to init btrfs-disk-list once per required thread
          (mostly use BTRFS_IOC_GET_DEVS, which would dump anything
          and everything about the btrfs devices)
        - the btrfs-disk-list is obtained from kernel first, and will
          fill with the remaining disks which kernel isn't aware of.
        - If the step one also provides the mount point(s) from the
          kernel that would complete the loop with what end user
          would want to know.


Thanks, Anand

Re: know mount location with in FS

[Goswin von Brederlow]

On Tue, Feb 18, 2014 at 11:06:38AM +0800, Anand Jain wrote:
> 
> >For what reason?
> >
> >Remember that a single block device can be mounted in multiple places
> > (or bind-mounted, etc), so there is not even necessarily a single
> > answer to that question.
> >
> >-Eric
> 
>  Yes indeed. (the attempt is should we be able to maintain all
>  the mount points as a list saved/updated under per fs_devices. ?)
> 
>  some of the exported symbols at fs/namei.c looks closely
>  related to the purpose here, but it didn't help unless
>  I missed something.
> 
>  any comment is helpful..
> 
>  The reason:
>     First of all btrfs-progs has used "scan-all-disks" very
>     liberally which isn't a scalable design (imagine a data
>     center with 1000's of LUN).
>     Even a simple check_mounted() does scan-all-disks (when
>     total_disk >1), that isn't necessary if the kernel could
>     let it know.
>     Scan for btrfs has expensive steps of reading each super-block,
>     and the effect is, in general most of the btrfs-progs commands
>     are very very slow when things like scrub is running.
>     check_mounted() fails when seeding is used (since
>     /proc/self/mounts would show disk with lowest devid and in
>     most common scenario it will be a seed disk. (which has
>     different FSID from the actual disk in question). and
>     Further most severe problem is some btrfs-progs threads has been
>     scan-all-disks more than once during the thread's life time.
>     So a total revamp of this design has become an immediate need.
> 
>     What I am planning is
>        - btrfs-progs to init btrfs-disk-list once per required thread
>          (mostly use BTRFS_IOC_GET_DEVS, which would dump anything
>          and everything about the btrfs devices)
>        - the btrfs-disk-list is obtained from kernel first, and will
>          fill with the remaining disks which kernel isn't aware of.
>        - If the step one also provides the mount point(s) from the
>          kernel that would complete the loop with what end user
>          would want to know.
> 
> 
> Thanks, Anand

What about mountpoints outside the current filesystem namespace or
ones that should be shortened to the filesystem namespace (e.g. in a
chroot the leading dirs need to be cut)?

MfG
	Goswin