Re: [PATCH v2 1/8] sh-pfc: Add OF support

[Laurent Pinchart <laurent.pinchart-ryLnwIuWjnjg/C1BVhZhaw@public.gmane.org>]

Hi Simon,

On Monday 21 January 2013 09:38:28 Simon Horman wrote:
> On Tue, Jan 15, 2013 at 10:10:19AM +0900, Simon Horman wrote:
> > On Sat, Jan 12, 2013 at 06:18:54PM +0100, Guennadi Liakhovetski wrote:
> > > On Wed, 9 Jan 2013, Laurent Pinchart wrote:
> > > > Support device instantiation through the device tree. The compatible
> > > > property is used to select the SoC pinmux information.
> > > > 
> > > > Set the gpio_chip device field to the PFC device to enable automatic
> > > > GPIO OF support.
> > > > 
> > > > Signed-off-by: Laurent Pinchart
> > > > <laurent.pinchart+renesas-ryLnwIuWjnjg/C1BVhZhaw@public.gmane.org>
> > > > Cc: devicetree-discuss-uLR06cmDAlY/bJ5BZ2RsiQ@public.gmane.org
> > > 
> > > This whole pinctrl mega-series is a very welcome improvement to the
> > > sh-/r-mobile GPIO framework, and is very well done IMHO! But,
> > > unfortunately, as discussed with you privately yesterday, there is still
> > > a problem with pinctrl DT support on sh73a0, which will, probably,
> > > enforce an update to one or several of patches from this lot. To explain
> > > to other readers, on sh73a0 pin numbers are not contiguous, they are
> > > sparse. When pins are referred to from C code, macro names are used,
> > > which are then correctly decoded to respective positions in pin
> > > descriptor tables. Whereas with DT, pins are referred to from .dts files
> > > using their physical numbers, which then refer to either wrong or
> > > missing entries in those tables.
> > > 
> > > I do not know where this problem should be solved best - either in
> > > descriptor tables, or in DT handling code, so, I don't know which
> > > patches would be affected. Don't think you'll want to keep the one-to-
> > > one index-to-pin mapping by also making pin-descriptor arrays sparse,
> > > so, so far I only see one possibility to fix this - by using the
> > > .enum_id field from struct sh_pfc_pin instead of just the index - both
> > > in  C and in DT case, and those .enum_id values will have to provide
> > > physical pin numbers instead of plane indices. That way you'd have to
> > > update at least drivers/pinctrl/sh-pfc/pfc-sh73a0.c and the
> > > sh_pfc_map_gpios() function in drivers/pinctrl/sh-pfc/pinctrl.c.
> > > 
> > > Anyway, I'm sure you'll find a suitable solution of this problem and for
> > > now I'll let Simon decide which patches he wants to apply and which ones
> > > he'd prefer to hold back;-)
> > 
> > Actually, I'd appreciate some guidance from Laurent on this.
> > It seems that the problems you raise go quite far back into the
> > mega-series.
> > 
> > I was intending to send pull requests for the following branches soon.
> > But I am now concerned that at least the sh73a0 patches may need
> > reworking.
> 
> I have concluded that the changes below are safe and have
> proceeded with sending them to arm-soc. However, I am still awaiting
> a response from arm-soc.

Sorry for the late reply. The below changes are indeed safe, what I need to 
rework are the pinctrl API and DT series.

> > pfc2: (based on a merge of sh-soc2 and pfc)
> > sh-pfc: Add shx3 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7786 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7785 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7757 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7734 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7724 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7723 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7722 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7720 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7269 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7264 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7203 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh73a0 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add sh7372 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add r8a7779 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Add r8a7740 pinmux support
> > sh-pfc: Support pinmux info in driver data instead of platform data
> > sh-pfc: Move driver from drivers/sh/ to drivers/pinctrl/
> > sh-pfc: Remove unused resource and num_resources platform data fields
> > sh-pfc: Remove platform device registration
> > 
> > sh-soc2: (based on pfc)
> > sh: shx3: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: sh7786: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: sh7785: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: sh7757: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: sh7734: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: sh7724: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: sh7723: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: sh7722: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: sh7720: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: sh7269: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: sh7264: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: sh7203: Register PFC platform device
> > sh: Add PFC platform device registration helper function
> > 
> > 
> > soc: (based on sh-soc)
> > ARM: shmobile: sh73a0: Add pin control resources
> > ARM: shmobile: sh7372: Add pin control resources
> > ARM: shmobile: r8a7740: Add pin control resources
> > ARM: shmobile: sh73a0: Register PFC platform device
> > ARM: shmobile: sh7372: Register PFC platform device
> > ARM: shmobile: r8a7779: Register PFC platform device
> > ARM: shmobile: r8a7740: Register PFC platform device
> > ARM: shmobile: Select PINCTRL
> > ARM: shmobile: add function declarations for sh7372 DT helper functions
> > ARM: sh7372: fix cache clean / invalidate order
> > ARM: sh7372: add clock lookup entries for DT-based devices
> > ARM: mach-shmobile: sh73a0 external IRQ wake update
> > ARM: shmobile: sh73a0: fixup div4_clks bitmap
> > ARM: shmobile: r8a7740: add TMU timer support
> > ARM: shmobile: Remove duplicate inclusion of dma-mapping.h in
> > setup-r8a7740.c
> > 
> > pfc: (based on sh-soc)
> > sh-pfc: Support passing resources through platform device
> > sh-pfc: Split platform device and platform driver registration
> > sh-pfc: Use sh_pfc_ namespace prefix through the whole driver
> > sh-pfc: Sort headers alphabetically
> > sh-pfc: Remove check for impossible error condition
> > sh-pfc: Let the compiler decide whether to inline functions
> > sh-pfc: Use devm_ioremap_nocache()
> > sh-pfc: Use devm_kzalloc()
> > sh-pfc: Move platform device and driver to the core
> > sh-pfc: Merge PFC core and gpio
> > sh-pfc: Merge PFC core and pinctrl
> > sh-pfc: Move private definitions and declarations to private header
> > sh-pfc: Split platform data from the sh_pfc structure
> > sh-pfc: Remove all use of __devinit/__devexit
> > 
> > sh-soc:
> > sh: shx3: Fix last GPIO index
> > sh: sh7786: Fix last GPIO index
> > sh: sh7786: Fix port E, G and J GPIOs
> > sh: sh7757: Fix GPIO_FN_ET0_MDIO and GPIO_FN_ET1_MDIO GPIO entries
> > sh: sh7723: Rename GPIO_FN_SIUOSPD to GPIO_FN_SIUAOSPD
> > sh: sh7269: Rename CRX0CRX1(CRX2) marks to match GPIO names
> > sh: sh7264: Rename CRX0CRX1 mark to match GPIO names

-- 
Regards,

Laurent Pinchart