From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from mout.web.de (mout.web.de [212.227.15.14]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 8532B233949; Tue, 19 May 2026 12:32:28 +0000 (UTC) Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.14 ARC-Seal:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1779193950; cv=none; b=j8gThWwP9hG8aM5gESJfF+Cc+61s9W76yiuOontYd/wnG1/0FBwOtJMxiOLcc0z1xZGmd7hdZH6DJymlRXxEAOULRHgkMlm8NNYC/6HRFjU0dKv8Mzei9VgnKLvYmL0oHOZUNhLlnz82/CRrFhYE0iecWrt/DN83TBp9mpi+lOw= ARC-Message-Signature:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1779193950; c=relaxed/simple; bh=a3i+o0McdYohTrVqOh3i5ioTr30WGEXz7x2q0R/6iQE=; h=Message-ID:Date:MIME-Version:Subject:To:Cc:References:From: In-Reply-To:Content-Type; b=MjmkZQBAksRl7rqvK8NdGPmBr8iLTziGHdcvTUNMm4VqR/n3UKeZ++/rWRidLS1UQIW9ou/4xCOK9rKRv0AHg2LAgGV5YEXVRoo2ZiwxPGpoxulVGDrYDAIbHJxnvKQ6//oRde82W6lMhswQnbGQbkCQK/BNj2q72PTbHytdtWo= ARC-Authentication-Results:i=1; smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=web.de; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=web.de; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=web.de header.i=markus.elfring@web.de header.b=bD4LrUFU; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.14 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=web.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=web.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=web.de header.i=markus.elfring@web.de header.b="bD4LrUFU" DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=web.de; s=s29768273; t=1779193935; x=1779798735; i=markus.elfring@web.de; bh=a3i+o0McdYohTrVqOh3i5ioTr30WGEXz7x2q0R/6iQE=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Message-ID:Date:MIME-Version:Subject:To:Cc: References:From:In-Reply-To:Content-Type: Content-Transfer-Encoding:cc:content-transfer-encoding: content-type:date:from:message-id:mime-version:reply-to:subject: to; b=bD4LrUFUa99UynQkR+0Haqdgw0dWp3RyKBUH8A/LzhDoAUbsOc0oiwArzrbVbhah 7OBGANqlIn6A0KGyV8mrfvU7c+dSaCpFjCIfumRmndbP0A4TNlg8rbZZWaCEQBLjx VlbX9r2+JkHZbLYXNCe2JG4DZbOCbYkUA1yqxwpCwZJWjoXWgg2TKid5sBs3yD9Bp KKbJvHzSy/Omsw2bJUsBq0wBRvwZG4hipgRxmYRJJH4dknj4rtWzdnL7J+VsXzkLo NaO+L+IvZfx+0lqG48vC8FDSCacJqYh4i9KNMzBeVjVKNImsmrR8jrhAAzv9wXdWl nHMJHfqEMikaFW+mqA== X-UI-Sender-Class: 814a7b36-bfc1-4dae-8640-3722d8ec6cd6 Received: from client.hidden.invalid by smtp.web.de (mrweb005 [213.165.67.108]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1MzTLI-1xKZ0Z263E-014uRG; Tue, 19 May 2026 14:32:15 +0200 Message-ID: <056ecc87-c4ba-47cb-9aa2-5e3211da195c@web.de> Date: Tue, 19 May 2026 14:32:11 +0200 Precedence: bulk X-Mailing-List: linux-doc@vger.kernel.org List-Id: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: MIME-Version: 1.0 User-Agent: Mozilla Thunderbird Subject: Re: [PATCH 09/15] accel/qda: Add DMA-backed GEM objects and memory manager integration To: Matthew Wilcox , dri-devel@lists.freedesktop.org, iommu@lists.linux.dev, linux-media@vger.kernel.org, linux-arm-msm@vger.kernel.org, linaro-mm-sig@lists.linaro.org Cc: Ekansh Gupta , =?UTF-8?Q?Christian_K=C3=B6nig?= , David Airlie , =?UTF-8?B?SsO2cmcgUsO2ZGVs?= , Jonathan Corbet , Maarten Lankhorst , Maxime Ripard , Oded Gabbay , Robin Murphy , Shuah Khan , Simona Vetter , Sumit Semwal , Thomas Zimmermann , linux-doc@vger.kernel.org, linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org, Bharath Kumar , Bjorn Andersson , Chenna Kesava Raju , Dmitry Baryshkov , Konrad Dybcio , Rob Clark , Srinivas Kandagatla , Will Deacon References: <20260519-qda-series-v1-9-b2d984c297f8@oss.qualcomm.com> <5e0d72fa-929a-4905-9066-6648892bef4a@web.de> Content-Language: en-GB, de-DE From: Markus Elfring In-Reply-To: Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:ZCsSJd3hlZA0+s6pw9oSu6hy//TO5pI7XEUP2fNCggWZexrtIeC ztmJ2lavQ+zqx4kDCnaiWe2OloINiorh0ir6/HZHLmgzLjBnCWEje6lfH+2omUmIOxImtZ8 oLJlyHHg7CSgf/fhhMzkYHPKesSLEMCEIdiyA3HuaBGm5L1K3/RB4gTtpny+qFIEcIc+nrw qec8gi9RND1ONV1qQOX+w== X-Spam-Flag: NO UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:vJshWSmoSHA=;XWZhCWYeZiiacMBiBDZaL9WPur4 Y8ORxJyfHaR0toT1h0GQpnWElEE1jK4s5zEyego/pC0dN6ad16u56fbHKi8E5eWF285iSXgMf zk1cHz/eDwQ5jcZLMVBfo+Ny+hozPzox4ExqjyDW+73IHnyjdmAoJBS2a7Bvyr4/AI8H+MCfD d8l+0wKmKxIFeQyedsTYyzaV/LORvVERG/q2V2ZQ8d6zJQt+2x6xnZzg5hfZnEV1okR/1c9tB EID81AVb4L9PapF4FZzr6HlLVFHotrRtVR0GLjV2181WwjFjfpO7kvUULzlUjQ1y6XZuenqb2 bfz1ioznTw2v+v316qDzVCln4TeemC3jsmqHoSKqqierlwELfjV4gMzuyELdD0UEtpJuva/kQ bSByUb3rOo4NpB3+CbSYN4cc0Mbc5X/zCRCQ3JPq5V2haxmfgSmZQIWQslOHrf+Qo14Gc5jCa 58i3MlV6ESSkIpnGwiijQxkuYXcRP3FKn78IWybQpPGbHqif3D75vFP2GMmOdhYt87yresHCN +1MU1Otp1t62//LcRjbfnybILCeS/Yy1wl4ptsu4kvyaM0qbWixkKHHYFsLXhZOY1aq2H0aqw UicWrdEHOOWmZQDYBA/6v6gy8YSoe1/G1OZXnerEKfyS9z3k3FN9QZFGvG5gDKj/OJkBv7T34 dB2uDe1GphrGVvRv9JX6G4iXGguwScIvFr3CD6piFApGQyeN9iE9zPK8/xj8hlSD3D1erunEY 7O+wZ+ujwmlgfjwb6sOk5RwkHBmXVoatTPm6Do15sPYZPoyLgEXJbksyI86G/+tJNUDnfZE4d HK55i34/VjiHwzT5CbPoELZZR6+5YTlVjaoNJqE77uD9Nj6p+k/VJjAlr+jXasLHcoGNS74YC 06gPph3ESd67O8k6RUtFRQEoisoeW+0nyhVOznQmpiTzGPd0O4ZI+jkkO6zV50BNsTBp69nOS S+TFdXnFxKKMNaQInQJRUSjCsZeHidr9OqWzLmtCd+3C9/SQHzfGbR/WDsNVj/BlBz3ppw5uY 7vAFaqbttG+AutrlWMb7odwHikZouVZ15BuNBzhVGgTG12cpKMOwbdSSzU5nW9dsyK5DStFN2 35Xo3MNVHyyjUDatC9tnNM4Wi1MLP3QxKnou9ILCO7r1N7y/nqlzuWIDuj4qRpXewzGeWjXHB cCFMvc6PipRQBKPsN8QzJ4ikuxIeOsSj34oiR+g2XMsI06z1o0JT9RN6rK2OeFHvMHQ699AnG 54/PYmNVK08Bj4IHEhOkv3qv/9Y7ozPXdCj6MqT8xn+Dmk2fXOjSwcg7E2Y9CW2HC922b1Cys 6wQ8/uB7gB5Ida6Ehe+5dM8fvtnJERoyFt8X0Y6gvn5jZHCKmexuV3e04hIezxe4wX9aipI+K 9HXjpXljSyjXwXnnC2AR3WjpNMhC4omps7gnn2n/NRnbj4nP5G/n541PFl47UuVT5JlWdEn9h J4sIvP8YX2wWdlkhVS7OK1nZOkjn9vtihj4rg381oPfyqwYwQmE8WIuxys4uWunfOf4Wex9GG MCc7acqiL/Vcckej84G6BUhpXlWGHx73qBdAD5+yvvGqt3zewKwtVm2pnqOXuI2RW6Sjo7gwC agXuafp7MsCO2i+xG61k65BSUTMoS6yeIv/toadeWy1wgx0cYGBPUMIBnL2ZYl9kys8qpckYS q/jFAC+YkS1Kf74GAhxiUB5K4fRggqMstEsPt3+l16paLjbZTLJh+Umh4CKG+fAf07p1iwYpf +6nADX7A6LDpKD/7chIXNQk1GQfhC9Zi1g8bBJlqdUX3/nx0SKr92lY2NlsS63ajKw7ZEirGR I1242weND5VRA7VpufvUTiOTGimB0J+tsKjMhJoLbXE1okw7yf5W7w8qJwLeJbnrnDfnyPDun MyQ/OOmuVeajt2juuTYBdu73XSRz3cuqB2bMGSmjFOml3WaB1l+ECYVpvAva0u8KzNs2QDapJ +qAtXcEUE8EkxLn2fAW0kfFMkZj4IORwqjfj8g0OB0ucLR1PfAKYIvR+ScEIj3Yp9wzscnwKU pR6JTW0pzqTbDQ/YQyih6MoK0mwbW9dognlbV+1SfkWi/FvkZd5OZELbtpAXZAqIHh9nS+W6x tJBp0xpt8G7r9blQY562DuVb4Sbj5H0sDafhlfYbZ4IjpyMWPt2KSEDg6fG9q8D5AfrGD1gd0 o9NwEwagEV9OJ3G72++Y0Kq4vSOs2s7/u8XMtf/CXQjEfK8V83k8P+6Tsc8sOJLDLE2JHiHOD tvKzetigT1JjMMnAhO3b1I0i9/xzphxC9q58TfPttvEQUXS6gWFG+PaErhPgROANNXE0kVE3o SHFWB374zOqoW8XutPuKqjYkpQ4D6GGDYYCFt0N6uISVOOx95xfoVfyyMspSHLi7yRZJgGJ48 Ohnz5deX10AiD48GChsPTIN7u3qfEPYnkKbazSZJUwonRHNSf7rTZ/r2RWvoSd7WOUoJkLaiS eHCA1pYXNV8HOiiHPbNFBGIe6I8KAraNZnlHlW6yvT+AFilISngU7ZwjIGoGfb4UBSE4HAo1d B4S2r0fSrIqqMv7YVtLF2S2rgSyCpWn6EBGVy0baPJeho7ARMRpB8HaybDTZ8rIiOQL+rtsTO QblVaAldyG71Id6fqM8DT8SyCR1bVdlLS4Ld+OeVtJ8uqz7Yt/Es9SgJZPI1XoVhcyuiRKix6 gPcT55BknwNH1LSKJlk9PR8KnTdOlaovdMdKTUY+NXARurDFjLADn/alMPBrshK2fzJj/YCX+ yQo71F+qVaA8gmoLEnCsjBIG66otxvALabJNr5LVPbFZazsJLqDMEju4xj0kTfXuU/9i4exss ZzMbqEOF5yWhP5S0Xc9TITyYzEUQM8fWbNeMhwKgwYXM1AM0V7hdFcsj+AEBnsVN8+lVifEqW f+GpFQ6d9fefNarxDDAua3W+ux6EBGdHUUbegofHrYonGuImsfJtPzuaTyHmKCECKFfZZNCoH W0rkeSW7IDi/F2eRpJbjxWMnoNg7gBG1u+avSGkgqRREmgq9cEu/ELctqf1OFSNr2XBrrsGow CxrIxzzE8ZPLVGQpU7QseqKpR+fvDbyz1rSBSBamtl3S9rXgC/Xmll5h/Qc/sUQZBowUAvETM zX8zPLFxVigPAvARGLS5kXirv3nPogQkXD+z9f9xvnAUaB781ORj5/y5BoHYUajsM1K0NM/vh RUr6qJMmj6qkx6gzQ8LZ/rYansT1Rl66JBVcf231HwJLTo22ogrz5u94lie7DF6ddHXpW52Il 5apKAZlHKKWyau0xqMGoXeQt8VfdVHAEiwBFJFV2XVecSU7Wz/5IYLL5CO+Io6XhksnvEvqD8 T6lxq6AEiOCtvnh1s3Fofv8TjMW7sZa99AsypinQTD9pGBp5E53OUxgJ+iGwuT4canFanulGR cDm23wlu+PLp9d4c36lFoGurzn2Ju7bse0UiaP+NBDeQ4hH6dzW1gZo34Su82DCY3Gftv25yN Tvs9jLfzT3cmFIXkEYPCMZ5WXEruzVWQPSR1874R5aPidZ6JAMKeH0szKla5ZV7WbeNnjFNmg XcQhp4swK0DFY5TXmX+m3Z2OktpsgqarqqVGTptaN10H+kO9JayVbcg1GVuw59aCdeZIlmoCJ vbJazMEwg42AcTt9LjeWh0ZPEKVKVErfW9QBTAWWey1U5jC1JrG0el2Of/NeGS7hQ4zXfmAHL /9/f7NusXwUM2gXPC5bEW/LxpFNVbehsyNtsIz04mjOmQwcTum8FveHznXycq6i85a3PTkT+I ICahal3BpieS9MdiTp6xuMgt+C05CL6GC2amLeyXJ0sbfVDVVjqPLDkVOHeEgAynntPOwb2sT zr0pixJHqSJOhFB9jh3GTooszM319nSfPoqGwujhBfOQynpZHRzojjqUh1v4+/qdtRIiRy7S6 6G9hwW5E3SszUMnRCiS8lUGB1i5AZacAjngMLNCO5ZMt/imNpYfTyNMShlUyHz2DLp3B/QlJE 9iPkHeH9s7NaO11EmjGEARCwqzIPUXhrOAlvIA7Ss4L2JNkrM9JrCnTj9RB0qMu9cRM3HC18R prgVFTJIPn3lhVyZBVNgeEkJD5mCp9CzhzVCQk6DZPZVPmzsmcd8xrMNiWoOlg3E+qB1qeX5X Uf9r2V8dvua+RZHjZETNJ2TZpq7dOA/3FTA+lWhdcW2u+nNQMNYmtQpg+Ty0Nb+Dah1zBOmfR GO6pY1BxUN0acBIoTGuWFrknaaqN8PWfAGLgvsg//1z6wf+hhCWocOP5ivxWKuyj6rfuYu/yI 34nlxQ0ZD07q3S5I/OVwWCcYDhxbdU66fxImO+sgb/A2Z4IFuNdjGBDdo0rgJgUEoTNdSvpZs unhHZC2BnrpC5YXwRuwveQwzNuXr4VIdPKaqwl1rS2gNI8f15WIO609rH0MesubT/5DKcr1ON KKxVdMkEBsn/RtkRC7GxbGYZCXDOt17GOyA9+n6TpcmCskuikdN2qdoCbwKqKF93QzxRoZdhG pVHYghgLum7O/K/2J0fkceAEE1QU1/2HFcIoRNXHZw6vBt/WFhHODRL5Pai4LQiehKvQY4bJA dRbQWUAekEBggWCG2aJdRYvP3YJYZZcLTEs/aBwMaZogur/4oj1iIMhiIxfE+hnEhjLr80wDL hHITZ21KRQCZqOvmYKardh7UY2DDWCIHkH5ytntIxAPCS/Z723VBziJku1RnX8R2Xpc0lzKCG PtgseZPhC+7cFyOFjkyeo6uOOANMz7he+RPI1fnunXBRkieymWNn69kOS8NJLEf/Ou6rc0Rmz mBzEieD2Tnn0bCdjVf0WU8LICGnvlscQwUNhM7ZHXOiDfJ6YXz02ZxpPRZBDiNEg3qi4s600H DMRcRomCbvUfAgxMoTjWfii4LGJFy4j3UKw4ZPHz+lu4I3SAe9OdHgI2BXCYczcpFtM9cPE+X m9s6fzWvVfzbdo2GhG47HhT9PchUWvBR+ONwiEsCsNbAtsGGXRea82S/a3m45C2lebMfLFLUM BbxcozZasHaV04qM5u12r4XBzGv3eEqjGQ2xuAbCKRsFSgfaVr40g3Qa8MyeFF/gj2CAV8E9D zGpQ2BXOEBk0/WeiMZrNn2BQJKeF1Tboa3eIchOCyGDeFkjrH7QOvb3wU4auiw3tYL9X3VhDJ 5if4hAQ33hDiWBFhrkVEVFxjx3/b/XnoCo7FDwIQtQqFphtopFvikMtXrSmArHB1fNW2U1DOo r/H8jWGPnHomEi6eMSXL+fO6kuL6TfSALKbNfk7vrp2PnvkrW/cA5NHJYxv8eQZWnwhgeK9wd oMfVlFJjW6saW8WDVrjVbwW6s9Z/Fj7VhESl2uoEH5Az4frL7N7rCgHCRG/1eOdwmgYzfYtXn 3gGIBKDFT2Vl6i5sJ2DnxUr2/OgrjtC+zDa6YdGj7Fi6qKRde+2LVb65TFDYq71Ercm9rz/ap OHt4nBwPgJIepAXxUYsnCwjNdMSqMU3jv+OkPAAzXxQkoaezbzV2VYI1MeXXIL9wVDnEO6M+L 5mos686/3+lhdADOsXrDp6oZM+L0iZM4LFuTTDh2B5HVG3GsIO5L6QL4aUMSj9mI9yFQCXj60 b9UjQg== > Feel free to ignore everything Markus says. Will any contributors care more for linked information sources (in constructive ways)? Regards, Markus