Ext4 devel interlock meeting minutes (October 22, 2007)

Ext4 devel interlock meeting minutes (October 22, 2007)

[Avantika Mathur]

Ext4 Developer Interlock Call
October 22, 2007: Meeting Minutes

Attendees: Mingming Cao, Andreas Dilger, Eric Sandeen, Dave Kleikamp, 
Jose Santos, Aneesh Veetil, Valerie Clement, Avantika Mathur

- There has been discussion on linux-ext4 about overflow in ext2 with 64 
KB block size.  Discussed adding an incompat flag to this feature and 
concluded that it is too late to do this; it will be treated as a bug fix.

Patch Status: patches that were not picked up to mainline in the recent 
pull:
- journal_checksum patches - the fsstress kernel oops is not yet 
resolved, Avantika will be working on this.
- i_version: Jean-Noel recently sent out an updated version which adds a 
lock every time i_version is updated.  Still waiting on more review
- mballoc - target for next kernel release. Remaining work:
    - Aneesh plans to run some performance test and include results in 
	the patch description.
    - Waiting for Alex to address the fixme's that aneesh has added to 
	the code, for more clarification.
- block groupdescriptor sync with e2fsprogs:
- Aneeesh recently posted patches which have been added to the patch queue.

E2fsprogs
- Ted has added new branches the the e2fsprogs git tree
    - master: current stable version
    - next: patches expected to go into the next stable version
    - pu: proposed update; patches that are in preliminary review and 
	test phase
- E2fsprogs patches should probably be submitted against the 'next' 
branch of the git tree.

- Aneesh was looking for patches to support mke2fs of large 
filesystems.  Valerie's old patches don't apply cleanly.

- Documentation in the kernel tree; ext4.txt is out of date and needs to 
be updated.

Performance:
- Andreas had asked Chris Mason to add ext4 to his BTRfs benchmarks. 
Chris Mason reported that ext4 is doing poorly on a test which performs 
kernel untar and compile on 20 kernels in a row.  The performance of 
ext4 on reads is poor compared to ext3.
- Eric will talk to Chris and get all of the details of the tests.
- Eric suggested enabling delalloc,mballoc mount options by default.  
The dellaloc option can then be disabled if the fs is not in writeback 
journaling mode.

Re: Ext4 devel interlock meeting minutes (October 22, 2007)

[Jan Kara]

  Hello,

  Sorry for not taking part in the call but I was just on my way from NY
to Prague...

> Ext4 Developer Interlock Call
> October 22, 2007: Meeting Minutes
> 
> Attendees: Mingming Cao, Andreas Dilger, Eric Sandeen, Dave Kleikamp, 
> Jose Santos, Aneesh Veetil, Valerie Clement, Avantika Mathur
> 
> - There has been discussion on linux-ext4 about overflow in ext2 with 64 
> KB block size.  Discussed adding an incompat flag to this feature and 
> concluded that it is too late to do this; it will be treated as a bug fix.
  Hmm, why adding an incompat flag? Obviously there's no harm in doing
that but the large block size itself should be enough to protect old
kernels/utils touching it, shouldn't it?

> E2fsprogs
> - Ted has added new branches the the e2fsprogs git tree
>    - master: current stable version
>    - next: patches expected to go into the next stable version
>    - pu: proposed update; patches that are in preliminary review and 
> 	test phase
> - E2fsprogs patches should probably be submitted against the 'next' 
> branch of the git tree.
  BTW: We still don't have appropriate patches for large block size in
e2fsprogs. I guess I should ping Ted about merging the patch once more.

								Honza
-- 
Jan Kara <jack@suse.cz>
SuSE CR Labs