Re: EXT4-fs (dm-1): Couldn't remount RDWR because of unprocessed orphan inode list

[Eric Sandeen <sandeen@redhat.com>]

On 9/6/11 11:37 AM, Christian Kujau wrote:
> On Tue, 6 Sep 2011 at 11:17, Eric Sandeen wrote:
>> It's probably not a bug or flaw; orphan inodes can occur for legitimate
>> reasons (fs goes down while someone is holding open an unlinked file),
> 
> The filesystem is being constantly accessed by an application, holding at 
> least one file open (readonly). And then there is this mechanism trying to 
> remount the filesystem rw and then ro again every day. I guess this equals
> the scenario of "fs goes down (remount!) while someone is holding open a 
> file"?

well, no - "goes down" means "crashed or lost power"

>> Did you happen to also get a message like this on the original mount?
>>                 ext4_msg(sb, KERN_ERR, "write access "
>>                         "unavailable, skipping orphan cleanup");
> 
> I think I've seen this message before, but I'm nore sure where and it's 
> not in the logs of this particular system.
> 
>> See also commit: 
>>
>> commit ead6596b9e776ac32d82f7d1931d7638e6d4a7bd
>> Author: Eric Sandeen <sandeen@redhat.com>
>> Date:   Sat Feb 10 01:46:08 2007 -0800
>>
>>     [PATCH] ext4: refuse ro to rw remount of fs with orphan inodes
> 
> Yes, I've seen this commit when I was searching where this message came
> from. And I think I understand now why this is happening, but 
> still...if I may ask: can't this be handled more elegantly? Do other 
> filesystems have the same problem?

well, as the commit said, it'd be nice to handle it in remount, yes... :(

> Right now the procedure is to pause the application, stop the nfs exports,
> unmount, fsck, mount, start nfs exports and resume the application. And
> every few days/weeks this has to be repeated, "just because" these daily
> remounts occur (which are the main reason for this, I suppose).

well, seems like you need to get to the root cause of the unprocessed
orphan inodes.

I don't yet have my post-vacation thinking cap back on... does cycling
rw/ro/rw/ro with open & unlinked files cause an orphan inode situation?

-Eric

> Thanks for replying,
> Christian.