From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from server.interlinx.bc.ca (mail.interlinx.bc.ca [69.165.217.196]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id B7F18224DC for ; Thu, 4 Jan 2024 14:10:15 +0000 (UTC) Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=none (p=none dis=none) header.from=interlinx.bc.ca Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=fail smtp.mailfrom=interlinx.bc.ca Received: from pc.interlinx.bc.ca (pc.interlinx.bc.ca [IPv6:fd31:aeb1:48df:0:3b14:e643:83d8:7017]) (using TLSv1.3 with cipher TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384 (256/256 bits) key-exchange X25519 server-signature RSA-PSS (2048 bits) server-digest SHA256) (No client certificate requested) by server.interlinx.bc.ca (Postfix) with ESMTPSA id 1F6E525A81 for ; Thu, 4 Jan 2024 09:10:14 -0500 (EST) Message-ID: <51aa3ceea05945c9f28e884bc2f43a249ef7e23e.camel@interlinx.bc.ca> Subject: Re: e2scrub finds corruption immediately after mounting From: "Brian J. Murrell" To: linux-ext4@vger.kernel.org Date: Thu, 04 Jan 2024 09:10:13 -0500 In-Reply-To: <20240104043813.GC108362@mit.edu> References: <536d25b24364eaf11a38b47e853008c3115d82b8.camel@interlinx.bc.ca> <20240104043813.GC108362@mit.edu> Autocrypt: addr=brian@interlinx.bc.ca; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata=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 Content-Type: multipart/signed; micalg="pgp-sha256"; protocol="application/pgp-signature"; boundary="=-UMt3Bf3NSJU5CTs9Rs0R" User-Agent: Evolution 3.50.2 (3.50.2-1.fc39) Precedence: bulk X-Mailing-List: linux-ext4@vger.kernel.org List-Id: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: MIME-Version: 1.0 --=-UMt3Bf3NSJU5CTs9Rs0R Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable On Wed, 2024-01-03 at 23:38 -0500, Theodore Ts'o wrote: > What distribution are you using, EL8, specifically AlmaLinux 8.9. > and what version of the kernel are > you using? EL8 is currently shipping 4.18.0-513.9.1.el8_9.x86_64 but as you know at this point in an EL8 kernel's life, the version hardly reflects what's actually in the kernel due to the copious backporting RH do their kernel. > This error means that e2fsck exited with a non-zero exit status. > Which is strange because there is no report of any kind of problem > from e2fsck in its output. Indeed! I even added debug output to e2scrub to print e2fsck's exit value and it's usually 1. > My best guess is that e2fsck from 1.45.6 is somehow returning a > non-zero exit status for some reason.=C2=A0 So the first thing I'd sugges= t > is upgrading to e2fsprogs 1.47.0 and see if that causes the problem > to > resolve itself. Unfortunately, that doesn't seem to be the solution. :-( + umount /opt + e2fsck -y /dev/rootvol_tmp/almalinux8_opt e2fsck 1.47.0 (5-Feb-2023) /dev/rootvol_tmp/almalinux8_opt: clean, 1698/178816 files, 482473/716800 bl= ocks + e2scrub /dev/rootvol_tmp/almalinux8_opt Logical volume "almalinux8_opt.e2scrub" created. e2fsck 1.47.0 (5-Feb-2023) Pass 1: Checking inodes, blocks, and sizes Pass 2: Checking directory structure Pass 3: Checking directory connectivity Pass 4: Checking reference counts Pass 5: Checking group summary information /dev/rootvol_tmp/almalinux8_opt.e2scrub: 1698/178816 files (87.0% non-conti= guous), 482473/716800 blocks /dev/rootvol_tmp/almalinux8_opt: Scrub succeeded. tune2fs 1.47.0 (5-Feb-2023) Setting current mount count to 0 Setting time filesystem last checked to Thu Jan 4 09:07:56 2024 Logical volume "almalinux8_opt.e2scrub" successfully removed. + mount /opt + e2scrub /dev/rootvol_tmp/almalinux8_opt Logical volume "almalinux8_opt.e2scrub" created. e2fsck 1.47.0 (5-Feb-2023) Pass 1: Checking inodes, blocks, and sizes Pass 2: Checking directory structure Pass 3: Checking directory connectivity Pass 4: Checking reference counts Pass 5: Checking group summary information /dev/rootvol_tmp/almalinux8_opt.e2scrub: 1698/178816 files (87.0% non-conti= guous), 482473/716800 blocks /dev/rootvol_tmp/almalinux8_opt: Scrub FAILED due to corruption! Unmount a= nd run e2fsck -y. tune2fs 1.47.0 (5-Feb-2023) Setting filesystem error flag to force fsck. Logical volume "almalinux8_opt.e2scrub" successfully removed. Cheers, b. --=-UMt3Bf3NSJU5CTs9Rs0R Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name="signature.asc" Content-Description: This is a digitally signed message part -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- iQEzBAABCAAdFiEE8B/A+mOVz5cTNBuZ2sHQNBbLyKAFAmWWvEUACgkQ2sHQNBbL yKA1Hwf/WBZ8x/EgeZ69/wm1Kj7p0fpjT+x2h1lz7+fzD8I2xogQ57ZMuTeJwP7S pJv0+flthtf7TlcpLZRW3zt2CP5m8S2dIK7a31Z43ZJAyzDkhdXFAthJ7H/B7U8z q+Yq3j9SwmRQKGMgGkqdoWKl46cOy8Nc4WY8lM+13lZFEc019EBl2iB6a9M1bpTp yyu6BZgz01XSx7rsj6KorakTo6oR+cN984cccUaBiz8GFHBmW3A4dbJRKWrvIWYa 3n6FlMdvkgV9oIOZ+MaAPche3hMhSCWWEzwCC9W8TCe0Wm6gW/boGHGgqRslpvXr DztOYSmOI6hKHDg+4iKDZbWPgPxyUw== =J3rT -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- --=-UMt3Bf3NSJU5CTs9Rs0R--